1 / 30

An Analysis of Trade Policy Environment and Global Production Networks: Implications on Regional Agreements

An Analysis of Trade Policy Environment and Global Production Networks: Implications on Regional Agreements. by Tereso S. Tullao, Jr. Mitzie Irene P. Conchada John Paul Aguinaldo. Introduction. Economic performance of the East Asian region registered fastest growth

angie
Download Presentation

An Analysis of Trade Policy Environment and Global Production Networks: Implications on Regional Agreements

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. An Analysis of Trade Policy Environment and Global Production Networks: Implications on Regional Agreements by Tereso S. Tullao, Jr. Mitzie Irene P. Conchada John Paul Aguinaldo

  2. Introduction • Economic performance of the East Asian region registered fastest growth • Growth is attributed to increase in exports • Global production networks is one of the causes of increase in exports • Forces of liberalization, deregulation & impact of information and communication technology changed the way TNCs compete globally

  3. Main Problems of the Study • What is the role of liberalization forces in promoting or enhancing growth of GPNs in the region? • What are other forces that may further enhance the growth of GPN? • What are the implications of GPN in the emergence of regional trading arrangements and regional arrangements?

  4. Objectives • To trace the pattern of trade within & outside the region (composition, direction and growth); • To trace the role of GPN in the pattern of trade in the region; • To review the liberalization forces in the Asian region (trade, investment and business facilitation); • To review the non-liberalization forces; • To assess the possible role and contributions of RTA or bilateral or regional trading arrangements and other regional agreements.

  5. Concept of Global Production Networks • Emergence of GPNs brought on a new perspective to pattern of trade & investments • GPNs are seen to replace the transnational corporations (TNCs) as a response to 3 constituent processes: • Ascendancy of liberalization processes • Rapid uptake of information & communication technologies • Onset of globalization

  6. GPNs are the nexus of interconnected functions & operations through which goods & services are produced, distributed & consumed • Three interconnected transformations in the cross-national organization of business: • GPNs multiplied as a major organizational involvements in global operations • GPNs acted as catalysts for international knowledge diffusion • A long-term process of “digital convergence” opened up new opportunities for organizational learning & knowledge exchange

  7. Hierarchy of GPN Participants • Local supplier – handles activities that are outsourced by flagships • Higher-tier suppliers/lead suppliers – interact directly with CMs and BLs; have their own propriety assets & technology; are able to develop & deepen linkages • lower-tier suppliers - main competitive advantage are low transactions costs; usually interact with higher-tier suppliers and do not have proprietary assets; most vulnerable to shocks • Flagship – supervises and directs operation of the network; has control over resources in the network & coordinates transactions and knowledge diffusion • Brand leader (BL) – top of the hierarchy • Contract manufacturer (CM) – links the BL to local suppliers; create their own supply chain networks to service BL

  8. Drivers of GPN • Liberalization/institutional changes – four elements: • Trade liberalization • Liberalization in capital flows • Liberalization in FDI policies • Privatization • permitted the integration of domestic markets with the global markets for goods, services & capital through changes in domestic regulations & policy • Liberalization made it easier for TNCs to identify locational specialization • Liberalization measures provide better access to external resources • Liberalization measures reduce the constraints for geographic dispersion of the value chain (Ernst and Kim, 2001)

  9. Information & communication technology • Enables better linkages in the international market • Reinforces globalization by increasing demand for it & creating new opportunities • Allows greater mobility of resources & capabilities across geographic boundaries & the selection of cost efficient locations • Provides a network infrastructure that allows for greater coordination among all GPN players

  10. Competition • Competition in the global arena became complex, fierce & dynamic • Due to competition, firms are forced to have some presence in all major markets & must be able to integrate activities across countries • Competition cuts across sectors & market segments • Growing complexity of competition changed the determinants of structure, location & growth of business organizations

  11. Other Issues • Knowledge diffusion • GPNs enable a network flagship to tap resources & capabilities of suppliers • Transfer of knowledge upgrades the GPN & makes it competitive • Provides incentive for flagships to spearhead knowledge transfer • Case of the evolution of Samsung • Governance • GPNs work with production parameters • Flagship directs the production process by enforcing production standards • Regulatory agencies (national governments/regional agreements) could specify production standards

  12. Pattern of Trade in ASEAN

  13. Limited intra-ASEAN trade • BUT relative to other regional trading groups, AFTA fares better • Major export & import products in the region: machinery & electronic appliances • Direction of trade: US, EU, and Japan are the leading trading partners of ASEAN • Other major trading partners: China, South Korea, India, Canada & CER

  14. GPN in Asia • Country experiences in GPN • Taiwan – transnational communities helped integrate Taiwan in a global production network (Saxenian, 2002) • Before 1980s, cheap labor in Taiwan attracted investments from US • More Taiwanese residents went to the US to take post-grad studies • Through active government recruitment (late 1980s), the brain drain reversed & a technology cluster emerged in Taiwan’s Hsinchu Science Park • Reverse brain drain resulted from Taiwanese policies that made opportunities greater

  15. India – similar to Taiwan’s initial brain drain • Relative slow pace of building ties between Silicon Valley and India • Development of India’s software industry was attributed to Silicon Valley’s influence in gov’t policy • Malaysia – is harnessing its competitive edges including cost competitiveness, good infrastructure, highly skilled and trainable workforce, stable socio-political environment, and attractive tax incentives • Attracted numerous electronics, computer peripherals and semiconductors firms due to its number of industrial zones

  16. China – leading destination of foreign direct investment and is an integral part of the GPN of foreign companies • Emerged as the leader in manufacturing electronic products • Philippines – experiences rapid growth of telecommunications industry • Became the production site for assembly and product-testing portions of the production stages of semi-conductors • Dominant role of call centers

  17. GPN in the Electronics Industry • Recently, global players shifted production to Asia • Two factors that caused the shift: • Boom periods in the region – allowed flagships to expand operations in Asia • Intense competition – led flagships to seek low-cost locations • Electronics industry faces some constrains: • Suppliers are faced with extremely short production cycles • Complex supply chain • GPN in the Automotive Industry • Car sales are increasing in emerging markets, together with the increase in population • Major strategy is introduction of an innovation • Suppliers are stepping up the value chain

  18. Liberalization Policies in ASEAN • Liberalization – key driver of global production networks; provides opportunities for locational specialization, outsourcing and spatial mobility • Regional trade agreements (RTAs) address the issue on opening up to trade by slowly integrating economic regions • RTAs should take measures to proceed to higher levels of integration – this issue is critical for global production networks

  19. Tariff Policies in Southeast Asia • Main goal of Common Effective Preferential Tariff (CEPT) was to reduce tariffs to 0% - 5% (Jan. 1993) • Average tariffs among ASEAN members steadily declined – now below 5% • Tariff rates at production level are between 0% - 5% • Temporary exclusions are products for which tariffs will ultimately be lowered to 0%-5% but are protected temporarily by delay in tariff reductions • General exceptions include products that are necessary for protection of national security, public morals, human, animal or plant life, etc.

  20. Non-tariff Policies in Southeast Asia • Para-tariff measures – increases the cost of imports by a fixed percentage or fixed amount, calculated on the basis of value and quantity • Price control measures – affects the cost of imports in a variable amount • Finance measures - regulates the access to and cost of foreign exchange for imports and define the terms of payment

  21. Monopolistic measures - creates a monopolistic situation by giving exclusive rights to a group of economic operators • Technical measures - refers to technical regulations, product characteristics requirements, marketing requirements and the like • Under CEPT, non-tariff barriers should be eliminated within a 5 year period after product has enjoyed CEPT concessions • Framework Agreement on Mutual Recognition Arrangements • Reduced trade barriers in service sectors • Greater financial cooperation

  22. FDI in ASEAN Region • The region is one of the major destinations of FDI due to liberalization measures and providing competitive and attractive investment environments • ASEAN Investment Area (AIA) – objective is to establish competitive investment region to attract FDI from ASEAN and non-ASEAN sources; 3 programs • Cooperation and facilitation • Promotion and awareness • Liberalization • AIA binds member countries to eliminate investment barriers, liberalize investment rules, grant national treatment & open up industries • Sensitive issue of AIA is the partial loss of economic sovereignty

  23. FDI Policies in the ASEAN Region • Short-term measures to enhance investment climate: • Fiscal incentives • Domestic market access • foreign equity ownership • right of use of industrial land • customs clearance • employment of foreign personnel

  24. FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT POLICIES IN THE ASEAN REGION

  25. Policies on Business Facilitation • Business facilitation - simplification of international procedures • Intends to open markets by reducing the cost of cross-border trade, improving access to trade information & aligning policy and business strategies • ASEAN emphasizes on building, networking, providing technical assistance & technology transfer • Facilitation measures that focus on transportation: • Framework agreement on mutual recognition arrangement (MRA) • Framework agreement on the facilitation of goods in transit • Framework agreement on the facilitation of inter-state transport

  26. Other Locational Advantages of GPN • Level of infrastructure such as telecommunications – facilitates firms to respond adequately to competitive challenges • State and quality of soft infrastructure – includes political stability of the country, peace and order situation, administration of justice, quality of human resources, & industrial relations • Strategic significance to the flagship company in the GPN

  27. FRAMEWORK FOR EVALUATING THE IMPLICATIONS OF GPN ON COUNTRY AND REGIONAL MEASURES

  28. Conclusion • Surge of GPN in the region facilitated the rapid liberalization mechanisms in host countries • Liberalization measures have brought about convergence in tariff rates & investment climate • Hard & soft infrastructure on ICT facilitated the growth of GPNs • Regional cooperative efforts influence one of the major drivers of GPN – liberalization • Since the impact of regional agreements on the two other drivers is rather limited & indirect, existing regional agreements should be reviewed & evaluated

More Related