Regione Umbria
Download
1 / 35

Regione Umbria Dept of Environment, Territory and Infrastructures Division of Land Defence, Quarries, Mines and Mineral - PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 118 Views
  • Uploaded on

Regione Umbria Dept of Environment, Territory and Infrastructures Division of Land Defence, Quarries, Mines and Mineral Waters. Rainfall-runoff models for the activities of the regional warning centre (first applications).

loader
I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
capcha
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about 'Regione Umbria Dept of Environment, Territory and Infrastructures Division of Land Defence, Quarries, Mines and Mineral ' - kieu


An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript
Slide1 l.jpg

Regione UmbriaDept of Environment, Territory and InfrastructuresDivision of Land Defence, Quarries, Mines and Mineral Waters

Rainfall-runoff models for the activities of the regional warning centre

(first applications)

Nicola Berni, Angelo Viterbo, Claudia Pandolfo, Marco Stelluti, Luca Brocca

Workshop on Rainfall – Runoff and regional models

Sofia, Bulgaria 9 - 11 July 2007

FLOODMED

Monitoring, forecasting and best practices

for FLOOD Mitigation and prevEntion

in the CADSES region


Pp6 umbria region italy role on floodmed project l.jpg
PP6 (Umbria region – Italy) role on FLOODMED project:

  • Provide hydrometeorological data from the regional real time operating network for model calibration (Actions 2.2, 2.3, 2.5, 3.1)

  • In this action we just would like to give a contribution about our first applications about rainfall – runoff models implemented for warning purposes in a sub-basin of the Tiber river Floodmed pilot area


Regional centri funzionali functional centers and national warning system l.jpg

Ø

OBSERVATION

Ø

NOW-CASTING

Prevenzione

and control

management

Monitoring

Gestione della

Previsional

emergency

prevention

del rischio

emergenza

risk

PHASE 1

PHASE 2

PHASE 3

PHASE 4

FUNCTIONAL

CENTERS

NATIONAL WARNING SYSTEM

CIVIL PROTECTION

REAL TIME

Regional “Centri Funzionali” (Functional Centers) and National Warning System


Slide4 l.jpg

LSPP control

Meteo predictions

Predicted Ground Effects for the following day

Precipitation observed in previous days

Evaluation tables


Slide5 l.jpg

Italian National network of Functional Centers

25 FC (central, regional)

2 CFC – “Central”

(DPC , APAT – Roma)

21 CFD – “Regional”

2 CFS – “Service”

(CAE – Bologna; ACROTEC - Savona)


Slide6 l.jpg

Italian National network of Functional Centers

fully operating * 9

  • Fully operating for DPC of Rome

  • CFD Province Autonome Trento e Bolzano

  • CFD regionali:

  • Piemonte, Lombardia, Liguria, Emilia Romagna, Toscana, Marche, Campania

Not yet fully operating

* Update at june 2007


Slide7 l.jpg

Umbrian Functional Center

  • December 2006: conclusion of new office civil and plants works, logistics, personnel definition;

  • March 2007: beginning of activities related to the definition of the procedures, scientific and technical work.

  • June 2007:political inauguration and official start-up.


Data acquisition and collection l.jpg
Data acquisition and collection

  • Real time acquisition of:

  • LAM models from CF Emilia Romagna and Toscana;

  • Hydrometeorological data from the whole central Italy networks (Arno and Tiber rivers);

  • Meteosat second generation images;

  • Meteo Radar data (this autumn);

  • Quasi static data collection of:

  • GIS themes on hydrogeologic risk matters;

  • Cartography at different scales;

  • Planning studies related to flooding areas mapping;

  • Flood lamination plan (dam managing during severe events);

  • Hydrologic and hydraulic studies in general.


Rainfall runoff models main issues l.jpg
Rainfall – runoff models: Main issues

For the activities of our regional warning centre we need simple models, robust, with few parameters but able to forecast quickly mainly time to peak and peak discharges

Dilemma:

Is it better to develop “home made” codes or adopt commercial or free to use tools continuously updated and tested?


Available forecasting tools operating nowadays l.jpg
Available forecasting tools operating nowadays

Mathematical models running:

  • X_Nash;

  • Mike DRiFt + Mike 11 HD mod;

  • Hec-HMS + Hec-RAS;

  • Mobidic;

  • STAFOM (CNR-IRPI);

On-line with real time data

V

V

RR models

Not yet

V

routing model

Not yet


Slide11 l.jpg

Why we have chosen these models?

