The Value of State Awareness in A Changing World:
1 / 52

The Value of State Awareness in A Changing World: Tackling Dynamics in Wireless Networks and Smart Grids - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

  • Uploaded on

The Value of State Awareness in A Changing World: Tackling Dynamics in Wireless Networks and Smart Grids. Junshan Zhang School of ECEE, Arizona State University A Growing Mobile World.

I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about 'The Value of State Awareness in A Changing World: Tackling Dynamics in Wireless Networks and Smart Grids' - vian

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript

The Value of State Awareness in A Changing World: Tackling Dynamics in Wireless Networks and Smart Grids

Junshan Zhang

School of ECEE, Arizona State University

A growing mobile world
A Growing Mobile World

  • “Broadband's take-up has repeatedly been jumpstarted by must-have applications. Napster drove the shift from dialup to wired broadband. Now Apple's iPhone is playing the same role in triggering explosive growth in the wireless Web. Unless we miss our guess, this dynamic is about to rudely change the subject from net neutrality to a shortage of wireless capacity to meet enthusiastic consumer demand …”

    [ “The Coming Mobile Meltdown,” Wall Street Journal, 10/14/2009]

State of the art of power grid
State-of the-Art of Power Grid

  • “If Alexander Graham Bell were somehow transported to the 21st century, he would not begin to recognize the components of modern telephony – cell phones, texting, cell towers, PDAs, etc; while Thomas Edison, one of the grid’s key early architects, would be totally familiar with the grid.''

    [ “Final report on smart grid," Dept of Energy Report, Dec. 2008]

Smart grid in the making
Smart Grid in the Making

The many meanings of “smart”:

  • Generation: renewable energy integration …

  • Transmission: enhanced situational awareness …

  • Distribution: demand response, automatic control…

  • End-user: smart metering, smart appliances…

Mobile commuications
Mobile Commuications mega-scale power grids.

  • Many signs of explosive growth of wireless traffic: voice/email, web browsing, audio/video streaming

  • Unique challenges in wireless communications:

    • Channel fading occurs on multi-timescales;

    • Time-varying topology due to mobility;

    • Interference varies on multi-timescales;

    • ……

Multi scale information dynamics
Multi-scale Information Dynamics mega-scale power grids.

  • Multi-scale network dynamics: channel-level, link-level, path-level, user-level …

Part i the value of state awareness for tackling dynamics in wireless networks
Part I: The Value of State Awareness for Tackling Dynamics in Wireless Networks

Q) How can we design state-aware transmissions in multi-scale dynamics?

  • Network/channel states are changing continuously;

  • Sensing/probing is needed to estimate/track states for state-aware network management.

  • DOS under noiseless probing [Mobihoc 2007, IT 2009]

  • DOS under noisy probing: reactive vs. proactive [ToN 2010]

  • DOS for cooperative networking [JSAC 2011]

  • DOS under delay constraint [Infocom 2010]

  • State-aware scheduling: DOS (Distributed opportunistic scheduling)

    Opportunistic state-aware

    System model
    System Model in Wireless Networks

    • Model: contention-based ad-hoc network

    • Two stages of probing: I) contention; II) channel estimation

    • Challenges: Links have no knowledge of others’ states; even their own states are unknown before probing.

      • Q) Which link to schedule based on local information, and how?

    • Approach: distributed exploitation and exploration

    • Focus: fundamental tradeoffs between probing and throughput gain.







    I noiseless probing
    I) Noiseless Probing



    Suppose after contention, the successful link has poor channel, and has two options:

    • Continue data transmission;

    • Or, alternatively, let this link give up this opportunity, and all links re-contend.

  • Intuition: At additional cost, further probing can lead to data transmission with better channel conditions.

  • In this way, multiuser diversity and time diversity can be exploited in a distributed and opportunistic manner.

  • E




    Tradeoff between probing and throughput gain
    Tradeoff between Probing and Throughput Gain

    • s(n) denote the successful link in n-th round of probing.

    • Clearly, there is a tradeoff between throughput gain from better channel conditions and the cost for further probing.

    • Using optimal stopping theory, we characterize this tradeoff for distributed scheduling.

    Channel coherence


    Probing time

    Ii noisy probing probing with imperfect rate estimation
    II) Noisy Probing: Probing with Imperfect Rate Estimation

    • In the above, channel state information (CSI) is assumed to be perfectly known after probing.

    • In practical scenarios, channel conditions are often estimated using

    • noisy observations, and CSI is imperfect.

    • Consider channel-aware distributed scheduling with noisy rate estimation.

    MMSE Estimation of the channel rate:

    Noisy probing
    Noisy Probing

    • Major differences between noisy/perfect probing:

      • The rate, after probing, is not perfectly known.

      • The stopping rule in noisy case is defined over filtration generated by noisy observations

    • Can show that structure of optimal scheduling remains same, except that the rate is replaced with its conditional expectation.

    • Reactive strategy: (linear) rate backoff

    • Proactive strategy: next

    Proactive strategy with noisy probing
    Proactive Strategy with Noisy Probing

    • Further probing may be helpful to improve the quality of rate estimation and hence the throughput.

    • Particularly interested in the wideband low SNR regime, i.e., and Potential significant improvement of rate estimation due to further probing in wideband regime. [Verdu’ IT2002]

    • Trade-off between enhanced rate gain due to improved estimate and further probing cost.

    Proactive approach: DOS with two-level probing;

    Underlying theory: optimal stopping theory with incomplete information

    [Stadje’ 97].

    Proactive strategy dos with two level probing
    Proactive Strategy: DOS with Two-Level Probing

    Q: Is it worthwhile for the successful link to “refine” rate estimation, with an additional cost? How much can we bargain?

    - Gain: more accurate rateestimate;

    - Cost: time overhead

    The answer is yes or no; there is a grey area where additional probing will help.

    Channel condition is good

    Channel condition is bad

    refinement is not helpful,

    defer and re-contend

    refinement is relatively

    meager, transmit immediately at the current rate



    Dos with two level probing structural results
    DOS with Two-Level Probing: Structural results

    Optimality Conditions:

    Dos with two level probing strategy a
    DOS with Two-Level Probing: Strategy A





    2nd Level Probing

    Refined rate R(2)





    1st level probing

    Rate R(1)



    Transmit at R(1)

    Give up and re-contend



    Give up and re-contend

    Transmit at R(2)


    Dos with two level probing strategy b
    DOS with Two-Level Probing: Strategy B






    1-st level probing

    Rate R(1)


    Transmit at R(1)

    Give up and


    Details: [Infocom’09]


    Numerical example
    Numerical Example

    • performance gap is significant in the low-SNR regime.

    • As increases, the performance gap narrows down

    • -The overhead due to extra probing offsets its gain in mitigating estimation errors

    • - The “gray area” collapses. As a result, Strategy A degenerates to Strategy B


    State awareness cooperative networking
    State Awareness & Cooperative Networking

    • Our initial steps started in 2001/2002 and studied 1) Capacity bounds of MIMO relay channel; 2) Power allocation in wireless relay networks; 3) Scaling laws of Wideband sensory relay networks

    • Two of our IT papers received about 800 citations: B. Wang, JZ & Host Madsen (IT 05); Host-Madsen & JZ (IT 05). [Google scholar]

    • High traffic volume

    • Need cooperative networking

    Iii distributed scheduling for cooperative networking to relay or not to relay
    III) Distributed Scheduling for Cooperative Networking: To Relay or Not to Relay?

    collision! re-contend

    no collision : to relay ?

    no collision and ‘good’ channel: transmit

    no collision but ‘bad’ channel : re-contend

    Dos with dedicated relay node
    DOS with Dedicated Relay Node

    trade-off: higher rate vs. overhead for probing relay and establishing coopertive relaying



    Dos without dedicated relay node
    DOS without Dedicated Relay Node

    . . .

    . . .

    tradeoff: (node diversity + higher rate) vs. (probing overhead + cost of relay)



    From primal to dual to dual s dual
    From Primal to Dual to Dual’s Dual

    “Hidden convexity”

    (Lyapunov Theorem)

    Details: [Infocom’10]

    Part ii the value of situation awareness tackling dynamics in smart grid
    Part II: The Value of Situation Awareness: Tackling Dynamics in Smart Grid

    • Transmission: PMU data processing for dynamic contingency analysis [He-JZ-Vittal (preprint)]

    • CPS inter-networking architecture: robustness vs. allocation of interconnecting edges [Yagan-Qian-JZ-Cochran 2011]

    • Wind generation integration: modeling and fortcast of wind generation; multi-scale scheduling and dispatch

    Situation awareness in smart grid
    Situation Awareness in Smart Grid

    • Multi-scale dynamics of power grid:

      • Supply uncertainty: deep penetration of renewable energy (wind, solar …)

      • Demand uncertainty: load variation, distributed generations …

    • Traditional SCADA systems

      • Measurements taken every few seconds; state estimation every few mins.

      • Lack “real-time” situational awareness; may fail to prevent large-scale blackouts (e.g., 2003 northeast blackout)

    • Emerging wide-area monitoring system (WAMS)

      • PMU sampling frequency (30~60/s), synchronized by GPS time-stamps

      • Useful for state estimation, fault diagnosis, and contingency analysis

    Synchronized measurements of phasor measurement units

    Location 2

    Location 1

    • Synchronizing pulses obtained from GPS satellites.

    • Phase angular difference between the two can be determined.

    Synchronized Measurements of Phasor Measurement Units

    Example june 2005 houston blackout phasor angle jumping and frequency spikes
    Example: June 2005 Houston Blackout Phasor Angle Jumping and Frequency Spikes

    Frequency “spikes”

    as Phase Angle

    jumps to 76⁰

    Normal Phase angle 30⁰

    Frequency collapse t 0 min
    Frequency Collapse ( T-0 min)

    5:16 PM

    5:10 PM

    20 minutes after initial indication

    Frequency becomes

    Unstable and Phase

    Angle difference

    Exceeds 120⁰



    Contingency analysis
    Contingency Analysis

    Contingency analysis: “What-if” a hypothetical accidental event occurs, e.g., outage of lines or generators; determines if state trajectories are in insecure regions, and if yes, take preventive/corrective actions.

