1 / 33

Research on Online Social Networks: Time to Face the Real Challenges

Research on Online Social Networks: Time to Face the Real Challenges. Walter Willinger AT&T Research Labs Reza Rejaie , Mojtaba Torkjazi , Masoud Valafar University of Oregon Mauro Maggioni Duke University HotMetrics’09, Seattle WA. Motivation.

bozica
Download Presentation

Research on Online Social Networks: Time to Face the Real Challenges

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Research on Online Social Networks: Time to Face the Real Challenges Walter Willinger AT&T Research Labs Reza Rejaie, Mojtaba Torkjazi, Masoud Valafar University of Oregon Mauro Maggioni Duke University HotMetrics’09, Seattle WA

  2. Motivation • Online Social Networks (OSNs) are becoming increasingly popular over the Internet • This growing popularity has motivated researchers to characterize user connectivity and user interaction in OSNs • Example: Facebook • Launched in 2004 and opened up to the general public in 2006 • More than 200M users as of Early 2009 and 300K new users per day • By late 2008, 300K images per second and 10 billion photos in total • Characterizing OSNs is critical for • Developing measurement and performance modeling/analysis tools • Improving OSN network architecture and system design • Understanding privacy and user behavior • Much of the existing OSN research studies seems to have lost sight of this unique opportunity for characterizing OSNs HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  3. State-of-the-art in OSN Characterization • Main focus has been on • Simple connectivity structures (e.g. friendship graphs or interaction graphs) • Graph metrics such as node degree distribution, clustering coefficient, density, diameter • Little is known about the actual structure and dynamics • User arrival/departure to/from the system • User interactions • Growth rate of the system HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  4. This Paper • We argue that OSN research has to change course • Abandon the traditional treatment of OSNs as static networks and become serious about dealing with dynamic nature of real OSNs • Come up with new techniques/tools for collecting and analyzing relevant data HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  5. Static Friendship Graph • Caveat emptor: our toy examples are for illustration purposes only, they are not meant to describe real-world OSNs • Toy example of static friendship graph (TOYFB) • Hierarchical Scale-Freenetworks [Barabasi2002] • HSF(n, m), n: size of the cell, m: number of levels • HSF graphs show power law node degree distribution, rich local clustering properties, and well-defined cluster-within-cluster structure Step 1: HSF(5,0) Step 2: HSF(5,1) HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA Step 3: HSF(5,2)

  6. Dynamic Friendship Graph (I) • Show a very elementary and highly stylized evolutionary process • 125 users join our toy OSN over time • Become friends with other users over time • Become inactive after a while • Consider time interval [0, 1], where graph structure changes at time points 1/16, 2/16, ..., and 16/16 • At any of these discrete points, some friendship relations become inactive, and some new friendships are being established HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  7. Dynamic Friendship Graph (II) t = 1/16 time HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  8. Dynamic Friendship Graph (II) t = 2/16 time HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  9. Dynamic Friendship Graph (II) t = 3/16 time HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  10. Dynamic Friendship Graph (II) t = 4/16 time HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  11. Dynamic Friendship Graph (II) t = 5/16 time HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  12. Dynamic Friendship Graph (II) t =6/16 time HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  13. Dynamic Friendship Graph (II) t = 7/16 time HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  14. Dynamic Friendship Graph (II) t = 8/16 time HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  15. Dynamic Friendship Graph (II) t = 9/16 time HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  16. Dynamic Friendship Graph (II) t = 10/16 time HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  17. Dynamic Friendship Graph (II) t = 11/16 time HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  18. Dynamic Friendship Graph (II) t = 12/16 time HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  19. Dynamic Friendship Graph (II) t = 13/16 time HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  20. Dynamic Friendship Graph (II) t = 14/16 time HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  21. Dynamic Friendship Graph (II) t = 15/16 time HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  22. Dynamic Friendship Graph (II) t = 16/16 time HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  23. Dynamic Friendship Graph (III) • A full crawl of TOYFB is identical to HSF(5,2), since friend lists maintained by users do not reflect any de-activation of friendship relations • Properties of the temporal snapshots , TOYFB(t), are radically different from those of the static counterpart TOYFB • What are the effective and efficient methods for accurately capturing and systematically characterizing the dynamic nature of large-scale real-world OSNs? HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  24. Measurement - Static • Crawling complete snapshots does not scale • Limited rate of crawling (e.g. 10 query/sec in Flickr) • Large population of OSNs (millions of users) • Partial snapshot is likely to be distorted and biased towards high degree nodes • Graph sampling is a promising approach for characterizing node properties [Stutzbach2006, Rasti2009] HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  25. Measurement - Dynamic • Goal of sampling: collect a “representative” set of users • In an unknown graph changing underneath any measurement tool (e.g. crawler), what does “representative” mean? • Even with a solid definition for “representative” snapshot, how to develop appropriate sampling techniques to deal with dynamic nature of OSNs? • Knowing all the challenges for measuring OSNs, is there any innovative approach for future analysis? HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  26. Analysis (I) • A new approach based on the following two observations in OSNs • Clustering at different spatial scales • Faster and more noisy temporal dynamics at finer levels of resolutions of the graph • Multi-Resolution Analysis (MRA) for graphs • Start from a coarse-scale representation that is typically small in size and has a slow dynamics • Use the insight gained at this scale to study the graph at the nextfiner levels of resolutions • Diffusion Wavelets (DW) as a principled approach for graph MRA • DW provides the necessary mathematical framework for performing the above graph coarsening intuition [Maggioni2004] HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  27. Analysis (II) • TOYFB at scale 2 is smaller in size than TOYFB at scale 1 • TOYFB at scale 2 has slower dynamics than TOYFB at scale 1 Scale 3 Scale 2 Scale 1 HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  28. Analysis (III) t = 1/16 time HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  29. Analysis (III) t = 5/16 time HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  30. Analysis (III) t = 9/16 time HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  31. Analysis (III) t = 13/16 time HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  32. Conclusion • Stop ignoring the dynamic nature of OSNs • For a better understanding of OSNs • Abandon current traditional measurement, modeling, analysis, and validation approaches • Replace them by new techniques that can account for the most of the dynamic features of real-world OSNs • New methodologies are required for advancing • OSN measurement: extend and develop current graph sampling techniques to consider churn in OSNs • OSN analysis: apply Multi-Resolution Analysis (MRA) methodology for large-scale dynamic graph structures HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

  33. Thank you! HotMetrics 2009 - Seattle WA

More Related