  • DRiFt and HMS are common event-bases models quite easy to use;

  • Mobidic is a distributed physically-based continuous model developed by Florence University and usefully adopted by Tuscan Functional Center from 2002.


Hec hms l.jpg
Hec - HMS

  • Most of the rainfall-runoff and routing models included in HEC-HMS are:

  • mainly event models;

  • mainly lumped;

  • deterministic;

  • both empirical and conceptual models.


Slide13 l.jpg

For precipitation-runoff-routing simulation, HEC-HMS provides the following components:

• Precipitation-specification options which can describe an observed

(historical) precipitation event, a frequency-based hypothetical precipitation

event, or a event that represents the upper limit of precipitation possible at a

given location.

• Loss models which can estimate the volume of runoff, given the precipitation and properties of the watershed.

• Direct runoff models that can account for overland flow, storage and energy losses as water runs off a watershed and into the stream channels.

• Hydrologic routing models that account for storage and energy flux as water moves through stream channels.

• Models of naturally occurring confluences and bifurcations.

Models of water-control measures, including diversions and storage

facilities.


Slide14 l.jpg

HEC-HMS also includes: provides the following components:

• A distributed runoff model for use with distributed precipitation data, such as the data available from weather radar.

• A continuous soil-moisture-accounting model used to simulate the long-term response of a watershed to wetting and drying.

• An automatic calibration package that can estimate certain model parameters and initial conditions, given observations of hydrometeorological conditions.

• Links to a database management system that permits data storage, retrieval and connectivity with other analysis tools available from HEC and other sources.


Mike drift l.jpg
Mike DRiFt provides the following components:

  • DRiFt is a linear, semi-distributed model with constant parameters entirely developed by an Italian research institute (CIMA of Genova);

  • It’s implemented by DHI among the available hydrologic models of MIKE 11 from rel. 2005;

  • Uses a Time Variant Unit Hydrograph (TVUH) approach;

  • It can be easily coupled with HD Mike 11 module.


Slide16 l.jpg

3 modules: provides the following components:

Dreainage network estimation

Concentration times for each cell

Effective rainfall


Slide17 l.jpg

5 parameters: provides the following components:

k, ASk

vh, vc

SCS-CN


Slide18 l.jpg

Concentration time distribution: provides the following components:


Slide20 l.jpg

Mobidic provides the following components:

The model MOBIDIC (MOdello di Bilancio Idrologico DIstribuito e Continuo – Distributed and Continuous Model for the Hydrological Balance) is used for the hydrological forecast and monitoring at the Tuscan Functional Center.

The model was developed in cooperation with the University of Florence.

MOBIDIC is a physically-based model that allows the estimation of the components of the hydrologic balance in the subsurface layer, the soil-vegetation system and surface water bodies.

The hydrological balance can then be run in realtime or deferred mode with the desired spatial and temporal resolution.


Slide21 l.jpg

In MOBIDIC, the spatial domain for the computation of the hydrological processes is represented with an horizontal discretization of the basin in square cell with arbitrary size and a vertical discretization into 5 layers:

1) vegetation, 2) surface reservoirs (rivers, lakes, artificial basins) , 3) gravitational soil 4) capillary soil 5)groundwater

In the representation of physical processes, the main innovations concern the coupling of the water balance in soil and vegetation with surface energy balance (to the benefit of evapotranspiration computation and use of remotely sensed maps of Land Surface Temperature for calibration and validation) and the detailed interaction between ground water and surface water bodies.


Slide22 l.jpg

The states computed by the model are hydrological processes is represented with an horizontal discretization of the basin in square cell with arbitrary size and a vertical discretization into 5 layers: soil water content, hydrological and energy balance components (evapotranspiration, soil temperature) and discharge in each branch of the river network (including minor branches).


Slide23 l.jpg

At the Functional Center, MOBIDIC is run in hydrological processes is represented with an horizontal discretization of the basin in square cell with arbitrary size and a vertical discretization into 5 layers: realtime mode, fed by the data from the hydrometeorological network (every 30 minutes) and Quantitative Precipitation Forecasts from 4 different meteorological models.

