310 likes | 315 Views
POLITICAL CULTURE. THE AMERICAN DREAM. “I have a dream”. What is the American dream? “Now is the time to make real the promises of democracy. “ . The American Dream. Belief that widespread opportunity exists for individuals to work hard and succeed at what they choose
E N D
POLITICAL CULTURE THE AMERICAN DREAM
“I have a dream” • What is the American dream? • “Now is the time to make real the promises of democracy. “
The American Dream • Belief that widespread opportunity exists for individuals to work hard and succeed at what they choose • Associated with individualism, liberty, limited government, democracy, equality of opportunity, and capitalism • Every era redefines what these principles mean
Thoreau on Individualism • Individual liberty is at the heart of the American Dream • Henry David Thoreau: “Go confidently in the direction of your dreams. Live the life you've imagined.”
Competing Visions of American Dream White Nationalists in Charlottesville, VA 2017 Multiculturalism and Diversity
John Locke 1662-1704 • British writer during the Restoration • Developed idea of parliamentary democracy • Supported a constitutional monarchy • American Dream traces back to his Second Treatise of Government 1689
Locke’s State of Nature • Humans once existed in a state of nature prior to civil society and the rule of law • All humans in the state of nature have natural rights of life, liberty, property • State of nature was in general benign but “inconvenient” • People need a limited government to protect their rights from criminals, to provide defense from invasion, to settle disputes, and to enforce contracts
The Social Contract • People give up their unlimited rights in state of nature and agree to a government to protect their rights according to the rule of law • Legitimate government must be based on consent of the governed (majority rule) • Separate executive from legislature • Right of rebellion if government becomes oppressive
Declaration of Independence • Based upon Locke’s social contract theory • A list of grievances against the king • A defiant call to revolution • Writers included Jefferson, Adams, Franklin Roger Sherman and Robert Livingston
Declaration of Independence--Discussion • What principles are found in the Declaration of Independence?
Principles Expressed • Reason (Enlightenment value) • Equality (what kind of equality?) • Individual liberty • Natural Rights—note that the Declaration excludes Locke’s right to property. Why is that significant?
Continued… • The pursuit of happiness (what does the pursuit of happiness mean?) • Popular sovereignty (consent of the governed) • Limited government (role of government is to protect and serve) • Rule of law (see list of grievances) • Right of revolution (when government becomes systematically oppressive)
Discussion • What about religion? Some argue that US government is based upon Judeo-Christian principles. • Example: Mayflower Compact and Puritan settlement • Example: Declaration states all men are “endowed by their Creator with certain inalienable rights.”
However… • Jefferson and Franklin were Deists--not Christians • Deists believe in a Creator (how else to explain the creation?) but not the God of Abraham—a personal God who enters into history and who came as Jesus to redeem us. • So Declaration of Independence is largely a secular document
Discussion • Jefferson said that equality and liberty are self-evident truths, but he was a slave holder. Was he a hypocrite? Can we resolve this contradiction?
Sally Hemings • Personal slave accompanied Jefferson to Paris and had six children with Jefferson. • Read more about her here: https://www.monticello.org/thomas-jefferson/jefferson-slavery/thomas-jefferson-and-sally-hemings-a-brief-account/
Answer • Existence of slavery denied the American dream to millions of Americans and was the principal cause of the greatest conflict in American history. • A. Lincoln and ML King tried to address this.
Discussion • What specific event is the Gettysburg Address associated with? • “Four score and seven years ago” refers to what? Why does Lincoln highlight this? • What political principles does Lincoln refer to? • What is “the unfinished work” and “the great task remaining before us?” • How does the Address differ from the Declaration of Independence?
The speech affirms and transforms American political principles. • Lincoln argues it was the Declaration of Independence founded the US, not the Constitution • Lincoln places greater emphasis on equality and reads that into the Constitution • “Of the people, by the people, for the people” redefines US as a democracy rather than simply a system based on individual liberty • Calls for a more active roll for the federal government
Also note… • Lincoln’s language and rhetoric infuse a religious spirit into the American Creed that” is missing from the Declaration of Independence • “that this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom”
However… • Despite emancipation, Jim Crow segregation forced unequal laws, living conditions, and opportunities on African Americans
Martin Luther King’s I Have a Dream • “Five score years ago;” “this hallowed spot”—references to Gettysburg Addr. • The Constitution and Declaration of Independence were “ promissory notes” that America has defaulted on. • “Now is the time to make justice a reality for all of God's children.”
Continued… • “I still have a dream. It is a dream deeply rooted in the American dream. I have a dream that one day this nation will rise up, live out the true meaning of its creed: ‘We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal.’”
Questions on “I Have A Dream” • What specific event is this speech associated with? Specific location? • “Five score years ago”--what’s the significance? • King compares the Declaration to “a promissory note.” What’s that? What does he mean when he says “America has defaulted on this promissory note?” • Role of religion in this speech?
Answers • March on Washington, 9/19/1963; Lincoln Memorial • Reference to Lincoln’s Emancipation Proclamation and Gettysburg Address • It’s an IOU or personal check. Blacks are due the same rights as the Declaration of Independence established for whites. • King (a minister) speaks of faith, redemption, God’s children.
Continued… • What values does he refer to from the Declaration? • What values does he add that are not found in the Declaration? • How does ML King redefine the American Dream for his era? • What might King say today about progress towards his vision of the American Dream?
Answers • Liberty, equality • Social justice, democracy, brotherhood, nonviolence • He redefines the American Dream as the struggle for racial equality
Review • The ”American Dream” refers to widely shared values of individual liberty, limited government, democracy, and equality of opportunity • American Dream originated in John Locke’s Social Contract Theory. • The Declaration of Independence, Gettysburg Address, and I Have a Dream Speech are versions of the American Dream.