1 / 5

The UN Practitioners Handbook for Peace Consolidation Benchmarking

The UN Practitioners Handbook for Peace Consolidation Benchmarking. Monitoring and Evaluation of Peace Operations Workshop co-organized by IPI and NUPI New York, 8 May 2009. Svein Erik Stave Fafo Institute for Applied International Studies.

fburtch
Download Presentation

The UN Practitioners Handbook for Peace Consolidation Benchmarking

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. The UN Practitioners Handbook for Peace Consolidation Benchmarking Monitoring and Evaluation of Peace Operations Workshop co-organized by IPI and NUPI New York, 8 May 2009 Svein Erik Stave Fafo Institute for Applied International Studies 1

  2. UN benchmarking practice and some characteristics of existing M&E frameworks UN Practice: • No common understanding or use of terms and concepts • Tendency of measuring ouputs and input (mandate or pilars) related outcomes (- and efficiency, e.g. RBB) • Biased focus on achievments according to mandated/strategic targets • Benchmarks for strategic level oucomes tend to be very ambitious or unrealistic given timeframes of PK operations • Little systematic use of data, metholdogies, and documentation of process Some general characteristics of existing frameworks: • Focused on impact measurements (input related outcomes) • Strive towards establishing universial sets of indicators • Reflect a political buy-in process of indicators and a mixture of basic visions and objectives • Use large sets of variables rather than ”indicators” • Unsolved challenges of aggregation (with respect to assessing peace consolidation or sustainable peace 2

  3. Contents of the UN Practitioners Handbook for Peace Consolidation UN Integrated Peace Operation: Mandate, Strategies, Plans, Activities Input Related Outcomes Inputs Outputs Uncontrolled factors Other Actors: Visions, Objectives, Activities Strategic Level Outcomes Basic premises for the handbook: • Should focus on context specific elements (inform strategy rather than comparison) • Should include perceptional indicators (consensus on importance) • Should focus on strategic level outcomes • Should not present an ”official” set of benchmarks/indicators • Should describe a benchmarking approach to M&E 3

  4. Contents of the UN Practitioners Handbook for Peace Consolidation Handbook modules: • I. Definitions of terms and concepts, and handbook structure • II. What to measure: Principles for identification of benchmarks • III. How to measure: Principles for selection of indicators; Overview of data sources; data collection methods; and methods for data analyses and aggregation • IV. Principles for presenting, documenting and reporting results • V. Resouces (existing frameworks, links, etc.) 4

  5. Ten Key Elements for Effective Peace Consolidation Benchmarking 1. Identify sound contextual benchmarks and indicators 2. Engage host country authorities and civil society 3. Keep the focus on the core intentions of the benchmark system 4. Establish direct relationships between benchmarks and indicators 5. Balance the selection of indicators to reveal both positive and negative developments 6. Be realistic when defining benchmarks 7. Prepare for benchmarking early and, ideally, from the outset of an operation 8. Map existing data sources 9. Link-up with and share resources with other monitoring systems 10. Report comprehensively, honestly, and in an unbiased manner 5

More Related