1 / 17

Social Theory: Collective Memory

Social Theory: Collective Memory. Bin Xu Assistant Professor of Sociology and Asian Studies Florida International University. What is a Nation?. Mnemonic Communities: Nations. Ernest Renan. “What is a Nation?” (1882) Purpose of the piece: to challenge the idea of race-based nation

kevlyn
Download Presentation

Social Theory: Collective Memory

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Social Theory: Collective Memory Bin Xu Assistant Professor of Sociology and Asian Studies Florida International University

  2. What is a Nation?

  3. Mnemonic Communities: Nations • Ernest Renan. “What is a Nation?” (1882) • Purpose of the piece: to challenge the idea of race-based nation • Political dimension of this purpose

  4. Ernest Renan. “What is a Nation?” • “A nation is a soul, a spiritual principle.” • Two thing constitute the soul: shared past; willingness to live together in the present. • Influence: civic nationalism • Problems: 1) separatism?; 2) forced forgetting?

  5. Anthony Smith. The Ethnic Origins of Nations • Primordialism and modernism • Smith’s ethnie concept

  6. Anthony Smith. The Ethnic Origins of Nations • The central role of myths and memories in ethnie: • A collective name • A common myth of descent • A shared history: A distinctive shared culture • An association with a specific territory • A sense of solidarity

  7. Anthony Smith. The Ethnic Origins of Nations • Full and empty pastrediscovery and reconstruction • Landscape and myth: • Poetic space: sacred sites of memory • Common elements of a national myth: origins in time; origins in space; ancestry; migration; liberation; the golden age (heroes); decline; rebirth

  8. American National Myth • A myth of origins in time • A myth of origins in space • A myth of ancestry • A myth of migration • A myth of liberation • A myth of the golden age • A myth of decline • A myth of rebirth

  9. Recovered Roots: the Zionist Reconstruction of the Past

  10. Masada • http://www.mordagan.com/links/masada/ • 3 years of resistance (70 • Josephus’s narrative of Masada: collective suicide. • The Book of Jossipon(around 10th century)

  11. Rediscovery of Masada • Revived interest in Masada (and Josephus) in the late 19th century • 1927 poem Masada • 3 aspects of the national myth of Masada: • A powerful story • A challenging site • Interesting archaeological remains • Archaeological excavation (20:00): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-8e0VjsLZjE

  12. The Myth of Masada • “Masada is a symbol. Masada is a guideline. Masada is longing. Masada is a loud cry. Masada is a tower of light…Masada is a symbol of Jewish and human heroism in all its greatness.” (p.68) • Continuity between the Antiquity and modern State of Israel • Selective representations: downplaying the suicide; highlighting readiness to die.

  13. Masada and the Holocaust • Heroism vs. disgrace; heroes vs. victims • The suicide theme reemerged as a heroic narrative • “The Masada of Warsaw” (Jewish Ghetto uprisings in 1942-1943)

  14. Mnemonic Practices • New commemorative rituals: reading Josephus • Youth pilgrimage: since the pre-state period • Challenging physical conditions • Demanding activities • Group solidarity • Climbing up as a patriotic ritual

  15. The state’s sponsorship • 1969 reburial service of remains of 27 excavated defenders • The state’s control of the site • Ceremonial events • New infrastructures (roads, cable car, stairs, hostels)

  16. Changing Memories of Masada • Since the 1960s: Masada and the Holocaust (victimhood emphasized) • The image of besieged Masada as a symbol of Israel (Yom Kippur War in 1973) • Masada and the Holocaust coexist in Israel’s contemporary commemorative culture

  17. Historical debates • Historical facts vs. stories • Jewish tradition: collective suicide is not glorified • Legal debate: suicide or murder or martyrdom • “The Masada complex” (hard-lined stance without compromise; particularly after the 1967 Six-Day War)

More Related