1 / 22

ESMD SI Workshop: Day 2 Calibration SI Options & Splinter Analysis

ESMD SI Workshop: Day 2 Calibration SI Options & Splinter Analysis. ESMD SE&I Strategy Team Benchmarking Workshop Process. Pre-Workshop. Wed 15Dec AM. Wed PM. Thu 16Dec. Thu PM. Splinter 1. Policy Splinter. End State Option Synthesis 1. Statutory, Regulatory, Policy Assessment.

emera
Download Presentation

ESMD SI Workshop: Day 2 Calibration SI Options & Splinter Analysis

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. ESMD SI Workshop:Day 2 CalibrationSI Options & Splinter Analysis

  2. ESMD SE&I Strategy TeamBenchmarking Workshop Process Pre-Workshop Wed 15Dec AM Wed PM Thu 16Dec Thu PM Splinter 1 Policy Splinter End State Option Synthesis 1 Statutory, Regulatory, Policy Assessment Additional Inputs Splinter 2 Transition Splinter End State Option Synthesis 2 Transition, Cost and Schedule Tactical Assessment Invited Orientation Briefings Splinter Team Briefouts Session Briefouts Read Aheads Adjourn Option Evaluation Acquisition Splinter • NRC Report • Strategy Team Options Splinter 3 Contract Type, Teaming Structure, Incentive Design Assessment Evaluation Criteria Development Tue 14Dec PM Evaluate Options for Day 2 Focus SE&I Strategy Team Executive Session SE&I Strategy Team • Benchmarking Site Visit Summaries

  3. Workshop Agenda –Thursday Morning, 16 Dec 04

  4. Workshop Agenda –Thursday Morning, 16 Dec 04

  5. Workshop Agenda – Thursday Morning & Afternoon, 16 Dec 04

  6. 8:00 am Thursday 16 Dec 04Options Evaluation Splinter Session Orientation

  7. Splinter Session: Options EvaluationThe Promenade Room, The Plaza, Salon III • Session objectives: This team will evaluate strengths/weaknesses of Options 1-4, and will propose actions that can be taken to ensure that these options are enabled. • Option 1: Apollo Model – Tier A-C SETA, “Prime of Primes” • Option 2: Tier A-D SETA with HW Partial Exclusion • Option 3: Tier A-D Independent Organization SETA • Option 4: NAVSEA “Nested” MAIT Model • Session leadership: • The Promenade • Betsy Park (facilitator) • Richard Beatty (recorder • Salon III • Chris Crumbly (facilitator) • Robert Shishko (recorder) • The Plaza • Dale Thomas (facilitator) • Louise Hamlin (recorder)

  8. Vision Requires System-of-Systems Integration The Human: an Essential Element of the System of Systems Crew Surface Transport Crew Landing Mobility Support Systems Comm/Nav Launch Transit and Launch Systems Surface and Orbital Systems Biomedical Countermeasures and Limits Telescope Mars Pre-Positioned Long-Duration Candidates Candidates Propellants Habitation Surface Power and Resource Identification and Characterization Outer Moons Candidates Resource Utilization Supporting Research Technology Options Commonality/Evolvability For Future Missions

  9. Constellation Definition • Develop, demonstrate, and deploy successive generations of capabilities to enable the sustained human and robotic exploration of the Moon, Mars, and beyond. • Capability to be developed will form a system-of-systems that includes: • Crew Transportation Systems • Crew Exploration Vehicle (CEV) • CEV Launch Vehicle • Cargo Transportation Systems • Surface Systems • In-Space Systems • Ground Systems • Humans as a Critical System

  10. Prime Prime Prime Option 1 (Apollo Model)Tier A-C: Centralized Gov’t with SETA / Tier D: “Prime of Primes” ESMD Tier A Agency Alignment Supporting Integration Contractor (Bellcom- Type SETA) ESMD Tier B Div Integration & Req’s Validation LOCATED @ DC Metro Area Common Functional Office Structure LOCATED @ NASA HQ ESMD Tier C Development Div Prog. Integration Prg Cont SE&I Test Ops S&MA ESMD Tier D Constellation Spiral 2 Program Spiral 1 Program Prg Cont SE&I Test Ops S&MA Prg Cont SE&I Test Ops S&MA Project Office Prime of Primes Project Office LOCATED @ NASA Centers LOCATED @ Contractor Facilities Project Office Project Office

