Ankle Arthrodesis
850 likes | 5.56k Views
Ankle Arthrodesis. Dr. C Wadden Dr. K-A Lalonde May 3, 2012. Overview. History Anatomy Indications Surgical Options Complications Outcomes. History. Originally described in 1879 by Albert Treatment for TB of ankle joint Over thirty procedures described
Ankle Arthrodesis
E N D
Presentation Transcript
Ankle Arthrodesis • Dr. C Wadden • Dr. K-A Lalonde • May 3, 2012
Overview • History • Anatomy • Indications • Surgical Options • Complications • Outcomes
History • Originally described in 1879 by Albert • Treatment for TB of ankle joint • Over thirty procedures described • Charnley developed compression technique in 1951, used an external-fixator • Arthroscopic arthrodesis described in 1983 • Mini-open arthrodesis described in 1996
Anatomy • Tibiotalar or talocrural joint is a hinge joint • consists of talar dome, tibial plafond, malleoli • Isolated movement occurs in the sagittal plane • 18o dorsiflexion to 48o plantar flexion • Small amounts of movement in coronal and axial planes • IR/ER in axial plane • Inversion/Eversion in coronal plane
Indications • Principle indication is pain and stiffness that is functionally disabling • prior #, infection, osteonecrosis, osteochondral defects, OA, RA • Absence of arthritis and normal alignment in the subtalar complex • talocalcaneal, talonavicular, calcaneocuboid
Evaluation • History and Physical Examination • Weight bearing AP and Lateral radiographs • CT +/- arthrography • Selective joint injections
Surgical Options • External Fixation • severe osteopenia, pre-existing septic joint • Open arthrodesis • significant deformity or malalignment • Mini-open/Arthroscopic arthrodesis • minimal deformity
Position of Fusion • Optimal ankle position is the same regardless of surgical technique • Ankle • Neutral flexion (0o) • 5o - 10o ER (comparable to contralateral side) • Slight valgus (5o) • Translate talus posteriorly to align with posterior margin of tibia
Position of Fusion • Ankle’s fused in neutral have 10o of plantar flexion though midfoot at heel strike • approximates normal ankle producing relatively normal barefoot gait pattern • Shifting the talus posteriorly + ER of 5o - 10o reduces lever arm of the foot • mild push-off by pronation through subtalar complex • Neutral position best utilizes midfoot motion to simulate normal ankle
External Fixation • Charnley Method • Open debridement of ankle joint cartilage + Ex-fix • External-fixator • One pin through tibia • One pin through neck of talus • Connecting bars • Compression relies on intact achilles tendon
External Fixation • Calandruccio external fixator • triangular, resists torsion, does not require intact achilles • Open debridement, external-fixator placed • Pins through neck and body of talus • Pin through tibia • Occasionally one pin through calcaneus • Fusion site buttressed with bimalleolar onlay grafts
External Fixation • Unilateral external fixator • adequate resistance to dorsi/plantarflexion • External fixators pins (larger diameter) • Medial aspect of tibia • Calcaneus • neck of talus • Compression exerted through a compression device attached to ex-fix prior to placement
Open Arthrodesis • Traditionally performed through a 2-incision transfibular exposure • Advantages • improved visualization of the joint • improved access for bony resection, correction, screw placement • Disadvantages • large incisions with significant soft tissue stripping
Open • Location of incisions • First over fibula • Second along anterior third of medial malleolus • Fibula osteotomized 10cm from tip, options: • morselized for bone graft • medial half cut away, turn down and away from arthrodesis site • Remaining fibula secured to tibia with 3.5mm screws later during procedure • lateral buttress, prevents lateral drift of talus
Open • Sharp dissection elevates scarred ankle capsule • Remove tibial plafond • large oscillating saw • cut perpendicular to tibial shaft at apex of articular dome • Preserve the medial malleolus • good area for screw insertion
Open • Position foot • neutral flexion, 5o valgus, 5o - 10o ER • Translate talus posteriorly • Posterior margin of talus flush with posterior margin of tibia • Cut through dome of talus parallel to distal tibial cut • resect 5mm talus
