1 / 23

CHAPTER 19 Nationalizing, Expropriation, and Privatization

CHAPTER 19 Nationalizing, Expropriation, and Privatization. Theories Relating to Takings of Foreign Property. Traditional theory: prohibition of all takings. Modern-Traditional theory: “prompt, adequate and effective” compensation for all takings.

joyce
Download Presentation

CHAPTER 19 Nationalizing, Expropriation, and Privatization

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. CHAPTER 19 Nationalizing, Expropriation, and Privatization

  2. Theories Relating to Takings of Foreign Property • Traditional theory: prohibition of all takings. • Modern-Traditional theory: “prompt, adequate and effective” compensation for all takings. • Non-Western theories: State has sovereign right to take, based on the Calvo Doctrine: sovereign placed ahead of foreign investor.

  3. Theories Relating to Takings of Foreign Property • Calvo rejected the modern-traditional theory’s prerequisites: Public Purpose and Non-Discrimination. • But sovereign rights states do take property based on “public purpose”. • Nationalization: taking an entire industry e.g. steel. • Expropriation: taking a single company.

  4. INA Corp. v. Islamic Republic of Iran • INA Corp. v. Islamic Republic of Iran: INA acquired a 20% share of an Iranian insurance co. In 1979 Iran passed a law of Nationalization. INA sought the value of its shares with interests and costs from the Iran-US Claims Tribunal. • The Tribunal awarded what INA was seeking. • Why? What factors were weighed? • What did the Tribunal say about nationalizations of a “lawful” character?

  5. Creeping Expropriation • Gradual erosion of value. • Discriminatory taxes. • Price controls. • License cancellation.

  6. Guarding Against Political Risk • U.S. investors in countries that once held sovereign rights theory, is now at risk from raw political power. • Political Risk Insurance. • Government: OPIC, MIGA • Private: insurance syndicates.

  7. Resolving Disputes with Foreign Nations • Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act. • Generally the state is immune from suit • Exceptions: waiver, commercial activity and noncommercial torts. • In light of terrorism, Congress amended the FSIA to allow U.S. citizens to bring suit against the sovereign for state sponsored acts of terrorism. 

  8. Resolving Disputes with Foreign Nations: FSIA • Saudi Arabia v. Nelson: FSIA warrants dismissal of the case brought by a former U.S. employee of a Saudi hospital. Supreme Court ruled that Nelsons could not bring suit in US court over actions in Saudi Arabia.

  9. Resolving Disputes with Foreign Nations: Act of State Doctrine • Even if court can hear case under FSIA, investor must still move past Act of State doctrine, a shield to prosecution. • Prevents court from passing on the validity of a foreign government’s action.

  10. Resolving Disputes: Act of State Doctrine • W.S. Kirkpatrick v. Environmental Tectronics Corp. • Case allowed to go forward because it involved the successful bidder and the unsuccessful bidder on a government contract and only tangentially brings in government’s action. • Act of State would not be an obstacle when there is a treaty applicable to investors. • Act of State also has commercial activity exception.

  11. International Adjudication • National Thermal Power Corp v. The Singer Co.: foreign investor failed to structure a contract that allowed binding arbitration under local law. • International Center for the Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID). • Arbitration. • What is the role of a BIT treaty? • Insurance.

  12. Preparation for Privatization • Creation of an Independent Government Corporation. • Preparation of a Legal System for Privatization. • “Clearing” of any expropriation claims. • Development of property rights and contract law. • China, Russia, East Germany examples.

  13. Methods of Distribution • Assets are transferred to new entity, run as private entity during transition. • Private and public equity placements. • Voucher systems. • Debt-for-Equity swaps.

  14. Models of Privatization • Sale of a Noncontrolling Interest (Partial Sale). • Advantage: simple • Disadvantage: depends upon perspective. • Lack of control, conflicting interests (full employment v. efficiency), may not invest in what can’t be controlled. 

  15. Partial Sale Assets NewCompany Government Shares(100%) NewOperator $ Shares Shares Shares GeneralPublic Underwriters Shares LocalGovernment

  16. Trade Sale NewOperating & InvestmentGroup Shares $ Assets NewCompany Government $ • Stock or Asset “trade” sale. • Advantages: speedy, useful in small enterprises. • Disadvantages: backlash, require capital infusion, conditions subsequent.

  17. The Sale to Employees • Similar to leveraged buyouts (LBO’s). • Advantages: gives government employees a stake in the outcome, may bring in labor unions. • Disadvantages: if management was poor- now they are owners, layoffs difficult. 

  18. The Sale to Employees ManagementorEmployees Assets Government $ NewCompany Shares Government $ EmploymentContract Waivers ManagementorEmployees

  19. Concessions: BOTs and BOOs • Two major types of concessions: BOT and BOO. • BOT: Build-Operate-Transfer. • BOO: Build-Operate-Own. • Government uses private sector to build infrastructure. • Joint venture: mix of trade sale and non- controlling interest model. • What about anticompetitive considerations?

  20. BOT Transaction Developer Contractor Banks ConstructionFees • Developer’s Fees • Equity Investment • Loans ConstructionContract Shares • Shares • Repayment • Equity Investment Concession Shares EquipmentManufacturer NewCompany Equity Investment Services Government Payment for Equipment Paymentfor Services Equipment Services Equity Investment • Paymentfor Services Operating Fees Shares Operating Agreement Operator Private Users

  21. Models in Combination: Joint Venture Privatization NewOperating & InvestmentGroup $ Assets NewCompany Government Shares(50%) Shares(50%) ShareholderAgreement

  22. Mixed Example Assets NewCompany Government Shares(40%) Shares(30%) Shares(10%) CapitalContribution Shares(50%) $ New LaborContract Waivers of Prior Obligations NewOperating & InvestmentGroup Underwriters Employees Shares(20%) Shares(30%) Paymentfor Shares Paymentfor Shares GeneralPublic

  23. Conclusion • Major issue for business in 21st century • Transition of nonmarket economies to market economies • Business must assess political risk and use contracts to protect interests • Consider arbitration clause

More Related