190 likes | 435 Views
Ideology. Background. An organized set of related ideas that modify one another Personal use: Helps us make sense of political questions Public use: Trying to attract allies to our position Major ideologies develop in Europe in 18 th and 19 th century What was life in medieval Europe like?
E N D
Background • An organized set of related ideas that modify one another • Personal use: Helps us make sense of political questions • Public use: Trying to attract allies to our position • Major ideologies develop in Europe in 18th and 19th century • What was life in medieval Europe like? • Bound to each other in systems of domination • Static
So What are the American Ideologies? • Liberal v. conservative in the American context
So What is Traditional Liberalism? • Invented by intellectuals • Limit power of nobility and church • High point of good society: • Ability of members to develop individual capacities to fullest extent • People must be responsible for their own actions • So what constitutes the liberal ideology? • Role for government? • Favor choice, not power
And Conservatism? • Defenders of existing social arrangements • Society is more than collection of individuals • Let people know where they stand relevant to each other • High point of good society: • Maintenance of ordered community and of common values • Power is binding • So what constitutes the conservative ideology? • Role for government?
And Socialism? • Working class tired of liberalism • Why? • More congenial to labor • How does it differ from liberalism? • Marx and classes • Marx’s view of history • How do communism and socialism differ? • Violence
Then We Have Fascists • Hitler, Mussolini, Franco • No major elaborations…why? • Glorify a mythical war-based society from the past • Opportunist • Violence and terror
And Now…The Dead White Guys • Plato • The Republic • Guardians • Aristotle • If unselfish… • But we are selfish… • St. Augustine • We need government because of human sin • Thomas Aquinas • Church v. Rulers • Machiavelli • Help kings resist the church • Ruthless and pragmatic—not sentiment or morality • Hobbes • State of nature • Leviathan
Background Typically, we do not think about ourselves in terms of the state to which we belong We pay more attention to central government as a result
Development • Idea of a state is fairly recent…early 19th Century • Even then, people were not really sold on the idea • Relatively large territory with stable boundaries, whose people were bound together by intricate political ties and thought of themselves distinctively in terms of the state to which they belonged • Napoleon and his role from 1800-1815
So Why Does it Develop? Industry and commercial arrangements It was a mutually dependent relationship, however
Public Goods Public goods Free-riders Role of the state PBS example
State v. Nation v. Nation-State • Nation • Large group of people who are bound together, and recognize a similarity among themselves, because of a common culture—a common language seems to be very important • State • Political unit that has ultimate sovereignty • Leaders try to link the two…why? • Nationalism • Where the two don’t link tend to be political hotspots • Quebec, Bangladesh, Basque, Belgium, PLO, Kurds, Chechnya, Darfur • Nation-States • Every state in the world tries to promote feelings of common nationhood among the people living within its boundaries
State-Building • Complicated! Not fun or easy! • See: Iraq • We sometimes end up with failed states • Geographic entities with no effective central state apparatus, but controlled by various warlords and gangs in loose and fluid relationships with one another • Afghanistan and Somalia
But What About Government? • When we talk about the actions of the state, we are referring to the government • Ultimate authority to act on behalf of the state • The Autonomous State • Government is a participant and claimant in politics • Relationship between state and society • Civil society
Challenges to the State • World leaders seem to be moving toward creating structures that would operate over a wider geographic range than the state • The EU • NAFTA • IMF • Ethnic and regional separatist movements • Buy why? • Environmental issues • Appropriate scale of industry has expanded • Clumsy in response to local problems
Alternatives • Regional integration? • The UN? • “World Culture” • International Law • Pinochet and Milosevic