The Challenges for the Mobile Sector
1 / 18

New Framework - Procedures - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

  • Uploaded on

The Challenges for the Mobile Sector The European Commission’s perspective Pearse O’Donohue European Commission DG INFSO Implementation of the Regulatory Framework. New Framework - Procedures. 1. Market definition 2. Market Analysis 3. Designation of SMP 4. Obligations

I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about ' New Framework - Procedures' - ronna

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript

The Challenges for the Mobile SectorThe European Commission’s perspectivePearse O’DonohueEuropean Commission DG INFSOImplementation of the Regulatory Framework

New framework procedures
New Framework - Procedures

1. Market definition

2. Market Analysis

3. Designation of SMP

4. Obligations

- Consultation: nationally, other M/S NRAs & Commission

- Possible Commission veto

Different stages of the analysis
Different stages of the analysis

  • Relevant Markets - Commission Recommendation

  • product aspect of the market

NRA input

Commission Guidelines

NRA Market definition

taking account of the Commission Recommendation

define geographical aspects

define other product markets, following Art 7 FWD

NRA removes existing obligations - does not impose new obligations

competition is effective

NRA analysis

is competition effective ?

dominance test/SMP designation

NRA designates SMP operator(s) -

maintains or modifies existing obligations, or imposes new obligations

competition not effective

Smp dominance assessment
SMP/Dominance Assessment

  • Single:

    • Evolution of market shares

    • Potential competition and barriers to entry

    • Control of essential facilities

  • Joint dominance:

    • “oligopolistic markets the structure of which was considered conductive to coordinated effects”

    • Market characteristics: concentration, transparency, retaliatory mechanisms.

  • Leveraging

Obligations remedies
Obligations / Remedies

  • Transparency

  • Non-discrimination

  • Accounting Separation

  • Access to, and use of, specific network facilities

  • Price control and cost accounting - cost orientation

  • Other access obligations...

Obligations to be proportionate and based on the problem found
Obligations to be proportionate and based on the problem found

  • Leveraging

    • transparency

    • non-discrimination and accounting separation

    • access to, and use of, specific network elements and associated facilities

  • Prices at an excessively high level or price squeezes

    • price control

    • accounting separation and cost- accounting


Appeals on nra decisions
Appeals on NRA decisions found

  • National legal systems must allow for appeals on NRA decisions

  • Appeal body may be a court or tribunal

  • Merits of the case must be taken into account

Dispute resolution
Dispute resolution found

  • National level

    • resolve in 4 months

    • refer to alternative dispute resolution mechanisms

    • results must be in conformity with the framework

  • Cross-border

    • co-ordination of NRAs concerned to resolve in 4 months

Transposition timeline
Transposition - Timeline found


Date of application in all MS


Entry into force

15 months

M States transpose, but don’t apply

NRAs do market analyses

Nras data gathering
NRAs - data gathering found

  • Market analysis key aspect of new framework

  • need for comprehensive and accurate overview of markets

  • interest and obligation of market players

  • consultation mechanisms

  • possibility of streamlining once systems in place

Mobile markets
Mobile Markets found

  • Access and call origination on public mobile telephone networks

  • Voice call termination on individual mobile networks

  • The wholesale national market for international roaming on public mobile networks

MVNOs found

NRAs may impose obligations to meet reasonable requests for access, including inter alia: - resale - intelligent network services - roaming

Obligations must be proportionate

Effect on competition (short term) and investment (long term)

Number portability
Number Portability found

  • Mobile number portability must be available under new framework

  • Pricing for interconnection related to portability to be cost oriented

  • Charges to subscribers should not act as a disincentive

  • No imposition of retail tariffs that would distort competition

Roaming found

  • Wholesale national market for international roaming targeted

  • Evidence of excessive charges

  • DG COMP sectoral enquiry and specific investigations

  • Introduction of local/national roaming

3G found

  • Delays in roll-out

  • Equipment and services

  • License sunk costs

  • Developments in WiFi / RLAN

  • Intermediate market / 2.5G

  • Coordinated measures at EU level

Radio spectrum
Radio Spectrum found

  • Allocation & assignment based on transparent, objective, non-discriminatory & proportionate criteria

  • Auctions & beauty contests permitted

  • Spectrum trading an option for Member States

    two conditions:

    • no distortion of competition

    • no threat to harmonisation

DG Information Society: found

Pearse O’DonohueEuropean Commission DG INFSOImplementation of the Regulatory Framework