1 / 20

Preparing for Promotion: The Tenure Process Julia Hirschberg, Columbia University

Preparing for Promotion: The Tenure Process Julia Hirschberg, Columbia University. Unusual Career. PhD in History: Teaching at Smith Lightning Strikes: Computer Science! PhD in CS at Upenn Bell Labs and AT&T Labs Columbia University

arden
Download Presentation

Preparing for Promotion: The Tenure Process Julia Hirschberg, Columbia University

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Preparing for Promotion: The Tenure ProcessJulia Hirschberg, Columbia University

  2. Unusual Career • PhD in History: Teaching at Smith • Lightning Strikes: Computer Science! • PhD in CS at Upenn • Bell Labs and AT&T Labs • Columbia University • Working for diversity as an MTS, professor, and department chair • A husband and 2 Siamese….

  3. The Academic “Ladder” Postdoc Assistant Professor Associate Professor Professor Chaired Professor Department Head Associate Dean Dean . . . tenure

  4. Tenure Process Usually a six year “clock” • Find out the evaluation and tenure process when you get the job • Yearly department evaluations • Mid-tenure review • Some depts get external letters for this • Sixth year promotion and tenure review • External letters (typically 8-15) • Think about where these will come from • Extension possible for maternity leave

  5. Understand your Institution & Find Mentors • Expectations vary by institution – know yours! • Some (good) departments provide mentors when you arrive • If not, ask department chair/head, mentor, colleagues • Look at CVs of successful, recently tenured faculty • Find mentors • Different mentors for different activities (teaching, research, dept politics, etc) • ask for advice, feedback, examples, etc

  6. Teaching • Understand your institution’s expectations • General tips • Goal: do a good job while minimizing effort • Have an overall teaching plan/goals and update annually • Try to limit the number of new courses you teach/prepare: if you can, teach what you love • Try for a mix of ugrad (honors!) & grad (core, seminar) courses • Negotiate for release from teaching • As part of start-up package, for developing new coursesand labs, pre-tenure mini-sabbaticals • Try for good perceptions – positive evaluations • Be available, but be careful of your time • Be on time and don’t end early • Give extra lectures, review sessions when students need them • Keep regular office hours • Don’t be too hard or too easy • Good learning is not hard teaching • Don’t do evaluations right after an exam

  7. Research Advising • Recruit good students • Review applicants and make offers to top ones (talk on the phone and get to know them) • Offer grad level reading courses, projects at Grad level • Participate in undergrad (summer) research programs • Learn when and how to say “no” • A bad student is worse than no student • See them “in action” first (in class, trial project) • Balance PhD and MS students • Try to graduate at least one PhD by year six • Don’t take on too many MS students • Help them be productive • Build a mentoring hierarchy

  8. Publications • Qualityand quantity in publications • Journal publications • Understand the importance of publishing in referred journals • Understand journal rankings in your field and related fields that you publish in • Track special issues for faster turnaround • Conferences and workshops • Be visible and well-respected • Understand conference/workshop rankings • Keep track of acceptance rates • Read reviews, revise and resubmit rejected papers worth salvaging

  9. Funding • Target funding opportunities • Visit funding agencies regularly • Get acquainted with your program managers • Volunteer to serve on review panels • Get on funding opportunities’ mailing lists • Apply for junior faculty awards • NSF/ONR/ARL CAREER competitions • Other career development awards (industry, university) • Seek advice/examples from colleagues • Ask successful colleagues to review your proposal and Listento their feedback • Borrow sample proposals from successful colleagues • If at first you don’t succeed, try, try again

  10. Collaboration • Successful Collaboration is a multiplier • Helps you achieve more than you can on your own, is fun, brings you new friends and colleagues • Unsuccessful Collaboration can be awful: learn to say no but without burning bridges • Wastes times, stressful, creates hard feelings • Advice • Choose your collaborators wisely - do your research before saying ``yes’’ & learn when and how to say “no” • Collaborate with Successful People – look at their CV, papers, • Some people may be looking for a free ride • Be a good collaborator • Pull your weight, be on time with deliverables, reports • Don’t take on too much – easy to happen at the beginning • Caveats/Caution • For your tenure evaluation, people will try to assess *your* contribution. • Collaboration good but mix it up: work with different teams

  11. External Evaluators • External letter writers • Some selected by you • Some selected by your department • Can usually black list one or two people--but do so carefully • Can informally suggest names • Some departments exclude/include: • Thesis advisor • Close collaborators • OK (good) to ask someone if you can recommend them as a letter writer • Provide them an easy way out -few people say “no” outright

  12. Getting Known • Network at Conferences • Go without a paper,ask questions during sessions, talk to people at poster sessions, introduce yourself • Talk tours • Self invitation (I’ll be in area ….) • Proposal Review Panels, Journal refereeing, Conference PCs • Volunteer • Host Distinguished Lectures, invite others to visit and give talks

  13. Service • Find out what/how much service really counts • To the department, to the school/college, to the University, to the profession, to you • Learn when/how/why to say no • Quality and reliability are more important than quantity • Do what’s visible and will bring respect • From your research community • From your campus and department “elders”

  14. Starting Out • Find mentors • Reach out to your peers • Don’t do too much, too early • Take time to learn about your environment • Don’t take every student who walks in the door, join every grant proposal you are asked to join • Avoid joining factions • Practice as a grad student • Mentor ugrad & junior grad students in research • Help write grant proposals

  15. Overall Advice • The most important thing is to enjoy the work you do • Keep in mind the milestones you need to reach to be successful at what you do • Strike a balance between your family and social life and your career

  16. Dos and Don’ts • Do become someone other faculty want as a colleague • Do make a good first impression • Do be a team player • Do get to know leaders in your field • Do take criticism/feedback/complaints seriously • Do find mentors • Do get along well with staff • Do keep records • Do choose your battles wisely • Don’t let your research get off to a slow start • Don’t be labeled as a bad teacher • Don’t do too much, too early – don’t take every grad student who walks in your door or join all collaborations • Don’t be viewed as unsupportive of department goals • Don’t do anything that is unethical or makes you uncomfortable • Don’t brown-nose or be insincere • Don’t make enemies, but speak up

  17. CRA-W Computer Research Association Committee on the Status of Women in Computing Research Mission increase the participation and success of women in computing research www.cra-w.org

  18. Industry/government Graduate Students Undergraduates Academic careers CRA-W Programs Undergrads: UndergraduateResearch Experiences Undergrads: Distinguished lecture role models Grad Cohort: group mentoring of grad students Grad Students: Discipline Specific Research workshops PhD Researchers: group mentoring of early & mid career @ CMW, CAPP, Hopper & Tapia www.cra-w.org

  19. What should you do next? Completethe evaluation survey http://alturl.com/z4gp9

  20. What should you do next? Apply your new knowledge Shareyournew knowledge at your institution Follow up with someone you’ve met here Participate! join us on Facebook www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=58020017457 Visitour web pages www.cra-w.org

More Related