Also through a web interface, the user can query the main discharge stations and view the predicted discharges assuming different predicted rainfall.


Slide24 l.jpg

Valore massimo previsto e ora prevista di raggiungimento hydrological processes is represented with an horizontal discretization of the basin in square cell with arbitrary size and a vertical discretization into 5 layers:

2° threshold value

6.43 (02:48 gg/mm)

1° threshold value

Predicted levels

Observed levels

Predicted rainfall with LAMI

Observed rainfall

DWD

WRF


Slide25 l.jpg

Internet experimental web page (Umbria region FC) hydrological processes is represented with an horizontal discretization of the basin in square cell with arbitrary size and a vertical discretization into 5 layers:


Case study upper tiber catchment at p felcino l.jpg
Case study: hydrological processes is represented with an horizontal discretization of the basin in square cell with arbitrary size and a vertical discretization into 5 layers: upper Tiber catchment at P.Felcino

3 stream gauge (along the main channel); 8 for tributaries;

11 raingauges

GOOD amount of data (GIS layers, DEM, meteo stations, rating curves, etc.)


Flooding events considered l.jpg
Flooding events considered hydrological processes is represented with an horizontal discretization of the basin in square cell with arbitrary size and a vertical discretization into 5 layers:

6 calibrating events

1 test events (the most important one of November 2005)


Hms calibration l.jpg
HMS calibration hydrological processes is represented with an horizontal discretization of the basin in square cell with arbitrary size and a vertical discretization into 5 layers:

6 calibrating events

Parameters:

Lag

CN

Ia


Hms calibration29 l.jpg
HMS calibration hydrological processes is represented with an horizontal discretization of the basin in square cell with arbitrary size and a vertical discretization into 5 layers:

  • Good estimation of the dynamic aspects (Lag);

  • Critical aspect (usually for the majority of Mediterranean catchments): AMC correct assessment (API doesn’t work well!);

DRifT calibration

  • Good estimation of the dynamic aspects (more difficulties related to the number of parameters to calibrate with no automatic calibration routine);

  • same critical aspect about AMC assessment.


Mobidic validation l.jpg
Mobidic “validation” hydrological processes is represented with an horizontal discretization of the basin in square cell with arbitrary size and a vertical discretization into 5 layers:

  • Parameters NOT CALIBRATED yet;

  • (Just fed with real time data with quite short time series);


Test event november 2005 l.jpg
Test event: November 2005 hydrological processes is represented with an horizontal discretization of the basin in square cell with arbitrary size and a vertical discretization into 5 layers:

MAIN STATISTICS


Conclusions 1 2 l.jpg
Conclusions 1/2 hydrological processes is represented with an horizontal discretization of the basin in square cell with arbitrary size and a vertical discretization into 5 layers:

  • All the shown models, thus after first quick applications, gave quite good results for warning purposes;

  • HMS and DRiFt produced similar results on simulating observed hydrographs in terms of time to peak and peak discharge value;

  • Very good results were linked to the estimation of time to peak value;

  • Better results (discharge peak value) depend very strongly on initial moisure conditions (AMC): it will be useful to find other indicators (BFI, etc.);


Conclusions 2 2 l.jpg
Conclusions 2/2 hydrological processes is represented with an horizontal discretization of the basin in square cell with arbitrary size and a vertical discretization into 5 layers:

  • Continuous models could solve these problems;

  • Calibration of Mobidic continuous model can produce for Umbrian Tiber river, such as for Tuscan Arno river, good operative results;

  • HEC-HMS, for the simplicity of use and calibration of parameters, for the fact that it’s free of charge and worldwide used, seems to be a good “parallel” tool for warning purposes.


Work to do l.jpg
Work to do hydrological processes is represented with an horizontal discretization of the basin in square cell with arbitrary size and a vertical discretization into 5 layers:

  • Implementation of the models within a distributed- semidistributed framework, and link with hydraulic models for the main Tiber river;

  • Feed all available RR models automatically from real time data (on-line continuous working);

  • Implement continuous HEC-HMS for AMC good estimates;

  • Continue the comparison between HEC-HMS and MIKE-DRifT;

  • Calibration of Mobidic;

  • (and much more…)


Slide35 l.jpg

Thank you hydrological processes is represented with an horizontal discretization of the basin in square cell with arbitrary size and a vertical discretization into 5 layers: