1 / 55

The Problem of Free Will

The Problem of Free Will. The Problem of Free Will. First, you tell me: What is the problem (roughly)?. The Computer Analogy: A computer can only do what it’s been programmed to do. Its a ctivities are completely caused by its programming.

michon
Download Presentation

The Problem of Free Will

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. The Problem of Free Will

  2. The Problem of Free Will First, you tell me: What is the problem (roughly)?

  3. The Computer Analogy: A computer can only do what it’s been programmed to do. Its activities are completely caused by its programming. A person can only do what her beliefs and desires cause her to do. Her actions are completely caused by her beliefs and desires.

  4. Environment Beliefs + Desires Actions Genes

  5. The Programmers The Program Environment Beliefs + Desires Actions Genes

  6. Two different problems The Programmers The Program Environment Beliefs + Desires Actions Genes

  7. Two different problems The Programmers The Program Creates the problem just mentioned: computers aren’t free to do anything other than what’s specified in their programming.

  8. Two different problems The Programmers The Program A different problem: The causes of the computer’s actions lie outside the computer itself, so it has no control over its actions. The computer isn’t the source of its own actions. (The programmers are.)

  9. Two Different Problems for Freedom: The Problem of Sourcehood (Sober: “Distant Causation Argument”) The Problem of theAbility To Do Otherwise (Sober: “Could-Not-Have-Done-Otherwise Argument”)

  10. The Sourcehood Problem (Distant Causation) The Programmers Environment Beliefs + Desires Actions The Agent Genes

  11. The Sourcehood Problem (Distant Causation) The programmers completely cause the program, which completely causes the action. Genes and environment completely cause beliefs and desires, which completely cause actions.

  12. The Sourcehood Problem (Distant Causation) The agent doesn’t control her own actions. The real causes of action are in the distant past, and this puts them outside the agent’s control.

  13. The real causes of action lie outside the agent. Environment Beliefs + Desires Actions The Agent Genes

  14. The Problem of Sourcehood P1) Your genes and environment determine what your actions are. P2) Your genes and environment are causes outside your control. P3) If your actions are determined by causes outside your control, then you don’t act freely. You don’t act freely.

  15. Imagine looking at a menu and trying to decide between two dishes you really want to order. Now, consider each of these premises in light of that situation. P1) Your genes and environment determine what your actions are. P2) Your genes and environment are causes outside your control. P3) If your actions are determined by causes outside your control, then you don’t act freely. You don’t act freely.

  16. Two Different Problems for Freedom: The Problem of Sourcehood (Sober: “Distant Causation Argument”) The Problem of theAbility To Do Otherwise (Sober: “Could-Not-Have-Done-Otherwise Argument”)

  17. The Problem of the Ability to Do Otherwise The programmers completely cause the program, which completely causes the action. Genes and environment completely cause beliefs and desires, which completely cause actions.

  18. The Programmers The Program Environment Beliefs + Desires Actions The Agent Genes

  19. The Problem of the Ability to Do Otherwise For a choice to be free, it must at least be possible to choose more than one thing. If there’s only one thing you can possibly do, then you don’t have freedom to choose.

  20. The Problem of the Ability to Do Otherwise • Given the input ‘5 + 7’, a computer must output ‘12’. • It has no ability to do otherwise. • Given her beliefs and desires, a person must do what they specify. • Once your beliefs and desires are fixed, you have no ability to do otherwise.

  21. The Problem of the Ability to Do Otherwise Another way to look at it: If you had done otherwise, it wouldn’t show that you were able do things that aren’t specified by your beliefs and desires. It would just show that you had different beliefs and desires.

  22. The Problem of the Ability to Do Otherwise P1) Your beliefs and desires determine what your actions are. P2) If your beliefs and desires determine what your actions are, then you have no ability to do otherwise. P3) If you have no ability to do otherwise, then you don’t act freely. You don’t act freely.

  23. The Puzzle of Locke’s Locked Room A man chooses to stay in a room, talking with a friend. Before he makes this choice, but while he’s still in the room, someone locks the door from the outside without his knowing it. So the man makes a choice, but at the time of the choice he isn’t able to do otherwise. Does the man choose freely?

  24. Two Different Problems for Freedom: The Problem of Sourcehood (Sober: “Distant Causation Argument”) The Problem of theAbility To Do Otherwise (Sober: “Could-Not-Have-Done-Otherwise Argument”)

  25. These two arguments both say that determinism and freedom are incompatible...

  26. P1) Your beliefs and desires determine what your actions are. P2) If your beliefs and desires determine what your actions are, then you have no ability to do otherwise. P3) If you have no ability to do otherwise, then you don’t act freely. P1) Your genes and environment determine what your actions are. P2) Your genes and environment are causes outside your control. P3) If your actions are determined by causes outside your control, then you don’t act freely. You don’t act freely. You don’t act freely.