  11. Prime Prime Prime Option 2Tier A-D: Centralized Gov’t with HW Partial-Excluded SETA ESMD Tier A Agency Alignment Supporting Integration Contractor (SETA with Partial HW Exclusion) ESMD Tier B Div Integration & Req’s Validation LOCATED @ DC Metro Area LOCATED @ NASA HQ ESMD Tier C Development Div Prog. Integration ESMD Tier D Constellation Spiral 2 Program Spiral 1 Program Project Office Prime Project Office LOCATED @ NASA Centers LOCATED @ Contractor Facilities Project Office Project Office

  12. Option 3Tier A-D: Centralized Gov’t with Independent Org SETA ESMD Tier A Agency Alignment Independent Established Organization (UARC) Or (FFRDC) ESMD Tier B Div Integration & Req’s Validation LOCATED @ DC Metro Area LOCATED @ NASA HQ ESMD Tier C Development Div Prog. Integration ESMD Tier D Constellation Spiral 2 Program Spiral 1 Program Project Office Prime Project Office LOCATED @ NASA Centers Prime LOCATED @ Contractor Facilities Project Office Prime Project Office Prime

  13. Option 4 (Virginia Class NAVSEA Model)Tier A-D: “Nested” Major-Area Integration Teams ESMD MAIT Tier A Tier B Tier C Tier D S-o-S MAIT ESMD Tier A Agency Alignment ESMD Tier B Div Integration & Req’s Validation LOCATED @ NASA HQ ESMD Tier C Development Div Prog. Integration ESMD Tier D Constellation S-o-S Design/Build MAIT S-o-S MAIT LOCATED @ DC Metro Area PO Pri Pri PO Spiral 2 Program Spiral 1 Program PO Pri PO Pri Segment 1 MAIT Project Office Prime Segment MAIT “Virtual” SI Decision Teams Primes LOCATED @ Contractor Facilities Project Office LOCATED @ NASA Centers Prime Segment 2 MAIT Project Office Prime Project Office Prime

  14. Option 4 Example MAJOR AREA TEAMS SYSTEM INTEGRATION TEAMS Sail Command & Control Systems Module Habitability Non-Pressure Hull Stern Pressure Hull Auxiliary Machinery Room Weapons Stowage & Handling *Ref: presentation by George M. Drakeley, Deputy Program Manager, Virginia Class Submarine Program Office, to the Constellation Organization Discipline Team, 15-May-2004.

  15. 8:00 am Thursday 16 Dec 04Policy/Transition/Acq Strategy Splinter Session Orientation

  16. Splinter Session: Policy Splinter The Promenade Room • Session objectives: this team will identify policy, regulatory, and statutory issues associated with the target End State Option(s) identified during the orientation. • What are the obstacles that lie in the path to standing up the End State organization? • What new authorities, if any, will NASA require in order to establish the End State SoSE&I organization? The more specific, the better! • Are there other organizations that have executed a similar transition, or which have obtained and implemented such policies/authorities? What successes and problems were encountered? • Session leadership: • Betsy Park (facilitator) • Richard Beatty (recorder)

  17. Policy

  18. Splinter Session: Program Transition Impacts Splinter Salon III • Session objectives: this team will identify key aspects for NASA to consider in transitioning from the Near/Mid-Term SoSE&I organization to the End State Option(s). • These aspects could include anticipated cost and schedule drivers and specific tasks/tactics that NASA should plan for. • A key consideration to be discussed is how NASA can retain the corporate knowledge and experienced personnel built up during the Near/Mid-Term five year time frame. • What is the level of participation with the government team necessary to ensure a good handoff of SoSE&I responsibilities? • Are there other organizations that have executed a similar transition? What successes and problems were encountered? • Session leadership: • Chris Crumbly (facilitator) • Robert Shishko (recorder)

  19. Program Transition Impacts

  20. Splinter Session: Acquisition Strategy Splinter The Plaza Room • Session objectives: this team will identify key aspects of the acquisition strategy NASA should pursue to implement the End State Option(s). These aspects should include, at a minimum: • Recommended contract and solicitation type; • Desirable industry partnering/teaming arrangements; • Contractor hardware exclusions (full, partial, none), and specific features or such exclusions (the more detail here the better!); • Arrangements for SoSE&I organization/contractor handling of Exploration system/element hardware prime contractor proprietary/sensitive data; • Design of incentives. • Transition strategy. • Session leadership: • Dale Thomas (facilitator) • Louise Hamlin (recorder)

  21. Acquisition Strategy

  22. Great Work So Far!!Keep Collaborating!

More Related