1 / 14

Meanings of Residential Security: A Perspective from Karachi

Meanings of Residential Security: A Perspective from Karachi. Haris Gazdar Collective for Social Science Research. Grades of citizenship. Citizens versus non-citizens Unequal citizens Effectively unequal citizens

inara
Download Presentation

Meanings of Residential Security: A Perspective from Karachi

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Meanings of Residential Security: A Perspective from Karachi Haris Gazdar Collective for Social Science Research

  2. Grades of citizenship • Citizens versus non-citizens • Unequal citizens • Effectively unequal citizens • Overlap between categories in case of marginalized irregular migrants, particularly non-citizens and effectively unequal citizens

  3. Grades in state and society

  4. Existing approaches to residential security • Legal: right to adequate housing • Administrative: focus on fixed abode • Economic: secure property and tenancy rights • Social: societal arrangements for access to land and housing – networks, patriarchy

  5. Karachi context • 13 million people, largest city of Pakistan, very ethnically diverse • Rapid growth since 1850s (pop 60,000) due to migration • Conflict-related displacement from outside: 1947, 1971, 1980s • Conflict-related displacement within: 1980s

  6. Quantitative versus qualitative understanding of “security” • Over two-thirds of families in Karachi report “owning” their homes • No clear estimates but at least half of these do not have individual title • Right of possession versus ownership and possession asserted politically • Half of city irregular or post hoc regularization – legacy of migration

  7. Vantage point • Analysis of statistical data • Research on range of localities across city, which started life as irregular settlements • Qualitative tools: oral histories, community histories, conflict and migration narratives • Community profiles: land, housing, amenities, interaction with state agencies, collective action

  8. Insights from qualitative research - 1 • Wide range of outcome in “irregular” settlements • Security of possession seen as key issue • Security from state – freedom from vulnerability to eviction • Security of contract – ability to transfer property rights • Both forms of security closely linked

  9. Insights from qualitative research - 2 • Informal provisioning dominates • Close link between informal and formal – city authorities and public utilities networked with informal providers • Non-state contract enforcement – legitimized violence • Importance of social and political networks in mobilization

  10. Perspective on residential security - 1 • Legal perspective – active where migrants or residentially vulnerable people are seen as political assets, or are socially connected. E.g property owning Muslim DPs from India, Afghan DPs in 1980s • Administrative perspective – two way relationship between residential security and other entitlements – KEY INSIGHT

  11. Perspective on residential security - 2 • Economic – frequency of transactions leads to security, but market is hierarchical, the most socially marginalized live in most insecure conditions, and often remain insecure • Social arrangements – these dominate, and ultimately citizenship rights are also endogenous

  12. Case 1: Natha Khan • Original indigenous Sindhis displaced and compensated by military in 1940s • Dominant group till 1960s when migrant Pashtuns with military connections arrived in large numbers • Violent conflict and tables turned • Pashtun segment regularized Sindhi segment still non-regularized

  13. Case 2: Lines Area • Military barracks turned over to 1947 migrant govt employees from India, other migrants settled in camps around • Frequent govt evictions from camps • Populist govt in 1970s declared amnesty • Militant ethnic group in 1980s carried out ethnic cleansing

  14. Case 3: Kausar Niazi Colony • Pashtun migrant set up camp on unused govt land, invited networks of Pashtun and Afghan nomadic families • Became local political activist linked to a party – and began marking and selling possession rights to plots • Regularization as a result of electoral promise

More Related