1 / 14

Prohibition versus Legalization

Prohibition versus Legalization. Do Economists Reach a Conclusion on Drug Policy? by Mark Thornton. What to do?. Keep current policy on drug prevention? Increase spending and efforts? Decriminalize and/or legalize drugs?. War on Drugs. Economists have at the forefront of the debate.

Download Presentation

Prohibition versus Legalization

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Prohibition versus Legalization Do Economists Reach a Conclusion on Drug Policy? by Mark Thornton

  2. What to do? • Keep current policy on drug prevention? • Increase spending and efforts? • Decriminalize and/or legalize drugs?

  3. War on Drugs • Economists have at the forefront of the debate. • Criticism of ineffectiveness • Unintended Consequences • Violent crime • Corruption of police • Corruption of public officials

  4. War on Drugs • Costs (2005): • US Gov’t cost report on drug control; $12b • In a separate US Gov’t report; • Incarceration: $30.1b • Police protection: $9.1b • Legal costs: $4.5b • State & Fed corrections: $11.0b • Total : $34.7

  5. Survey of Economists • 15% favored status quo • 21% favored increased efforts • 58% favored a change in policy • 71% favored legalization or decriminalization • <2% favored stiffer sentences and increased enforcement budgets

  6. Survey of Americans • 36% favored legalization or controlled distribution of most drugs • 40% believe decriminalization of cocaine would reduce violent crime • 3-1 margin preferred addiction treatment and counseling for drug users over fines and/or imprisonment

  7. Demographic Characteristics • Characteristic Reformers Prohibitionists • Sex Male Female • Race White Nonwhite • Education College or more Grade School • Occupation Professional/Farmer Clerical/manual • Income level High and Middle Low • Age Young and Middle 50+ years • Region Northeast and West South • Religion Jewish or none Protestant • Politics Independent Dem. and Rep.

  8. Positions Against • The permanent reduction in price caused by legalization is likely to have a substantial positive effect on use, particularly among the poor and young • Prohibition shows that the society can make a dent in the consumption of drugs through laws.

  9. Positions Against • The estimate of al the effects of drug use needs to be improved substantially before it can be determined whether the benefits outweigh the costs of decriminalization. • The elasticity of demand is not zero; • Decriminalization will sharply lower prices • Will lead to a noticeable increase in use of drugs, new users and addicts

  10. Positions For • Taxpayers, who are usually not associated with illegal drug activity, foot the bill of the war on drugs • Tax revenues from legalized drugs could fund drug education and rehab

  11. Positions For • Prohibition has, at least in part, led to; • Increase in street crime • Increase in gang activity • Police corruption • Congested courts • Overcrowded prisons • The repeal of alcohol prohibition led to the demise of bootleggers

  12. Conclusion • The general consensus among drug-policy researchers and economists is in opposition to prohibition • Still, only timidly in support of decriminalization and even more timidly in favor of legalization

  13. Conclusion • The ONLY feasible way to eliminate the black market for drugs is to legalize them • The legalization of drugs will lead to some, maybe different but nonetheless, problems • Much more research needs to be conducted before a legalization policy is enacted

  14. Work Cited • Thornton, Mark 2007. Prohibition versus legalization. The Independent Review, Winter 2007, pp417-433.

More Related