1 / 19

International services outsourcing and innovation: an empirical investigation

International services outsourcing and innovation: an empirical investigation Holger Görg and Aoife Hanley University of Nottingham . Why look at services outsourcing?. ‘Fear factor’ Media attention spurred economists to look into effects of services offshoring (e.g. Amiti and Wei (2006))

Download Presentation

International services outsourcing and innovation: an empirical investigation

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. International services outsourcing and innovation: an empirical investigation Holger Görg and Aoife Hanley University of Nottingham

  2. Why look at services outsourcing? • ‘Fear factor’ • Media attention spurred economists to look into effects of services offshoring (e.g. Amiti and Wei (2006)) • But maybe a good thing: economic restructuring? • Reverse the ‘hollowing out’ of industrial production: ever shifting PPFs through increased innovation sustain a country’s competitive advantage

  3. Our research question • We empirically analyse the link between services offshoring and innovation at establishment level • Does offshoring of services raise innovation? • Data for ROI: Amiti and Wei (2006) suggest services more important in ROI than in US • We use data for both services and manufacturing sectors • Time period: 2000 - 2004

  4. Background • Empirical work on domestic market effects (Feenstra and Hanson, 1999; Head and Ries, 2002; Hijzen et al., 2005) • Theory: Wage savings prompt North to o/s relatively less advanced intermediates from South (Glass and Saggi, 2001) • Prediction: Northern wages (relative to the South) fall due to outsourcing • What makes Glass-Saggi special: dynamic model with reinvestment of profits

  5. Predictions of G-S model • G-S and earlier work allow 2 effects to be identified: • Offshoring negative effect on wage rate • Offshoring raises innovation in offshoring firm • Non G-S effects: • Restructuring • Learning of new technologies

  6. Services offshoring in practice (1) • Positive impact of cheaper transport, telecommunications improvements, cheaper computing and liberalisation (Gage and Lesher, 2005) • Overall importance of service inputs small (Amiti and Wei, 2006) • Compelling cost reasons underscoring future growth: • €54 Germany • €44 US • €9.24 Russia • €14 Portugal and China • € India

  7. Services offshoring in practice (2) • ‘Services industry’ no longer means strictly services (Gage and Lesher, 2005) • Some trade patterns in services violate textbook predictions: e.g. computer programming from Hyderabad in India

  8. Methodology (1) • Innovation measured as R&D intensity • X contains other plant characteristics (lagged) • Time and industry dummies • Error terms: μ (plant specific) and ε (time specific) • To test Glass-Saggi: within transformation i.e. coefficients determined using within plant deviation from the mean in variables

  9. Methodology (2) • This equation allows the wage channel (from Glass-Saggi) to work • Expected sign on γ 1t to be negative • Estimate 1) and 2 separately with outs as exogenous • Also try instrumenting outs in both 1) and 2) • If ε and φ are correlated, we estimate using 3SLS

  10. Data description • Data from ABSEI collected by Forfásfor 2000 to 2004 • Survey of plants with at least 10 employees • 55 – 60 percent response rate • Spending on R&D in Ireland only 0.8% of GDP (OECD, 1998) • This means Ireland is low on the list of industrialised countries in terms of R&D spending

  11. Key variables in the data Table 1

  12. Innovation rates for firms that offshore services Table 2

  13. Which industries offshore services? Table 3

  14. Econometric results (1)

  15. Econometric results (2)

  16. Econometric results (3)

  17. Econometric results (4)

  18. Econometric results (5)

  19. Conclusions • Recent developments in Web and other media improve scope for offshoring service inputs • Firm should increase innovation with increases in offshored services through the mechanism of wages • Our results somewhat agree with G-S (+ive relationship between offshored services and R&D) • This only holds for manufacturing sector firms • This positive effect does not work through the wage channel, contrary to G-S

More Related