1 / 15

The Local Option

The Local Option. An Alaskan policy to reduce alcohol-related harm in villages. My Project Objectives. Objectives: to understand the greater success of the Local Option in some villages in reducing alcohol related harm

lottie
Download Presentation

The Local Option

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. The Local Option An Alaskan policy to reduce alcohol-related harm in villages

  2. My Project Objectives • Objectives: • to understand the greater success of the Local Option in some villages in reducing alcohol related harm • to report to village residents and state policymakers, so the findings may inform local and state decision making • Long term goal: to contribute to development of policies that will reduce alcohol-related harm in rural Alaska

  3. Study Region Doyon / TCC Region

  4. And Fourth Judicial District Fourth Judicial District extends to Yup’ik region in Western Alaska, allowing inclusion of some Yup’ik villages

  5. Methods • Use of quantitative data • state and local crime reports, death reports, demographic info, etc. • Limitations: reported data ≠ number of incidents • Original qualitative research • Interviews in Fairbanks and in villages to understand peoples’ perceptions of conditions, successes, challenges, failures in their villages • Limitations: biases, personal attitudes; info is anecdotal • (perceptions reflect expectations; evaluative terminology is relative – good, bad, better, worse . . . )

  6. Stage I – Exploratory Research in Fairbanks • Interview professionals who live in or visit villages regularly • Health care workers, police officers, magistrates, teachers, TCC contacts, chiefs • Develop hypotheses re: greater success in some villages • Select villages for case studies / secure invitations to villages • Seek funding for Stages II and III

  7. Historic Time of regular contact with outsiders History of missionization Social and Health Village health aide? Active church org? Org. non-alcoholic events? Sobriety movement? Strong adult role models? Amount of social capital among residents Physical / demographic On or off road system Distance from hub Age dist. of residents Male-female ratio Avg. ed. level of adults Ethnic homogeneity Economic Level of public assist. % of males doing subsist. % males, females employed Potential Variables

  8. Variables (cont.) • Political • Degree of community support behind Local Option (measured by vote count, active vigilance against bootlegging, efforts to rescind vote) • Presence of law enforcement • Presence of active tribal gov’t • Other community orgs. (relates to social capital issue)

  9. Stage II – Case Studies • Travel to selected villages • Conduct interviews with village residents to learn their perspectives on • Alcohol problems • Trends • Explanations for current conditions • Frustrations

  10. Measures of Success • Positive change as perceived by residents • Fewer alcohol-related disturbances • Improved school attendance and/or better academic performance (teacher perceptions) • Reduction in alcohol-related crimes • Reductions in reported child abuse and neglect • Reductions in accidents, suicides and other alcohol-related deaths

  11. Stage III • Report back to villages on findings (ask for responses) • Report to AFN (ask for responses) • Report to legislature (ask for responses) • Publish findings

  12. Progress • Identification of six villages of interest • Two road system villages • Two villages with community-owned stores • Two remote dry villages • Met with IRB officer • Developed interview questions, tested them with grad students

  13. Progress (cont.) • Contacts and interviews: • Tribal court administrator at TCC • She’s interested incollaborating and could offer villages support through workshops on making the local option work better. • Director of VPSO program at TCC • Member of the ABC Board • Tribal leader in one target village • Plus other villagers there (background) • Magistrate in village with community store • Fairbanksan with strong ties to other village with community store • Pastor in non-study village near planned study village for background

  14. Challenges • Developing relationships with villages • I’m an outsider • My bringing up the issue will raise tension in villages • Tension could result in revisiting L.O. status • Funding . . . • Chicken or egg question re: funding and village selection

More Related