190 likes | 386 Views
Purpose of the Research. With winter temperatures reaching as low as
E N D
1. Overwintering Garlic in High Tunnels Terrance T. Nennich
Extension Professor
Commercial Fruit and Vegetable Production
University of Minnesota Extension.
nenni001@umn.edu
2. Purpose of the Research With winter temperatures reaching as low as 40 to 50 F degrees in Zone 2 and 3 and the inside soil of high tunnels receiving no snow protection, would fall planted garlic survive the winter and produce a good early crop the next spring?
3. Research Location
The location of the research was Bagley Minnesota, about 25 miles west of Bemidji.
Zone 2 3
4. The garlic research project was conducted over a three year period
2005, 2006 ( planted, harvested)
2006, 2007
2007, 2008
5. Variety Selection.
The variety Music was selected for all three years of this study.
6. Tunnel Design
Two different high tunnel designs were used in this research project.
Gothic V roof design
Small round design.
8. Planting Dates - Outside The garlic was planted on the following dates outside of the tunnel
2005 September 21
2006 September 23
2007 September 19
Six inches of straw was applied following planting.
9. Planting Dates Inside the Tunnels
2005 October 20
2006 October 18
2007 October 22
Six inches of straw was applied 30 day
after planting
10. Cold Temperature Data Days below 0 F Coldest Day
2005-06 17 days -37 F
2006-07 24 days -41 F
2007-08 33 days -38 F
The 2006-2007 winter had 8 consecutive
night -20F or colder.
11. Snow Fall Data 2005-2006 Ample but below average
2006- 2007 Little snow cover
2007- 2008 Average snow cover
12. Survival Rate (%) Inside TunnelGothic 2005 06 94%
2006-2007 92%
2007-2008 95%
13. Survival Rate (%) Inside Tunnel Round
2005 2006 92%
2006 2007 87%
2007 2008 94%
14. Survival Rate Outside Tunnel
2005 06 69%
2006 07 2%
2007 08 79%
15. Harvest Data
Average 3 year harvest was 21 days earlier in high tunnels.
16. Size Difference The size of the garlic grown in the high tunnels was about 30% more then outside.
Hard to statically compare because of different soils, fertility, rainfall, ect.
17. Results The effect of extreme cold winter temperatures of the variety Music Garlic grown in high tunnels in zone 2 or 3 has little effect on garlic winter survival.
The garlic grown in high tunnels had a much higher survival rate and increased size then the garlic grown outside. Drastic differences were noted in 2006 -07 when there was very little snow cover outside.
18. Future Research
In the fall of 2008, 18 different varieties, many soft neck were planted in the high tunnel
19. Future Research
Given this data, how will other perennial
plants overwinter in high tunnels????
20.
Questions????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????