1 / 24

Collateral Considerations

Collateral Considerations. Managing Collateral Amounts and Instruments in Today's Insurance Market. Collateral Considerations. SPEAKERS: Raymond J. Rocchio, Jr. , Vice President – Specialty Markets, The PMA Insurance Group

Download Presentation

Collateral Considerations

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.


Presentation Transcript

  1. Collateral Considerations Managing Collateral Amounts and Instruments in Today's Insurance Market

  2. Collateral Considerations SPEAKERS: • Raymond J. Rocchio, Jr.,Vice President – Specialty Markets, The PMA Insurance Group • Lisa K. Wall,CPA, CPCU, ARM, Senior Vice President – Captive Consulting, Lockton Companies • Hugh Barit, Chairman & CEO, PRP Performa Limited MODERATOR: • Thomas R. McMahon, B. Comm, FCA, President, Cedar Management Limited

  3. Agenda • Purpose of Collateral • Collateral Components • Collateral Determination • Loss Estimate • Stacking Principle • Credit Analysis • Carrier Rating • Collateral Documentation • Collateral Instrument • Deductible Programs • Captive Reimbursement • Recent Developments • Investment Considerations

  4. Purpose of Collateral • Statutory Requirements/Benefits • Rating Agency Considerations • Mandate to Pay Claims • Non Admitted Reinsurance

  5. Collateral Components Insurance Company’s collateral requirement is based on three components: • Estimated deductible losses for the applicable policy periods • Actuarially determined • Based on insured’s own experience, if credible • Financial strength of insured • Strong insured credit ratings allow for unsecured credits • Poor credit ratings may result in surcharged requirement • Each carrier has its own criteria and process • Collateral instrument to be provided • Letters of credit are preferred • Other forms may preclude credits earned on financial strength Loss Estimate (Exposure) Credit Analysis (Financial Strength) Instrument

  6. Collateral Determination • Financial Exposure Analysis • Line of Business, Severity, Predictability, Form of Security • Financial Statement Analysis • Combining the Two • What is the “Loan”?

  7. Collateral DeterminationLoss Estimate • Aggregate Limits • A Cap on a Policy’s Reimbursement Obligation • Specific Limits • A Cap on One Loss’ Reimbursement Obligation • Reimbursed Losses/Expenses • Line of Business Considerations • Tail • Payout Pattern • Development Factors

  8. Loss Estimate – Cumulative Collateral Requirement Stacking Principle No Growth vs. 10% Growth

  9. Collateral DeterminationCredit Analysis Balance Sheet • List of Assets and How they are Financed • Focus on Trends • Assets • Asset Quality • Accounts Receivable • Inventory • Intangibles • Current Assets • Fixed Assets • Age • Depreciation Methodologies • Replacement Requirements

  10. Collateral DeterminationCredit Analysis Balance Sheet • Liabilities • Current Liabilities • Long -Term Debt • Equity • Paid in Capital • Retained Earnings • Tangible vs. Intangible • Working Capital • Current Assets Less Current Liabilities

  11. Collateral DeterminationCredit Analysis Income Statement • Focus on Trends • Revenues • Operating Income • One Time Gains/Losses • Net Income • Retained Earnings • Dividends

  12. Collateral DeterminationCredit Analysis Cash Flow Statement • Hardest Statement to Falsify • Must Tie to Balance Sheet • How Cash is Generated; How it is Utilized • How Operations are Financed • Focus on Trends

  13. Collateral DeterminationCredit Analysis Cash Flow Statement • Operating Cash Flow • Net Income • Non-Cash Expenses • Changes in Working Capital Items • Investing Cash Flow • Fixed Asset Purchases/Sales • Securities Purchases/Sales • Financing Cash Flow • New Borrowings • Debt Repayments • Dividends • Shareholder Withdrawals

  14. Collateral DeterminationCredit Analysis Footnotes • Banking Relationships • Debt Secured/Unsecured • Interest Rate • Payback Period • Covenants • Credit Line – Letters of Credit • Asset Quality • Accounts Receivable • Inventory • Intangibles • Litigation/Contingencies • Subsequent Events • Environmental Exposure • Sales Backlog • Significant Customers/Suppliers • Off Balance Sheet Transactions • Affiliates • Officers • Guaranties • Accounting Methodologies • Inventory • Depreciation • Bad Debt Allowance • Managing Results

  15. Collateral DeterminationCredit Analysis Ratios • Liquidity • Current Ratio • Current Assets/Current Liabilities • Quick Ratio • Working Capital • Solvency • Debt/Equity • Long -Term Debt/Equity • Profitability • Operating Income/Sales • Net Income/Sales • Cash Flow • Time Interest Earned • Debt Service Coverage

  16. Collateral DeterminationCredit Analysis Underwriting Risk High Financial Risk Low

  17. Collateral DeterminationCredit Analysis • Consistent Methodology Over Time • Establish Collateral Requirement • Amount • Equal to Loss Exposure • Surcharge • Discount • Why?

  18. Collateral DeterminationCredit Analysis – Carrier Rating Credit rating and unsecured balance varies by Insurance Carrier

  19. Collateral Documentation • Security Agreements • Language Requirements • Clean, Irrevocable, Evergreen • Benefits Clients Who Have Provided Collateral • Events of Default • Remedies • Documents collateral review timing and minimum parameters

  20. Deductible Programs Claimants/ State Carrier Evidence of Coverage Credit Risk Deductible Reimbursement Insured

  21. Deductible Programs with Captive Reimbursement Insurance Company • Issues deductible policy to Insured • Requires an Indemnity Agreement from Insured and collateral for deductible obligation • Insured • Pays Insurance Company premium for large deductible program • Promises to reimburse for losses Insured Insurance Company 1. 3. 2. Insurance Company • Insurance Company allows TPA to manage and pay claims • Obligated for Insured’s losses within the deductible • Credit exposure for Insured’s losses within the deductible • Collateral required to secure future obligations *Captive TPA *Insurance Company has no contractual relationship with the Captive Insured • Contracts with Captive via deductible reimbursement policy • Transfer deductible obligation for a premium

  22. Recent Collateral Developments • Letters of credit are more desired by insurers than ever. • Alternative collateral instruments have been less frequently and less favorably accepted in the last 12 months. • Insurance Companies in general have increased the surcharge (provided less unsecured credit) for trusts and accept bonds on a very limited basis. • Select Insurance Companies are having capacity issues with select banks. • List of acceptable banks are dwindling due to rating downgrades and consolidations. • Unencumbered verifiable asset-backed letters of credit capacity is available.

  23. Collateral Instrument Trusts Letters of Credit (LCs) Surety Cash

  24. Investment Considerations Making the Right Choice • If the captive has a considerable amount of “free funds” and a longer term investment horizon, then LOC makes more sense. • Important that bank is comfortable with underlying collateral and are seen to be in the LOC business for the long term. • If a trust is the answer, make sure that excess funds can be withdrawn from the trust effectively.

More Related