110 likes | 145 Views
This study by Polona Domadenik, Bojan Ivanc, and Denis Marinšek analyzes the productivity of Slovenian firms before and after the crisis, considering factors like ownership, subsidies, investment, and more. The research utilizes data from 1995 to 2015 to identify key drivers of firm productivity and assess the impact of different ownership structures and government interventions.
E N D
Productivity of Slovenian firms Polona Domadenik, PhD University of Ljubljana, Faculty of Economics Bojan Ivanc, CFA, CAIA Chamber of Commerce & Industry of Slovenia Denis Marinšek, PhD, CFA University of Ljubljana, Faculty of Economics
Motivation – Governance and Institutional Context • Privatization model in 90s favored internal owners (employees and managers) • efficient in SME , diversified ownership in big firms • State asan(in)efficient owner before and during the crisis • Period of 2004-2008 • riskier investments in private firms • ownership consolidation in firms with diversified owners • Deleveragingfollowing 2009 andgrowthafter2014 • Structural weaknesses within the regulatory system • The role of state aid(differenttypesofsubsidies) before and after the crisis
Data • Firms’ annual financial statements – AJPES database 1995-2015 • Government subsidy allocation data – Ministryof Finance • Ownership structure gathered in several previous surveys • Methodology • TFP calculated as the residual from the production function (Levinsohn – Petrin procedure) • Dynamic production function estimation
Results – all firms TFP in four different industries
Results – all firms TFP according to export
Results – state owned vs others TFP growth in state owned firms vs other firms
Results – different owners TFP according to more detailed ownership structure
What are factors that generate differences among firms? Before crisis After crisis Investment** R&D activity ** State owners * Subsidies** R&D activity *** Foreign owners *** Privatizatized firms ***
Conclusions • Outperformingfactors: • Size (large to medium) • Exportorientation • R&D activity • Beforecrisisforeignownedfirmsandde-novo firmswere more productiveifcomparedwithothers. • After 2009 investmentand R&D activitywasimportantforproductivitygrowth, whilesubsidiesrepresentedsurvivingfactorforfirms in financialdifficulties. Stateownedfirmsreportedlowerproductivityduringthecrisis. • Zombie firmsrepresentedhighershare in totalstructure as reportedby OECD study (McGowan etal, 2017).