  27. The difference between them: different reasons for incompatibilism

  28. P1) Your beliefs and desires determine what your actions are. P2) If your beliefs and desires determine what your actions are, then you have no ability to do otherwise. P3) If you have no ability to do otherwise, then you don’t act freely. P1) Your genes and environment determine what your actions are. P2) Your genes and environment are causes outside your control. P3) If your actions are determined by causes outside your control, then you don’t act freely. You don’t act freely. You don’t act freely.

  29. Incompatibilism: Determinism (of actions) is incompatible with free will.

  30. Note the difference: Determinism: Actions are determined. Incompatibilism: Determinism and freedom are incompatible.

  31. Note the difference: Determinism: Actions are determined. Determinism is true. Incompatibilism: Determinism and freedom are incompatible. If determinism is true, we don’t have free will.

  32. Note the difference: Philosophers haven’t paid much attention to this question. Traditionally, determinism seemed more likely, so the classic debate focuses on incompatibilism. Determinism: Actions are determined. Determinism is true. Incompatibilism: Determinism and freedom are incompatible. If determinism is true, we don’t have free will.

  33. Note the difference: Determinism: Actions are determined. Determinism is true. Note: you can be an incompatiblist whether you believe in determinism or not. Incompatibilism: Determinism and freedom are incompatible. If determinism is true, we don’t have free will.

  34. Incompatibilism says you can’t have both determinism and freedom. It doesn’t say which one to keep.

  35. Incompatibilism says you can’t have both determinism and freedom. It doesn’t say which one to keep. Determinism Free Will Determinism Free Will

  36. Incompatibilism says you can’t have both determinism and freedom. It doesn’t say which one to keep. Determinism Free Will Libertarianism Hard Determinism Determinism Free Will

  37. Compatibilism Incompatibilism Soft Determinism Libertarianism Determinism Free Will Determinism Free Will Hard Determinism Determinism Free Will

  38. Compatibilism Incompatibilism Soft Determinism Libertarianism Determinism Free Will Determinism Free Will Hard Determinism Take a minute to consider these three options. Which box would you place yourself in? Determinism Free Will

  39. What is determinism? The events of the past, along with the laws of nature, completely “fix” the course of the future. Given the past and the laws of nature, there is only one way the future can possibly unfold.

  40. What is determinism? Exactly one state of the universe at a later time The state of the universe at one time + = The laws of nature Given past events and the laws of nature, everything that does happen must happen. No alternative futures are possible.

  41. What is determinism? Notice that this is a possibility claim. Given past events and the laws of nature, everything that does happen must happen. No alternative futures are possible.

  42. What is determinism? Notice that this is a possibility claim. This makes it something more than just a causal claim. • Compare: • A caused B • A caused B, and made B necessary. Given past events and the laws of nature, everything that does happen must happen. No alternative futures are possible.

  43. What is determinism? Notice that this is a possibility claim. This makes it something more than just a causal claim. • Compare: • A caused B • A caused B, and made B necessary. Sometimes causes are just contributing factors—they don’t necessitate what they cause.

  44. What is determinism? In a book I’m reading, a boat sinks and an important character drowns. There are two contributing factors: A submarine torpedoes the boat A storm prevents the rescue operation The torpedoes cause the drowning, but they don’t make it necessary. Without the storm, rescue was still possible.

  45. What is determinism? • Compare: • A caused B • A caused B, and made B necessary. The torpedoes cause the drowning, but they don’t make it necessary. Without the storm, rescue was still possible.

  46. What is determinism? Not fatalism. What’s the difference?

  47. What is determinism? Not fatalism. What’s the difference? • If an event is fated, it will happen no matter what—regardless of the events that lead up to it (or the laws of nature). • Determinism says that events depend on the events that lead up to them (and the laws of nature) .

  48. What is determinism? With regard to free will, what’s important is determinism about actions, in particular. Genes and environment necessitate actions. or Beliefs and desires necessitate actions.

  49. Would indeterminism be better? Suppose determinism is false. Actions are not necessitated by prior causes. Discuss in groups. Consider both problems: Sourcehood Ability To Do Otherwise

  50. Would indeterminism be better? Suppose determinism is false. Actions are not necessitated by prior causes. This helps with the ability to do otherwise... It’s clearly possible for the agent to do more than one thing.

More Related