1 / 14

Does General Budget Support Work?

Does General Budget Support Work?. Stephen Lister Copenhagen, 16 May 2006 . Overview of Presentation. The Study joint donor (+government) study rigorous methodology, 18 month study seven countries, 1994—2004: Burkina Faso, Malawi, Mozambique, Nicaragua, Rwanda, Uganda, Vietnam

EllenMixel
Download Presentation

Does General Budget Support Work?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Does General Budget Support Work? Stephen Lister Copenhagen, 16 May 2006

  2. Overview of Presentation The Study • joint donor (+government) study • rigorous methodology, 18 month study • seven countries, 1994—2004: Burkina Faso, Malawi, Mozambique, Nicaragua, Rwanda, Uganda, Vietnam Presentation • theory and practice of budget support • scope of the evaluation • principal findings • implications Does Budget Support Work?

  3. What is general budget support (GBS)? • Unearmarked funds to government budget • Using government systems • Complementary inputs: • dialogue and conditionality • harmonisation and alignment • technical assistance and capacity building • Focus on partnership GBS • new style of conditionality (?) • support to poverty reduction strategy • Identified via country-level inventories • overlap with “sector budget support” Does Budget Support Work?

  4. What effects did we look for? • Expectations from GBS • ultimately, poverty reduction • via: • more predictable funding • harmonisation and alignment • lower transaction costs • more efficient public expenditure • more effective state and public administration • improved domestic accountability • etc. • i.e. • more efficient, effective use of resources • strengthening government systems • Types of Effect • flow of funds effects • policy effects • institutional effects Does Budget Support Work?

  5. What did we find to evaluate? • illustrative sample of countries • large volume, but recent, uneven distribution of PGBS • useful contrasts in “penetration” (e.g. Uganda vs. Vietnam) Partnership GBS flows (Table 3.3) Does Budget Support Work?

  6. Main Effects – Flow of Funds • Influence on discretionary expenditure • Influence on “pro-poor” expenditures • support to expansion of public services • Efficiency of expenditure • gains in allocative and operational efficiency • efficiency improvements benefit other modalities • lower transaction costs for government • Macroeconomic effects Does Budget Support Work?

  7. Institutional and Policy Effects • Harmonisation and alignment of aid • Public finance management • Bringing discretionary funds on budget, and using government systems does have the anticipated effects on ownership and system strengthening. • Capacity development • TA and capacity building are the least well specified or coordinated inputs of PGBS. • Nevertheless, complementary effects on system development. • Policy processes • A variety of positive effects on policy processes, where PGBS is established. Does Budget Support Work?

  8. Effects on growth and poverty • Macro-economic effects • contribution to total aid flow effects, reinforces existing stability and discipline • Effects on poverty reduction Caveats: • problems of data, time scale, correlation vs causality (not unique to GBS) • form vs. content of PGBS: support to evolving PRSs Conclusions: • Weak effect on income poverty (indirect, via macro effect) • Stronger effect on basic services (limited by quality and targeting issues) • Weak empowerment effects (but early..) Does Budget Support Work?

  9. Unintended and adverse effects • Unpredictability? • short term predictability improving • destabilising effect of suspension in Malawi • long term predictability? • Bias against private sector / growth? • public services bias reflects first-generation PRSPs • no major “crowding out” effects specific to PGBS • Revenue effect? • no major revenue substitution effects found • Fiduciary risk and corruption? • PGBS increases focus on strengthening public finance management • no clear evidence that PGBS funds have been more vulnerable than other modalities Does Budget Support Work?

  10. Interaction with other modalities Important interactions include: • Broad influence on harmonisation and alignment. • Increased policy coherence across sectors. • PGBS flexibility improves expenditure efficiency across all funding sources. • General benefit of strengthening PFM (public finance management). • Complementarity between PGBS and other instruments (e.g. on cross-cutting issues, capacity building, corruption). • PGBS benefits (e.g. on efficiency and t-costs) are diminished when off-budget modalities persist. Potential complementarities are not very systematically exploited. Does Budget Support Work?

  11. Feedback and sustainability • Evolutionary design, adaptation. • Some convergence between PGBS and PRSP monitoring systems. • Limited effects so far on domestic accountability (but domestic and donor accountability can reinforce each other). • PGBS needs to be durable for sustained institutional effects – main risk political? Does Budget Support Work?

  12. Overall assessment • Overall positive assessment in 5 of 7 cases. • Principal findings: • Relevant response to problems in aid effectiveness. • Efficient, effective and sustainable way of supporting national poverty reduction strategies. • Positive systemic effects on capacity by providing discretionary funds to national budget system. • Spill-over effects enhance quality of aid as a whole. • Initial effects on poverty mainly through expanding public services. Ultimate effects will depend on the quality of the national poverty reduction strategy. • Capacity for learning suggests instrument can become more effective over time. • Did not find unintended effects or side-effects that would outweigh benefits. • Sustainability requires more attention to mitigation of risks. • Findings are more widely relevant to programme-based approaches which share PGBS design principles. Does Budget Support Work?

  13. Implications and challenges • Use of budget support as part of portfolio • Range of applications? • Adaptation by both governments and donors to new ways of doing business • Long-term support instruments • Mitigating risks (fiduciary, political) Does Budget Support Work?

  14. Thank You Does Budget Support Work?

More Related