Overview of ERCOT Board TAC Report: PRR Recommendations and Changes – November 2003
This report details the recommendations for Protocol Revision Requests (PRRs) approved by the Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) during the ERCOT Board meeting on November 18, 2003. Key PRRs include implementation strategies, updates on data validation procedures, the reinstatement of the Block Load Transfer generic cost, and guidelines for unavailable units and Reliability Must Run agreements. Each PRR outlines its effective dates, impacts, and unanimous approvals by TAC, ensuring the continued reliability and efficiency of ERCOT's operations.
Overview of ERCOT Board TAC Report: PRR Recommendations and Changes – November 2003
E N D
Presentation Transcript
TAC Report to the ERCOT Board November 18, 2003
PRRs recommended for approval • 441 – Protocol Revision Implementation • 449 – Successful Data Validation Response • 450 – Block Load Transfer Generic Cost • 452 – Unavailable Units and RMR Agreements • 453 – Black Start Voice Communication • 454 – OOME Offline • 456 – Disclosure of Short Paying QSEs • 457 – Balancing Energy Down • 463 – PCR Allocation Regarding the 25% TCR Ownership Limit
PRR 441 – Protocol Revision Implementation • Provides more information about PRR implementation • Allows PRS the opportunity to review alternative implementation options • Requires additional 4 FTEs plus added time for other ERCOT staff • Effective upon ERCOT staffing • Unanimously approved by TAC
PRR 449 – Successful Validation Response • Provides response to TDSPs for successful data loading or cancellation • ERCOT computer system input mitigated because changes are “in flight” as part of other projects • Effective upon system implementation (December 1, 2003?) • Unanimously approved by TAC
PRR 450 – BLT Generic Cost Fix…..The Sequel • Reinstates generic cost category for Block Load Transfers—inadvertently eliminated in PRR 371 • Effective upon system implementation—part of existing system projects for PRR 371 • Unanimously approved by TAC
PRR 453 – Black Start Service Voice Communication • Bid date moves from October to June • ERCOT can evaluate and specify necessary communication facilities • May require ERCOT to install back-up communications with TDSPs • Effective December 1, 2003 • Unanimously approved by TAC
PRR 454 – OOME Off-Line • When a unit receives and OOME instruction that would force it off-line, ERCOT will provide OOME instructions until the unit was scheduled to come off-line, or an OOMC instruction when requested to return on-line • Provides cost recovery for start-up after being instructed off-line and then on-line • Impacts ERCOT computer systems and staffing if manual work-around • Portion effective December 1, 2003, the remainder upon system implementation • Unanimously approved by TAC with revisions to allow immediate implementation
PRR 456 – Short Pay QSE Identity Disclosure • Identifies the short-pay QSE and associated dollar amounts of the short-pay • No impacts • Effective December 1, 2003 • Unanimously approved by TAC
PRR 457 – BES Down Requirement Revision • Changes the BES Down requirement to apply to MW capability above the QSE’s Low Operating Limit for the units operating in the QSE’s portfolio • Impact could result in fewer BES Down bids in the stack • Effective December 1, 2003 • Unanimously approved by TAC with modified implementation date
PRR 463 – PCR Allocation Regarding the TCR Ownership Limit • Clarifies that PCRs will not exceed 25% of the total TCRs on any CSC in a single direction • Clarifies that the ownership limit applies to PCRs • No impacts • Effective December 1, 2003 • Unanimously approved by TAC with clarifying revision
PRR 452 – Unavailable Units and RMR Agreements • Generation Entity must notify ERCOT it’s suspending operations within 3 days • ERCOT will regard notice as application for RMR status and evaluate need • If RMR status is needed, ERCOT and Generation Entity will negotiate for 30 days • If no agreement within the period, Generation Entity may cease or suspend operations
PRR 452 – Unavailable Units and RMR Agreements (cont) • Effective December 1, 2003 – Expires March 31, 2004 • Approved by TAC by a vote of 24-6 • Bill B. asked to lead a group to develop a follow-up PRR to address what happens at the end of the negotiation period if ERCOT and the Generation Entity cannot come to an agreement.
PRR 455 – Liability for QSE Defaults and ERCOT Fee • Allocates responsibility for QSE defaults and the ERCOT fee to both Loads and Resources • PRS recommended rejection • Appeal for TAC reconsideration by Green Mountain • TAC evenly split whether to accept or reject (15-14-1 vs. 15-13-2) • Motion to remand and split into 2 PRRs , brought to TAC in January, failed (18-10-1)