    • Two important approaches (both assuming a given set of contingencies)

      • Nonlinear system analysis [Chiang’95, Chiang’99]

      • Decision tree [Sun-Vittal’07,Diao-Vittal’09]

        Dynamic contingency analysis:

    • Goal: Incorporate new contingencies and adapt to new measurements; distributed implementation.

    • Challenges:

      • Large contingency list; thousands of states and many more data;

      • Exact analysis is non-attainable since large-scale power systems are highly nonlinear; numerical study is challenging due to computational burden.

    Decision tree for contingency analysis
    Decision Tree for Contingency Analysis

    • Decision tree: a tree structure that maps observation to a predicted value

      • is binary for classification (continuous for regression tree )

      • At each internal node, compare an attribute to a threshold, and generate two branches

      • Each binary string points to a region and a predicted value per leaf

      • Decision tree learning: Select the attribute and its threshold for each internal node, so as to minimize prediction error, e.g., for classification tree using Gini Index ,

        For regression tree:

    where, is the region corresponding to left branch of A, is number of samples in , and .

    Example dt learning for contingency analysis
    Example: DT Learning for Contingency Analysis

    • A classification tree trained with given historic data to find secure (insecure) regions in attribute space

    • Learned DT applied to real-time PMU data for contingency analysis

    Pre processing and post processing for dt based dynamic contingency analysis
    Pre-processing and Post-processing for DT-based Dynamic Contingency Analysis

    • In existing approaches:

      • DT is rebuilt to incorporate new contingencies; high complexity for updating a DT; centralized.

      • DT with a large number of correlated attributes is prone to overfitting.

    • Treeletsbased preprocessing [Lee08]:

      Data mining & learning tools are used for dimension reduction to transform attributes into a lower dimensional space; new attributes as linear combinations of original ones

    • Multi-classifier boosting (MCBoost) as post-processing [Kim08]:

      • Each classifier corresponds to a subset of contingencies.

      • Each classifier is obtained by boosting a few simple DTs, easy to update in online applications.

      • Combine multiple classifiers to obtain final decision.

    Examples boosting simple dts
    Examples: Boosting simple DTs

    • Use the SRP database

    • Single DT: 35 internal nodes, largest simple DT: 7 internal nodes; complexity is much lower

    Examples incorporation of new contingency
    Examples: Incorporation of New Contingency

    Convergence performance: the 6th contingency (CT183) is incorporated into a 5-classifier analyzer, via updates with incremental observations for CT183

    . Robust CPS inter-networking architecture: Allocating Interconnecting Links against Cascading Failures

    CPS - Two Interacting Networks

    Networked systems: modern world consists of an intricate web of Interconnected infrastructure systems.

    Interdependence: Operation of one network depends heavily on the functioning of the other network

    Vulnerability to cascading failures: node failures in one network may trigger a cascade of failures in both networks, and overall damage on cyber-physical systems can be catastrophic since the affected area is much greater than that affected in a single network alone.


    Robust Inter-networking Architecture:

    An Interconnecting Edge Allocation View

    • Q) How to improve robustness against cascading failures, under constraint of average inter-edges per node

    • Allocation without intra-degree information

      • Random vs. Uniform allocation

      • Unidirectional edges vs. bi-directional edges

    • Allocation with intra-degree information

      • Preferential allocation

      • Ranking based allocation

    • Approach: compute ultimate fractions of functioning giant components, and critical threshold pc; the lower pc the more robust


    Robustness of Different Allocation Strategies

    Lower pc indicates the higher robustness

    • Two Erdos-Renyi networks with average intra-degree fixed at 4

    • The pc varies over different average inter-degree k

    • As expected, the uniform & bi-directional allocation leads to the lowest pc

      under various conditions



    Allocation with Intra-degree Information

    • Preferential allocation

      • Intuition: Important nodes have more support

      • Probabilistically allocate the inter-degree proportional to intra-degree

    • Ranking based allocation

      • Rank nodes based on their intra-degrees; and partition nodes into groups

      • Deterministically allocate more inter-edges to groups with higher intra-degrees

    • Analysis is fairly difficult; evaluate the performance by simulations.

    • By exploiting intra-degree information, both strategies outperform the

      allocations without topology information




    • Multi-scale dynamics is ubiquitous in complex networks, e.g., in mobile communications and in mega-scale power grids.

    • Tackling dynamics in mobile communications: distributed opportunistic scheduling for a variety of models.

    • Tackling dynamics in smart grids: PMU data processing for contingency analysis, and robust CPS architecture design.

    • (We have also looked into fault diagnosis based on Markov random field model of PMU data; multi-scale scheduling and control for wind generation integration.)

    • Many open research problems need “marriage” of expertise in power system, renewable energy, communication, control, computing, …

      Need multi-disciplinary research!