1 / 99

Challenge of Effective Public Management

Challenge of Effective Public Management. By Chandra-nuj Mahakanjana, Ph.D. GSPA, NIDA. 9/11 Weakness in the way agencies were organized and managed Organization and managerial problem  inadequate communication and handling crucial info. Understanding management of public organizations.

blanca
Download Presentation

Challenge of Effective Public Management

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Challenge of Effective Public Management By Chandra-nuj Mahakanjana, Ph.D. GSPA, NIDA

  2. 9/11 • Weakness in the way agencies were organized and managed • Organization and managerial problem  inadequate communication and handling crucial info

  3. Understanding management of public organizations • Skepticism about government • Public-private continuum • Body of management knowledge has paid too little attention to the public sector  managing bureaucracy • Legitimate skepticism about public org VS. recognition of their indispensable roles in society

  4. Need to improve their effectiveness (efficiency-effectiveness) • Government context (envi) influences public organization and management  constraining performance • Gov organization and managers perform better than perceived

  5. More authority & responsibility to Dept. of homeland security • Go against the trend of anti gov. movement • Resentment of taxes and ineffective government performance • Politicians attack Bureaucracy • Red tape

  6. Public org (in the U.S.)  great achievement • Small proportion of the GDP • Low taxes • Strong anti-gov role == demand for a strong and active government have continued

  7. Both government & private activities have strengths and weaknesses • Both are still very crucial for its existence • Challenge  designing the mix and balance of the two while attaining effective management of both

  8. Organization Behavior • Psychology • Individual behavior • Group behavior • Organization Theory • Sociology • Org as a whole • Org envi • Goals • Effectiveness • Strategy • Decision making • Change management

  9. Public Management • Ineffective public management • Effective operation • Control over by democratic processes • Need to be balanced

  10. Dilemmas of improving public management • Improving  Reform • Negative, control-oriented • Damage public service at the end

  11. Defining Effective Public Management • Perception of government incompetence  crisis in public management • Confusion between reinventing government & government cutback

  12. Image of incompetence • Why? • People in private sector are smarter? • Government employees are lazy and corrupt? • Government cannot get any work done?

  13. Lots of successful government programs, but no attention given • Negative image remains • Media  Public sector failures are more difficult to hide than failures in private sector • Fishbowl atmosphere

  14. Rules and regulations in public sector • Not designed for rapid and effective operation • But to combat fraud and improper political influences • If rules and regulations are ignored  media & public will suspect fraud or corruption

  15. Fishbowl atmosphere  always negative image of public manager

  16. Image problem • Bumbling bureaucrat (stereotype by media & politicians) • Inept bureaucrat  national economy • Too simple  ignore the benefit of government programs in economic growth (ex. infrastructure) • Social security program  more opportunity for young generation (not having to take care of their parents)

  17. causes • 1) Bureaucrat bashing by the media & politicians  easy to do and draw more attention than trying to explain how complex their situation is • Public policy process is so complicated and involve trade-off (usually not notice by the media)

  18. 2) Bureaucrat avoiding choices • Using vague language to avoid choices • Making choices  draw criticism (both from internal & public in general) • 3) Extreme Formality (red tape) • Rely on written communication • Focus on accountability • Habit • Leads to in effective and costly management practices  negative image

  19. 4) Public managers  lack of control over goal setting (unlike those in private sector) • Private sector  BOD is controlled or related to org managers • Public sector  BOD = elected legislators and executives )who are more focusing on their political popularity more than organizational performance • Political interests always change without much warning • Successful public managers = 1) adjust programs rapidly, 2) foresee changes in policy direction, 3) build org capacity for change

  20. สูตรแห่งความล้มเหลว • 1) Negative image  Bureaucrats’ self perception • negative thinking • psychology of failure • Ex. Roper family (p.5) • self-defeated = define ‘success’ as ‘the absence of failure’ • Low expectations • Ignore sense of vision • Make fun of those who are ambitious • Same manager in private sector  fired • In public sector  impossible to fire  hard to measure performance objectively • Hard to measure ‘success’ (unlike balance sheet in private sector

