Download
what industry should do if osha comes knocking at the door n.
Skip this Video
Loading SlideShow in 5 Seconds..
What Industry Should Do If OSHA Comes Knocking at the Door? PowerPoint Presentation
Download Presentation
What Industry Should Do If OSHA Comes Knocking at the Door?

What Industry Should Do If OSHA Comes Knocking at the Door?

318 Views Download Presentation
Download Presentation

What Industry Should Do If OSHA Comes Knocking at the Door?

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript

  1. What Industry Should Do If OSHA Comes Knocking at the Door? by: Walter Siegfried CSP, MS Retired OSHA Certified Safety Professional Ziggy@windsorknolls.com

  2. Options • Don’t answer the door? • Deny entry? • Let OSHA in?

  3. PA Governor’s Safety Conference20 OCT 2009 • Jordan Barab, Acting Assistant Secretary • Strong enforcement: e.g. $58M BP citation • Severe Violators Program: EEP revision • Troubling trends: e.g., “Texas sweep”, dust hazards • Emphasis programs: Refineries, chemical plants • 200 new OSHA personnel in 2010 • Questionable Recordkeeping Practices: Congressional hearings, new OSHA NEP, using hospital records, reporting disincentives

  4. Strategies • Continuous Improvement Process • Proactively apply Occupational Health & Safety Management Systems (ANSI/AIHA Z10) to control hazards • Review recordkeeping very carefully! • Use OSHA’s free consultation? • Establish procedures to handle an inspection • Define inspection scope, chain of command, documentation request procedures, private interviews, etc. with OSHA inspector • Post Inspection Options • Informal conference (informal settlement) • Contest process

  5. Inspection Positives • Effective audit process • Increases health & safety program importance! • Serves to inspire when parties buy into integrated safety management • Reduces employee risk to serious injury & illness

  6. Inspection Strategies • Try “honey” instead of “vinegar” • Constructive EHS program improvement adds value • Limit activities to scope of inspection • Plain view hazards are “fair game” • Duplicate OSHA’s photographs, private employee interviews and sampling • Research thoroughly: OSHA policy, such as • Final Rule preambles • Directives & letters of interpretation • Source standards & base standards • Application of standards: 1910.5 • Case law

  7. OSHA’s LEGAL SUFFICIENCY OSHA 1B Form Prima Facie • Cited standard is applicable • Employer failed to comply • Employees were exposed • Employer knowledge: actual or constructive Apply • Enforcement policy, such as: • OSHA Field Operations Manual • Directives • Letters of interpretation • Multi-employer policy

  8. Affirmative Defenses • Commonly used by employers • e.g., unsafe work practices • Employer’s burden of proof

  9. Affirmative Defenses • Unpreventable employee misconduct • Unpreventable isolated incident • Impossibility: infeasibility • Greater hazard • Multi-employer worksites • Exposing, controlling, creating & correcting employers

  10. Closing Conference • Discuss issues & take notes • Presentappropriate material to OSHA compliance officer: i.e., in terms of compliance-related documentation • Follow company protocol regarding legal counsel • Attorney/Client privilege: e.g. use of an attorney-hired consultant

  11. What Happens After an OSHA Inspection? • OSHA may or may not issue citations. • Citations inform employer and employees of the regulations and standards allegedly violated and the abatement time-frames. • Employer must post a copy of each citation at or near place where violation occurred, for 3 days or until violation is corrected, whichever is longer.

  12. Post Inspection • Informal Conference • An informal meeting may be held to discuss any inspection issues, such as the citation, notice of proposed penalty, or possible contest • §1903.20 covers amended citations, citation withdraws, & settlement agreements • 15 working day contest period limitation • Both parties, including legal counsel, are afforded the opportunity to participate fully

  13. Appeals by Employers • Employer (who wishes to contest) must submit a written objection to OSHA within 15 working days • Notice of Contest • Area Director forwards to the Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission (OSHRC) • OHRC is an independent agency not associated with OSHA • Must be posted in a prominent location or given personally to each employee

  14. Contest Process • If timely, the Notice of Contest is forwarded to the OSHRC • OSHRC is an independent agency not associated with OSHA • Case assigned to an administrative law judge (ALJ) who decides a case based on its merit • Either party may appeal the ALJ decision to the OSHRC and U.S. Court of Appeals

  15. Questions?