Open • Remove residual cartilage, drill sclerotic bone, defects filled with bone graft • Oppose cut ends of tibia and talus • Fix with cannulated screws (minimum 2) • One from posterior malleolus into talar neck • Second from medial malleolus into talus • Potentially a third
Fixation • Home run screw • primary stabilizer against doris/plantar flexion forces • Parallel versus crossed screws • Two crossed screws create more rigid construct • Two versus three screws • Cadaveric studies have shown that three screw configurations provide increased compression and resist torque better
Post-operative Care • Bulky splint maintained for 2 weeks, NWB • NWB in SLC until radiographic evidence of fusion • Usually occurs between 8 - 12 weeks post-operatively
Arthroscopic Arthrodesis • Originally described in 1983 • Rate of fusion comparable to open technique • Advantages • faster time to union • less blood loss, morbidity, shorter LOS • faster mobilization • Disadvantages • does not allow for large deformity correction
Arthroscopic • Intra-articular portion of arthrodesis can be performed using an arthroscope, high speed burr and currettes • Arthroscopy performed using 2 or sometimes 3 portals • anteromedial portal -> medial to tibialis anterior tendon • anterolateral portal -> lateral to peroneus tertius tendon • debris removal from denudation of joint surface • posterolateral portal -> lateral to achilles, 1-2cm distal
Mini-Open • Originally described in 1996 by Paremain • utilizes enlarged arthroscopic portals • Has advantages of open and arthroscopic • decreased soft-tissue dissection • decreased bone stripping • quicker radiologic fusion rates • Disadvantages • minimal deformity/malalignment correction
Mini-Open • Utilizes two 1.5cm incisions • medial side • anterolateral • Subchondral bone resection with high-speed burr, slurry used for local bone graft • Ankle positioned appropriately, fixation with cannulated screws
Complications • Non-union is the most common complication following ankle arthrodesis • Others include • Infection • Never injury • malunion • wound problems
78 ankle arthrodesis, complications in 44/78 (56%) • 32 non-unions • 7 infections • 2 each: nerve injuries, malunion, wound problems • Risk factors for non-union • severe fracture • open injury • local infection • osteonecrosis of the talus • coexisting major medical problems
Smoking is associated with non-union • Risk of non-union in smokers is 16 times than that of non-smokers in absence of other risk factors • Optimal period of smoking cessation prior to arthrodesis unknown • minimum of 1 week suggested empirically
23 patients (11 men, 12 women) • isolated post-traumatic ankle arthritis • Mean age at operation • 41 years (12 - 70) • Mean follow-up duration • 22 years (12 - 44) • 11 internal fixation, 12 external fixation
67% satisfied, 88% would have procedure again, 92% would recommend to a friend • More severe OA in ipsilateral adjacent joints when compared to the contralateral foot • subtalar, talonavicular, calcaneocuboid, naviculocuneiform, TMT, 1st MTP joints • 91% had mod-severe subtalar OA • Significantly more activity limitation, pain, and disability on affected side
Retrospective review 17 patients with 18 ankle arthrodeses • Post-traumatic arthritis in 16/18 ankles • Charnley ex-fix in 14, internal fixation with screws in 4 • Olerud Molander Ankle (OMA) Score, SF-36, and standing radiographs • subtalar and chopart’s joints assessed for OA
50% of patients not handicapped, 44% were in the same pre-injury job • Significant correlation between OMA score and SF-36, OMA score and radiologic score • Arthrodesis leads to functional outcome deficits, limitations of ADLs, and adjacent joint degeneration
Retrospective review of 26 patients who underwent arthrodesis • Posttraumatic arthritis in 25/26, primary OA in the other • All patients underwent open arthrodesis • the first 19 with fibular resection for grafting • remainder fibula retained, fixed to tibia and talus with compression screws
77% of patients completely satisfied,19% did not notice a gait abnormality • Sagittal plane motion significantly decreased at hip, hindfoot, and forefoot • hindfoot and forefoot coronal and transverse plane motion reduced as well • Ankle fusion will relieve pain and improve function but it is a salvage procedure