  21. 2) Letting the constraint constrain you • Accept problems and obstacles (instead of searching for solutions)  explanation for nonperformance • Give up easily • Due to the love-hate relationship with government (need government to do things ‘for’ them but not ‘to’ them)

  22. 3) Allowing caution to become inertia • Caution paralysis • New projects are abandon once tentative negative signals are received (ex. some other powerful public orgs do not favor the project proposal • Ex. Internet & USPS (p. 10) • Emphasize ‘process’ over ‘product’ • Standard operation procedures (SOP)

  23. 4) Hiding behind ambiguity • Use of unclear language • Ex. disturbed man • Hide their actions behind unclear phases, passive voice, refuse to agree to logical conclusions • To prevent outsiders from understanding who is doing what to whom!! • To hide poor or nonexistent performance (using vague statement of goals, unclear assignments of responsibility) • Create impression that they are achieving goals while actually achieving very little • Focus on image more than actual performance • Ex. preventive-retaliatory = invasion • Ex. revenue enhancements = tax increases

  24. 5) Forgetting that people matter • Forgetting that org = people  people count • Effective Management = art of getting people to do the right things  obtain resources to create incentives to achieve org goals • Org as organic entities (living, breathing, being) = organism  need nourishment from envi • Public managers usually ignore this essential concept forgetting to interact and communicate with people who work for them  deal with staff as abstractions  productivity impaired  org lost ability to attract resources from its envi

  25. Ex. of ‘empowering people’ (p.13) • Goodwill Industries of Tulsa  shifting people from welfare to work  (Nonprofit, receiving grants from Oklahoma state) • In 2000  Okl. Started to give grants based on outcome rather than output • Output = placing most people from welfare to work • Outcome = meaningful welfare-to-work =number of people who keep their new jobs)  staff need to spend more time with their clients to make sure they suit the job • Allowing people to do their best • Focusing on goal • Giving staff to feel they are in control of what they are doing

  26. ** “Effective public manager must understand the psychological, economic, and social needs that motivate their workforce” ** • BUT, normally, public managers are not trained to manage • Rudeness  dealing with subordinates as they were not valuable human beings • Have one personality for their staff/another personality for their boss • Example p. 15

  27. Innovative, Effective Public Manager • Effective management • active, aggressive, and innovative effort to overcome constraints and obstacles • Positive with “Can-do” attitude • Make things happen • Pursue goals by thinking and acting strategically • Understand why things are happening and how things can be changes • Touch with informal network (SC?)  information, ideas, initiatives • Learning, teaching, experimenting, changing • Understand org envi • Able to Project the effect of the envi • Understand constrain and influence of the envi • Entrepreneurship

  28. Risk taking • Bigger numbers of government employees • Professionalization of government service (MPA, MBA) • Public management  more on private contractors to provide services • Privatization, competition, contracting • Innovative public-private partnership (ex.)

  29. Need for effective and innovative public management • Economic reason (free market) • Modern industrial life • Labor moved from direct production of food, clothing, and shelter  manage info, provide services, profession • Econ downturn, disease, terrorists, fear of flying, homeless  government intervention • Trend  reduce government role  threat to liberty • Reality  economic interdependence is a far great constraint than power of government • Growth of government = reflection of economic reality (material consumption)

  30. Government (Traditional value) • Liberty, family, spirituality, envi preservation • Plastic bags – toxic-free envi • Fresh fruit – safe pesticides • Material wealth – spiritual fulfillment • ** Free market DOES NOT designed to protect traditional value**

  31. What Makes Public Organizations Distinctive • Experts on management & Org  treatdifferences bt public & private orgs as unimportant issue • Generic theory of organization • Broadly apply to all types of organizations • Standard principles to govern administrative structures of all organization

  32. Public Organizations • If public and private organizations are the same  questions are… • Can we nationalize all industrial firms? • Can we privatize all government agencies?

