250 likes | 348 Views
Explore educational research methodologies, problem-based learning, & theory evaluation in interactive course activities. Discover practical constraints, theories of action, and research topics for analysis.
E N D
EDUC 505.44 July 18, 2011
Agenda • Introductory activities • Course outline • Educators as researchers • World views • Problem based methodology • Choice of research topic • Application activity
Introductory activities • Who am I? • Who are you? • Who’s here? • Lie detector • Questions and concerns
Who are you? I teach in the Faculty of EducationatStFX: FL2 C&I, P&P, assessment (B.Ed.); research (M.Ed.) I workwithMi’kmaw-kina’tenewey staff on Mi’kmawlanguagelearning and revitalization. Anne Curry Collaborative self-study on assessment; study of Mi’kmawlanguage use in schools Read a master’sproject and thesis, mark researchassignments; takesome time off
Who are you? Whatyouteach or workat Somethingunexpected or unusual about yourwork or teaching Yourname Yourinvolvement in or witheducationalresearch Your plans for August
Data collection and analysis • What data do we have? • How canweorganize the data? • How canweinterpret the data?
Formation of base groups • P-3, 4-6, 7-9, 10-12, other • Geographicallydistributed (school) • Program (regular, FI, other) • Likenumbers / likewords • Variety in August activities
Questions and concerns • What questions do you have about the expectations of the course? • Whatconcerns or fears do you have about the course? • Writeeach question or concern on a separatepostit note • Place the postit notes in the basket • I willaddresseach of the questions / concernswith the class
Whatisresearch? • Research • … systematic, critical and self-criticalenquirywhichaims to contributetoward the advancement of knowledge and wisdom . • Educationalresearch • Criticalinquiryaimedatinformingeducationaljudgements and decisions in order to improveeducational action (Bussey, 1999, cited in Morrison, 2002)
Who are you as a researcher? • INDIVIDUALLY • Write 10 wordsthat come to mind as youthink about educationalresearch • IN YOUR GROUPS • Positivist / Post-positivist • Interpretivist • Critical / Participatory • Pragmatic
Check-in • How are thingsgoing?
Problem-basedmethodology • Whatis a practicalproblem? • How is the problemsolved? • How is the adequacy of the solution judged? • What type of relationshipfostersimproved solutions to problems? Wheredoes PBM fall in the world views table?
Problem-basedmethodology (PBM) • Whatis a practicalproblem? • How is the problemsolved? • How is the adequacy of the solution judged? • What type of relationshipfostersimproved solutions to problems?
PBM: The power of constraints • Whatis a constraint in PBM language? • Whymay a constraintbe consideredpositive? • What are the types of constraints? • Whatis a constraint set? • What causes tension amongconstraint sets? • Whatmay cause tension whenanalyzingconstraints?
PBM: Actionsintegrateconstraints and haveconsequences • How canconstraints influence actions? • What are the consequences of actions? • What are intended and unintendedconsequences?
PBM: Theories of action • Whatis the differencebetween an expousedtheory and a theory-in-use? • Whydoes a teacher-researcher have to consider the difference?
PBM: Guided practice • INDIVIDUALLYChoose an aspect of learning and teaching oral language • Whatisyourtheory of action? • Constraints • Actions • Consequences • BASE GROUP Shareyourtheories of action notingsimilarities and differences.
PBM: Evaluatingtheories of action Accuracy • Whatdoesaccuracymean in PBM language? • Whatdoesevaluatingaccuracysometimesreveal? • Whatmethodscanbeused to evaluateaccuracy? Effectiveness • Whatdoeseffectivenessmean in PBM language?
PBM: Evaluatingtheories of action Coherence • Whatdoescoherencemean in PBM language? • Can constraintsbechallenged? • Whatis unique about the coherencecriterion? Improvability • Whatdoesimprovabilitymean in PBM language? • Whatdoesthiscriterion encourage?
PBM: Alternatetheories of action • Whatis the potential of alternatetheories of action?
PBM: Guided practice • BASE GROUPChoose an espousedtheory of action about teaching and learning oral language • Evaluatethistheory of action • Accuracy • Effectiveness • Coherence • Improvability CONFIDENTIALITY!
Yourresearch question • « Pebble in yourshoe » • « One night stand »
PBM: Independent practice • INDIVIDUALLY Consider a potentialresearchtopic • Whatisyourcurrenttheory of action? • Constraints • Actions • Consequences • Whatfurther information do youneed? • How canyoufindit?
Let’s do someresearch! • BASE GROUP Choose a topic/situation related to oral language • Analyze the situation • Constraints • Actions • Consequences • Formulate a research question
Beforenext class READ Chapters 3 and 10 DO Q cards 1 and 2 • Chapters 1 & 2; chapters 3 & 10 Decide on yourresearchtopic • E-mail me Ethicsexercise