An Optical Search for Small Comets
Download
1 / 31

An Optical Search for Small Comets R. L. Mutel & J.D. Fix University of Iowa - PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 68 Views
  • Uploaded on

An Optical Search for Small Comets R. L. Mutel & J.D. Fix University of Iowa. Small Comet Detection Papers. DE-1 (April 1986). Polar (May 1997). Small Comet Scenario (From L. Frank Website). Small Comet Parameters (from Frank and Sigwarth 1993, Small comet Web site)

loader
I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
capcha
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about 'An Optical Search for Small Comets R. L. Mutel & J.D. Fix University of Iowa' - kacia


An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript
An optical search for small comets r l mutel j d fix university of iowa

An Optical Search for Small Comets

R. L. Mutel & J.D. Fix

University of Iowa


An optical search for small comets r l mutel j d fix university of iowa

Small Comet Detection Papers

DE-1 (April 1986)

Polar (May 1997)


Small comet scenario from l frank website
Small Comet Scenario(From L. Frank Website)


An optical search for small comets r l mutel j d fix university of iowa

Small Comet Parameters

(from Frank and Sigwarth 1993, Small comet Web site)

Mass: 20,000 – 40,000 kg

Size: 4 – 10 m

Density: ~ 0.1 x H20

Number density: (3 ± 1) · 10-11 km-3

Flux at Earth: 1 every 3 seconds (107 per yr.)

Composition: Water ice with very dark mantle (albedo 0.01-0.02)

Orbit: Confined to ecliptic, prograde

Speed: ~10 km-sec-1 at 1 a.u.

Origin: Hypothesized comet belt beyond Neptune



An optical search for small comets r l mutel j d fix university of iowa

  • Observations

  • The observations were made using the 0.5 m f/8 reflector of the Iowa Robotic Observatory between 24 September 1998 and 11 June 1999.

  • Observations were scheduled every month within one week of new moon. A total of 6,148 images were obtained, of which 2,718 were classified as category A (visual detection magnitude 16.5 or brighter in a 100 pixel trail).

  • Seeing conditions varied from 2 - 5 arcsec (see histogram). For quality A images, seeing was < 3.5 arcsec.

  • All images were has thermal and bias corrections applied.

  • Images were recorded on CDROM and sent to the University of Iowa for analysis.

  • All images are available for independent analysis via anonymous ftp at node atf.physics.uiowa.edu.





Visual magnitude calibration using standard stars adu counts vs v fwhm

FWHM = 2.8"

FWHM = 4.2"

Visual Magnitude Calibration using Standard Stars:ADU counts vs. V, FWHM

16.7

15.6

17.1


Visual magnitude detection vs trail length 20 april 1999 60 s fixed 30 pixel trailed

16.7

17.1

17.1

15.6

16.7

Visual Magnitude Detection vs. Trail Length(20 April 1999, 60 s: fixed & 30 pixel trailed


Example of trails caused by cosmic rays geostationary satellite

Cosmic Ray

Example of Trails Caused by Cosmic Rays, Geostationary Satellite


An optical search for small comets r l mutel j d fix university of iowa

V = 16.4

39 pixels

Visual Detection Calibration Using Synthetic Trails

  • Synthetic comet trails were added to 520 search images with randomly chosen magnitudes and trail lengths.

  • Three observers independently inspected all images

  • Result: Visual detection threshold is ~0.9  per pixel, with a suggestion that longer trails can be detected slightly fainter, perhaps 0.7 - 0.8 .


An optical search for small comets r l mutel j d fix university of iowa

V = 16.6

103 pixels

V = 16.4

39 pixels

V = 15.1

417 pixels

Sample Synthetic Comet Calibration Images


Synthetic comet trail nearing limiting magnitude v 17 0

V = 17.0

124 pixels

Synthetic Comet Trail Nearing Limiting Magnitude (V=17.0)


Calculation of sampled volume

Observer

r-

r+

Calculation of Sampled Volume

1.Sampled volume as function of trail length L, field of view  :

2.Use faintest visual magnitude vs. trail length from synthetic comet test (60 s,  = 17 ADU  = 3.5"):

3. Detection volume as a function of visual magnitude (mv), speed (vobj ):



Detection probability per image assumes n sc 3x10 11 km 3
Detection Probability Per Image(assumes nsc = 3x10-11 km-3)


Upper limit to small comet number density 99 confidence level
Upper Limit to Small Comet Number Density (99% confidence level)

Rejected density region

0.05 n0

Allowed density region


Probability of non detection vs number density n 2 713 no detections n 0 3 10 11 km 3
Probability of Non-detection vs. Number Density(N=2,713, no detections, n0 = 310-11 km-3)

n = 0.05  n0

n = 0.25  n0



Comparison with previous searches detection magnitude comparison
Comparison with Previous Searches:Detection magnitude comparison

1. Visual magnitude m correction for distance (55,000 km vs. 137,000 km) is 2.0 magnitudes.

2a. Visual magnitude m as function of solar phase angle , scattering parameter Q, phase function () [Lumme & Bowell 1981]:

2b. Best fit phase function for solar system objects is:

2c. For Q ~ 0, magnitude difference between previous searches (fixed phase angle 20) and present search (4<  < 9 ) is:


Multiple scattering factor q versus albedo for solar system objects from lumme bowell aj 86 1705
Multiple Scattering Factor Q versus Albedo for Solar System Objects(from Lumme & Bowell AJ 86, 1705)

Asteroids

Planets, Satellites

Small comet albedo range


An optical search for small comets r l mutel j d fix university of iowa

Phase angle versus local time for IRO search

8 average solar phase angle

Midnight

6 am/pm


An optical search for small comets r l mutel j d fix university of iowa

Q = 0.3

Q = 0.6

Q = 0.0

Magnitude difference between IRO search and previous searches at fixed  = 20

0.54


An optical search for small comets r l mutel j d fix university of iowa

V=16.5

Implications for Physical Characteristics of Small Comets

The magnitude limit can be converted to limits on the physical properties of small comets. Assuming a single scattering function Q = 0 and and a mean solar phase angle of 8°, the allowed range of geometrical albedo and density for a mass of 20,000 kg (Frank et al. 1990) is shown below.

V=16.0

Permitted Region

Forbidden Region

Darkest solar system objects (Iapetus)

Darkest part of Halley nucleus


An optical search for small comets r l mutel j d fix university of iowa

Density 0.1 x H2O

Frank et al. (1990) estimated mass range

V = 16.5

V = 17.0

Physical Conditions of Small Comets

Alternatively, assuming a mass density of 0.1 gm-cm-3 (e.g. Frank and Sigwarth 1993), the mass-albedo allowed range is shown below.


An optical search for small comets r l mutel j d fix university of iowa

  • Summary

  • We have conducted an extensive optical search for small comets proposed by Frank et al. (1986; Frank & Sigwarth 1997,1999).

  • After careful visual inspection of more than 2,700 images, we found no objects consistent with small comets. The detection limit depends on magnitude and trail length: e.g. for V = 16.5, trail lengths up to 120 pixels are robustly detected.

  • These results strongly disagree with previous optical searches of Yeates (1989) and Frank et al. (1990). Extrapolation of their detections to our search predicts more than 60 detections brighter than V = 16.5.

  • The null detections place an upper limit to the number density

    n < 0.05 (99% confidence)

    of the value claimed by Frank and Sigwarth (1990).

  • Any object with mass M = 20,000 kg and fainter than the magnitude-trail length limit must have either:

    • An implausibly low geometric albedo (p<0.01)

      or

    • Density greater than ice ( > 1 gm/cm3).