  33. If no, this means there are some important differences in the administration of public and private organization

  34. Purpose of public organizations • Public organization = “inevitable components of free-market economies” (Downs, 1967) • Thomas Hobbes  State of Nature

  35. Politics & Market • Political Hierarchy  “Polyarchy”  Political authority  social control • People willing to stop at red light vs. paying them to do so • Can be clumsy, ineffective, poorly adapted to local circumstances, resistance to change

  36. Market  voluntary exchanges • Producers •  induce customers to engage willingly in exchanges with them •  incentive to produce what consumers want, as efficiently as possible • Freedom & flexibility • Efficiently use of resources • However, have limited capacity in handling certain problems (ex.?) that require government action

  37. Public goods & Free riders • tragedy of the common • Services that benefit to everyone in society • Free-riders  get common benefit, let others pay • Individual incompetence • People lack sufficient edu or info to make wise individual choices in some areas ex. medicines, food safety  need government regulations

  38. Externalities/Spillovers • Costs that spill over to other people who are not part of a market exchange (air pollution, water contamination  Government intervention (EPA – Environmental Protection Agency)

  39. Government  correct problems that economic market creates or unable to address • Monopolies • Income redistribution • Provide services that are too risky/too expensive for private competitors to provide (facility for handicaps) • Conservative economists •  think that market will eventually solves all these problems •  Government makes these problems worse

  40. Political Rationales for Government • Maintain law, justice, social organization • Maintain individual rights & freedom • Provide national security and stability • Promote general prosperity • Provide direction for the nation & communities • Provide services that are not exchanged on economic markets (but based on general social values, public interest, politically imposed demands of groups (politics)

  41. Meaning and Nature of Public Organizations & Public Management Public (Latin)  people Private (Latin)  set apart from government as a personal matter

  42. Three major factors • Interests affected • benefits or losses are communal or individuals • Access to facilities, resources, information • Agency • A person/org acts as individual or for the community as a whole

  43. Agencies & Enterprises Continuum • Agencies ------------------- Enterprises (Public)(Private)

  44. Ownership & Funding Public Ownership Private Ownership Public Funding (taxes, gov contract) Private Funding (sales, private donations)

  45. Distinctive Characteristics of public Management • Environmental Factors • Organization-Environment Transactions • Organizational Roles, Structures, and Processes

  46. Environmental Factors • No economic markets for outputs • Depend on governmental funding • No incentives for cost reduction, efficiency, effective performance • Low efficiency allocating resources • Weak reflection of consumer preferences • Weak supply-demand relations • Less clear on market indicators and info that lead to managerial decisions

  47. Heavy formal legal constraints • Oversight by legislative branch, executive branch, courts • Constraints on operation procedures • Managers have less autonomy in making choices • Leading to more and more formal administrative controls • External formal authorities involved • Intensive external political influences • Bargaining, negotiating, lobbying, public opinion, interest groups, constituent pressure • Need political support

  48. Organization-Environment Transactions • Production of public goods • Handle externalities • Outputs are not transferable to economic market at a market price • Gov activities are coercive, monopolistic, unavoidable, unique sanctioning power • Financing of activities are mandatory • Activities have broader impact and greater symbolic significance • Involve public interest • Pressure on public managers • Expectation of fairness, responsiveness, honesty, transparency, and accountability

  49. Org roles, structures, and processes • Unclear goals • Vagueness, intangibility, hard to measure goals and performance criteria • Debatable & value-laden goal (clean envi, public safety, better living standards for the poor, etc) • Multi goals • Efficiency, accountability, transparency, responsiveness • Fairness, equality, distribution, moral correctness

  50. Conflicting goals • Involve trade-off (due to limited resources) • Value conflicting • Efficiency vs. transparency • Efficiency vs. social equality • Efficiency vs. accountability

More Related