1 / 18

Budget Support and Poverty Reduction in South Asia

Budget Support and Poverty Reduction in South Asia. Shanta Devarajan Shekhar Shah. Forthcoming in Budget Support as More Effective Aid: Recent Experiences and Emerging Lessons World Bank, April 2006. Main messages. South Asia needs second-generation reforms, but these are deeply contested

clay
Download Presentation

Budget Support and Poverty Reduction in South Asia

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Budget Support and Poverty Reduction in South Asia Shanta Devarajan Shekhar Shah Forthcoming in Budget Support as More Effective Aid: Recent Experiences and Emerging Lessons World Bank, April 2006

  2. Main messages • South Asia needs second-generation reforms, but these are deeply contested • Governance problems persist, politics is clientelist, reform capacity varies greatly • If funding is to be provided, budget support improves chances of policy & institutional change in both strong and weak settings • Budget support faces new challenges as ground realities change in South Asia

  3. Impressive growth

  4. On track for income poverty reduction

  5. But a long way to go on health and gender parity

  6. Governance problems persist • Corruption (Bangladesh) • Conflict (Afghanistan, Nepal, Sri Lanka) • Lagging states (Bihar, Sindh, Two “Indias”) • Delivery of basic services (India, Pakistan)

  7. Needed: second-generation reforms • Restructuring state-owned enterprises • Reducing untargeted subsidies • Privatizing banks • Improving public expenditure management • Implementing sector reforms • Decentralizing to increase accountability

  8. Characteristics of South Asia • Very strong reform settings (Punjab, South India) and weak reform settings (Bihar, Baluchistan, Bangladesh, Nepal) co-exist • Policies and programs are highly contested in open, democratic settings • Politics more clientelist than programmatic, so reformers often lose elections

  9. Success in both high and low-capacity settings requires • Decisions for which policymakers can be held accountable • Client ownership to sustain progress • Deep local knowledge • Political choices on timing and sequencing of contested, long-haul reforms • Focus on outcomes, not on inputs

  10. Budget support for second-generation reforms • Focusing on budgets that matter • State-level, medium-term reform framework (Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, NWFP, Punjab) • Improve state finances (India)

  11. Fiscal deficits of Indian states

  12. Budget support for second-generation reforms • Focusing on budgets that matter • Exercising flexibility in implementation • In timing (Karnataka, AP, Pakistan PRSC) • In addressing binding constraint to growth (Bangladesh governance) • In aligning reforms with political realities

  13. Budget support for second-generation reforms • Focus on budgets that matter • Exercising flexibility in implementation • Promoting ownership • Support PRSPs or equivalent (AP Vision 2020, Regaining Sri Lanka) • Dialogue and analysis create climate for reform (knowledge partnership Tamil Nadu)

  14. Budget support to strengthen public sector management • Reveals capacity gaps (budget reform in Bangladesh) • Maintains dialogue, joint search for solutions to problems (Bangladesh DSCs) • Supports sector reforms (Punjab, AP, Nepal)

  15. Budget support to scale up human development • Keeps policymakers’ attention on human development (Punjab education) • Promotes innovation in service delivery and supports devolution (also Bangladesh) • Supply-side (textbooks, school councils) • Demand-side (stipends for girls)

  16. 19.9% 12.7 % Average increase1.5% per annum Primary school enrollmentPunjab, Pakistan, 1994-2005

  17. Budget support to scale up human development • Keeps policymakers’ attention on human development (Punjab education) • Promotes innovations in service delivery (Punjab, Bangladesh ESDSC1&2) • Cross-fertilizes learning (India primary education and HIV/AIDS, Nepal education and health)

  18. Challenges in South Asia • Decentralization • Third-, fourth- and fifth-tier governments • Governance • Dealing with crises (Nepal, Sri Lanka) • Donor perceptions, “writing a blank check”, “money down a rat-hole”

More Related