1 / 48

Designing for Nonmotorists: Shared Use Paths

Designing for Nonmotorists: Shared Use Paths. Trails for Transportation Christopher Douwes, Trails and Enhancements Program Manager, Federal Highway Administration. Designing for Nonmotorists Course Overview. Part 3: Off-Road Facilities Shared Use Paths Recreational Trails Motorized Trails

demi
Download Presentation

Designing for Nonmotorists: Shared Use Paths

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Designing for Nonmotorists: Shared Use Paths Trails for Transportation Christopher Douwes, Trails and Enhancements Program Manager, Federal Highway Administration CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  2. Designing for Nonmotorists Course Overview Part 3: Off-Road Facilities • Shared Use Paths • Recreational Trails • Motorized Trails Part 4: Resources • Training, Publications, and Websites • Credits CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  3. Shared Use Paths CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  4. What is a Shared Use Path? • The term “shared use path” means a multi-use trail or other path, physically separated from motorized vehicular traffic by an open space or barrier, either within a highway right-of-way or within an independent right-of-way, and usable for transportation purposes. • Shared use paths may be used by pedestrians, bicyclists, skaters, equestrians, and other nonmotorized users. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  5. Sidewalk or Trail? What is the difference between a sidewalk and a trail? Part function, part location. • If it acts like a sidewalk, it’s a sidewalk. • If it acts like a trail, it’s a trail. • If it is in between….. • Facilities on park land parallel to streets. • Doesn’t matter who maintains (parks or streets department). The function matters. • People will always argue fine details…….. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  6. Provisions If you build a shared use path…. • Make sure it works for all users. • Accommodate pre-existing legal users, including equestrians. • Ensure Accessibility: to be covered in the Accessible Design course. • Ensure construction to guidelines: Verify! CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  7. Good Examples Oregon integrates recreational trails and transportation facilities: Portland Esplanade Trails connect parks and recreation: MKT Trail, Columbia MO CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  8. Bad Example What do these curves do? • Landscape architect vs Engineer? • Practical vs pretty? • Transportation vs recreation? • Opposite side of the road from a high school and other origins or destinations; no crosswalks. • It may be part of a larger plan. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  9. Shared Use Paths: Guidelines American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHTO) • Guide for the Development of Bicycle Facilities: 1999.https://bookstore.transportation.org/. • The 2010 version is under final review. • Guide for the Planning, Design, and Operation of Pedestrian Facilities: 2004.https://bookstore.transportation.org/ CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  10. Shared Use Paths: Surface Surface: Firm and stable. • Must accommodate wheelchairs. • Accommodate narrow-tire bicycles. • Accommodate people pushing baby strollers (good “test equipment”). • Slip resistance desired, but not required.* * Required for public rights-of-way (PROW). • Pavement is not required. Pavement may not be appropriate in some settings (rural). CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  11. Shared Use Paths: Surface • There are no Federal laws or regulations that require a shared use path to be paved. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  12. Shared Use Paths: Surface Firm and stable. • Some crushed aggregates can be firm and stable. • Rotational Penetrometer: Measures firmness and stability of ground and floor surfaces. www.beneficialdesigns.com/surfaces/surface.html#rotational CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  13. Shared Use Paths: Surface Pavement • Asphalt or Concrete? • Asphalt often cheaper to construct, but may suffer water, frost, and tree root damage. • Concrete may be cheaper in the long run: may better withstand flooding, frost, roots, etc. • Concrete: use “saw cut” for joints. • Check for accessibility and a smooth surface. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  14. Shared Use Paths: Tread Obstacles Tread Obstacles: Avoid, Minimize, and Prevent. • Prevent roots, rocks, ruts, bumps, cracks, etc. • Maintain a smooth path: sweep, fix irregularities. • Exception: Detectable warnings at crossings. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  15. Shared Use Paths: Gaps Gaps: Avoid, Minimize, and Prevent. • Keep drainage grates off the trail. • Minimize: openings, pavement and bridge joints, open bridge decks, railroad crossings, boardwalks. • Openings shall not permit passage of a 0.5 inch / 13 mm diameter sphere. • Elongated openings should be perpendicular or diagonal to travel direction. • Some exceptions for boardwalks: 0.75 inch/19 mm. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  16. Shared Use Paths: Speed • Design Speed: AASHTO Guide is 20 mi/h. • Draft 2010 AASHTO Guide proposes 14 mi/h. • REASON: Most bicyclists are slower than the “design bicyclist”, pedestrians, other users. • Consider not having completely straight paths: • May encourage excessive speed. • May result in speed variation conflicts. • Boring experience. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  17. Shared Use Paths: Width • How much use will there be? • 8 foot minimum for low-use facilities: • Connectors between cul-de-sac neighborhoods. • To avoid inviting cut-through motor vehicles. • Prefer 10 foot minimum, recommend 12 foot, more if needed. • Avoid designing only for the minimum. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  18. Shared Use Paths: Width • High use facilities: Consider separating “heels and wheels” on two separate paths. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  19. Shared Use Paths: Width Passing Space • Accessibility requirement: At least 60 inches (1525 mm) width within 1,000 foot (300 m) intervals. • Usually not an issue for Shared Use Paths. • Avoid designing only for the minimum. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  20. Shared Use Paths: Slope Slope: Accessibility is the primary consideration. • Based on Outdoor Developed Areas Guidelines. • Access Board to propose stricter guidelines: • Either Public Rights of Way (PROW), or • Outdoor Recreation Access Routes (ORAR). • At highway crossings: Highway slope is trail cross slope, highway cross slope is trail slope. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  21. Shared Use Paths: Slope Slope: <5% to the extent feasible. Slope ORAR Trail 1:20 (5%) any length any length 1:12 (8.33%) up to 50 feet up to 200 feet 1:10 (10%) up to 30 feet up to 30 feet 1:8 (12.5%) no up to 10 feet Trail: No more than 30% of the total trail length shall exceed 1:12 (8.33%). CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  22. Shared Use Paths: Slope • Avoid abrupt grade changes: • Not only annoying, they can be dangerous. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  23. Shared Use Paths: Rest Intervals Rest Intervals: A place to stop and rest. • Where running slopes exceed 1:20 (5%), at intervals no greater than the lengths permitted under running slope. • Size: 60 inch (1525 mm) length, at least as wide as the widest trail segment adjacent to the rest area. • PROW Level Landing: 2%. • ORAR: 3% (5% if drainage needs). • Trail: 5% (exempt if not possible). • Rest area may be off to the side. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  24. Shared Use Paths: Cross Slope Cross Slope: <2% on paved surfaces. PROW ORAR Trail General: 2% 3% 5%, 3% preferred Exception: 5%* 5%** 10%** * At street crossings without stop control or at midblock. ** If needed for drainage on an unpaved surface. Superelevation? Accessibility trumps. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  25. Shared Use Paths: Vertical Clearance • Accessibility: 80 inches minimum. • Equestrian Use: 10 feet minimum. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  26. Shared Use Paths: Vertical Clearance • Maintenance vehicles: 12 feet? More? • Provide warnings or barriers for low overhead clearance: detectable by people with visual impairments. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  27. Shared Use Paths: Protruding Objects • Avoid protruding objects in the treadway: • Poles, wires, signs, other objects. • Tree branches, hanging vines. • Mark unavoidable objects with retroreflective markings. • Covered in Accessible Design Course. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  28. Shared Use Path Crossings • Use Public Rights-of-Way Guidelines. • Treat as an intersection. • Who gets the right of way? Where is the volume? • Include detectable warnings. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  29. Trails in Freeway Rights-of-Way QUESTION: Can trails be built along an Interstate or other freeway right-of-way? ANSWER: • Yes! There are examples. • Ensure barrier separation between the trail and freeway lanes. www.fhwa.dot.gov/environment/bikeped/freeways.htm CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  30. Shared Use Paths Near Railroads QUESTION: Can Shared Use Paths (or other trails) coexist with railroads? ANSWER: • It depends. • Right-of-way. • Safety • Security • No trespassing! CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  31. Shared Use Paths Near Railroads • Many factors to consider. • See FHWA/FRA Rails-with-Trails: Lessons Learned: www.fhwa.dot.gov/environment/rectrails/rwt/index.htm • Trail may reduce trespassing on railroad property. • Trail is easier to use than walking on tracks. • Use a barrier: • Fence or vegetation. • Ditch. • Vertical grade. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  32. Rails-to-Trails • Good examples of shared use paths. • Low grade, good sight lines, wide, stable base. • It could handle trains, it can handle bicyclists and pedestrians! • Access points must be accessible. • Pay attention to property rights issues. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  33. Bollards: A Bad Idea. Why? What are some possible problems? CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  34. Bollards: A Bad Idea • Bollards should never be a default treatment. • Bollards are a potentially fatal safety hazard. • Unjustified bollards can create liability exposure. • Bollards, gates, fences, or other barriers can slow emergency response access. • Bollards are often ineffective: people go around, or damage the bollards or area. • A landscaped median is better. • Don’t use unless intrusions are documented. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  35. Bollards: A Bad Idea If installed, bollard, gates, fences, or other barriers: • Must not restrict access for people with disabilities. • Must be easily visible in low light conditions. • Have enough sight distance so users can adjust speed. • Should permit passage, without dismounting, for adult tricycles, bicycles towing trailers, and tandem bicycles. • Accommodate all users legally permitted to use the trail. • Must be easily removable for emergency vehicle access. • Never use even numbers of bollards, possibly creating head-on collisions….. (see previous examples). CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  36. Environmental Impacts • Shared use paths may qualify for Categorical Exclusions, but they can impact: • Drainage patterns and wetlands. • Wildlife: threatened and endangered species. • Historic, cultural, archaeological resources. • Privacy perceptions for adjacent properties. • Light pollution. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  37. Bridges: Essential Links Bridges are needed for any transportation network. • Union Street Railroad Bridge, Salem OR. • A half-mile span over the Willamette River. • The project improved bicycle and pedestrian safety and access, and provided a critical link in local, regional, and State transportation and trail networks. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  38. Bridges: Essential Links • Be creative. • Reuse historic bridges. • Reuse railroad flatcars. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  39. Rail Bridge to Trail BridgeWalkway Over the HudsonPoughkeepsie – Highland NY CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  40. Big Dam BridgeNear Little Rock AR Over Lock & Dam. Built and managed by by Pulaski County. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  41. Tunnels and Underpasses Design for the tallest likely user: • Maintenance vehicles • Equestrians • Snow level Think about maintenance. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  42. Tunnels and Underpasses Design for Perception of Security • Good visibility through the underpass: • No hiding places. • Lighting if needed. • Highway underpasses: • Underpass approach grade may be easier than a bridge over. • Drainage issues. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  43. Signs See MUTCD Chapter 9: http://mutcd.fhwa.dot.gov/. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  44. Support Facilities Trailside and Trailhead Facilities • Rest rooms, water. • Benches along trails, hitching posts, bike racks. • Buildings and built site facilities must meet accessibility guidelines for built facilities. • Not our job: Park amenities: picnic pavilions, campgrounds, ball fields, boat launches, etc. • Not our job: school running tracks, lighting. CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  45. Motorized Use on Shared Use Paths • Generally prohibited. Exceptions: • Motorized wheelchairs • Snowmobiles or electric bicycles at State or local option • See Framework for Considering Motorized Use on Nonmotorized Trails and Pedestrian Walkways • www.fhwa.dot.gov/environment/bikeped/framework.htm • Electric vehicles: currently not allowed (except electric bicycles at State or local option). CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  46. Motorized Use or Larger Vehicles on Shared Use Paths • Coming soon to a trail near you? CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  47. Critique? • What do you see that you like? • What do you see that you don’t like? CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

  48. Questions, Comments, etc. ????? CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT DESIGN GENERALIST PAVEMENT & MATERIALS

More Related