1 / 30

Isn’t it obvious that it’s beneficial?

Influences of a Wilderness Experience on Individual Health and Wellbeing: A Case Study on Fraser Island Belinda Warren Science Honours Student 2005 Supervisors: Dr Anne Neller Assoc. Prof. Ron Neller. Isn’t it obvious that it’s beneficial?.

lefty
Download Presentation

Isn’t it obvious that it’s beneficial?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Influences of a Wilderness Experience on Individual Health and Wellbeing: A Case Study on Fraser IslandBelinda WarrenScience Honours Student 2005Supervisors: Dr Anne Neller Assoc. Prof. Ron Neller

  2. Isn’t it obvious that it’s beneficial? • Environmental Health research is mainly centred on the adverse effects of various environmental exposures • Environmental exposures may have positive health effects • Intuitive, however, • Anecdotal and empirical evidence lacking on actual benefits • Theoretical and empirical evidence lacking on the role environments play in facilitating social connectedness • No evidence on the extent, nature and process of the impact of nature on health or quality of life

  3. The Biophilia Hypothesis • Humans are innately attracted to other living organisms • Four aspects of the Natural World: Animals Plants Landscapes Wilderness • Evidence: Real estate Preservation Knowledge of natural settings increases survival

  4. Health Approach “Although everybody knows what it feels like to be healthy, it is impossible to give a precise definition; health is a subjective experience whose quality can be known intuitively, but can never be exhaustively described or quantified.” (Capra, 1983)

  5. Aim “To Characterise the influences of a wilderness experience on the individual health and wellbeing among tour guests on Fraser Island.”

  6. Research Questions • What are the influences of a wilderness experience on the health and wellbeing of tour guests on Fraser Island? • Is the degree of health benefit derived from a wilderness experience associated with: • Level of pre-existing health and wellbeing status • The length of the wilderness experience • Level of social connectedness experienced among group members

  7. Methodology

  8. Research Approach • Survey • Similar studies used this approach • Appropriate for time-frame and budget • Strengths: • Can measure extent & nature of phenomenon • Comparisons to previous studies possible • Survey can be replicated • One-day and Three-day Tour Groups (n = 216) • Cluster Sampling

  9. Questionnaire Design • General Themes were: • Motivations and Purpose • Perceptions of Experience • Subjective Wellbeing • Self-reported health status • Demographics • Face-to-face interviews • Brief and non-structured • More detailed perspective

  10. Data Collection Methods • Instrument: self-administered questionnaire • cost effective • closed and open-ended • effective for sensitive data • groups surveyed in a relatively short time • Limitations • varying literacy and language skills • questionnaires limit the ‘depth’ of responses

  11. Data Analysis • Quantitative Analysis • Descriptive Analyses to summarise data • Pearson’s Chi Square to compare 2 tour groups • Mann-Whitney Tests on non-parametric data • Factor analysis: data reduction • Pre-defined instruments as per instructions • Analysis of Qualitative Data • Responses collapsed into common categories

  12. Demographics and Characteristics of Experience One-day Group Three-day Group Equal Male and Female Older/Couples Younger/ Singles ¾ English Speaking Domestic International 83% First Trip Positive Perceptions: Higher Educational Qualifications Lower Educational Qualifications Scenery, Awe & Wonder Learning, Conservation Lakes, Relaxation Residence: House Residence: Unit/Flat Visitor Numbers more than expected Visitor Numbers about as expected

  13. Motivations for Visiting • • Top factors: • Relaxation • Nature • Personal • 4. Away • 5. Practical • 6. Culture Median (and mean) Scores of Motivational Items for Visitation to Fraser Island for One-day and Three-day Tour Groups 1 = not important; 5 = very important

  14. Influences on Health and Wellbeing Influences of a Wilderness Experience on Health and Wellbeing for One-day and Three-day Tour Groups on Fraser Island

  15. Changes in Health and Wellbeing > 50 - Positive change Self-reported changes for Fraser Island One-day and Three-day Tour Respondents

  16. Physical and Mental Health (r = -0.231, p = .002, n = 185) Association between Physical Health and Compatibility for all Tour Guests Association between Mental Health and Compatibility for all Tour Guests (r = 0.210, p = .004, n = 185)

  17. Personal Wellbeing Associations • Those who rated highly on the Personal Wellbeing Index indicated more positive change in their health and wellbeing (r = 0.199, p = .016, n = 147) Association between Personal Wellbeing and Negative Emotion for all Tour Guests (r = -0.159, p = .042, n = 166)

  18. Social Connectedness Associations • Social Connectedness • Trust • Reciprocity • Diversity …..is significantly associated with…… • Perceived Restorativeness Scale • Being Away (rs = .171, p = .020, n = 185) • Compatibility (rs = .161, p = .029, n = 184) • Fascination (rs = .208, p = .004, n = 186) • Coherence (rs = .234, p = .001, n = 184)

  19. Length of stay: • No significant correlations • Interviews: • Stated how their mood had changed • Suggestions – eg. more time, info booklet

  20. Limitations • Language and literacy skills of the respondents • Honesty from respondents, although anonymous self-completion • Data only provides a snapshot; seasonal variations • Survey may not have been adequate to capture the complex issues • Case study – only Fraser Island

  21. Summary • To Characterise the influences of a wilderness experience on the individual health and wellbeing among tour guests on Fraser Island • Self-administered Questionnaire & Face-to-face Interviews • The degree of health benefit derived from a wilderness experience… …is associated with: • Level of pre-existing health and wellbeing status • Level of social connectedness experienced among group members …is NOT associated with: • The length of the wilderness experience

  22. Where now? • Recommendations for research: • More empirical research with the tourist population; experimental • Increase sample size • Comparative tours that are much longer in length • Implications for the future: • Contact with parks and nature is affordable, non-elitist and highly accessible • Key stake holders (ie. Tour operators) can promote benefits

  23. Influences of a Wilderness Experience on Individual Health and Wellbeing: A Case Study on Fraser IslandBelinda WarrenScience Honours Student 2005Supervisors: Dr Anne Neller Assoc. Prof. Ron Neller

  24. Attention Restoration Theory • Grounded in cognitive psychology • Focuses on how the interaction with nature is important for effective mental functioning • Directed attention: requires effort; voluntary control; suppress focus towards a competing, more interesting activity; susceptible to fatigue. • Fascination, being away, extent, and compatibility – Perceived Restorativeness Scale

  25. Health Approach • “A complete state of physical, mental and social wellbeing, and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity.”(WHO, 1948) • “Although everybody knows what it feels like to be healthy, it is impossible to give a precise definition; health is a subjective experience whose quality can be known intuitively, but can never be exhaustively described or quantified.” (Capra, 1983) • Primary Health Care: emphasises social justice, equitable distribution of services, community participation & involvement, prevention, use of a range of sectors to respond to the needs of local populations.

  26. Current Body of Knowledge • Recent research: • Personal/commercial interest in wilderness experiences (wilderness therapy) (Frumkin 2001) • Predominantly Theoretical • US-based • Gaps: • Little Australian research • How long a wilderness experience is • Level of pre-existing health and wellbeing status • Contributing factor: social connectedness

  27. International Tourists • International Tourists • Australians • Australians Target Population Short-term Arrivals • Fishermen • Resort Guests • KBRV • Eurong • Adventurers • Independent Campers • Resort Visitors • Day Trips out of KBRV • Tour Groups • 3 Days • Guided • Walkers/Hikers

  28. Previous Activity and Main Mood Main Mood of Fraser Island Tour Respondents in Previous Four Weeks Previous Activity in Last Four Weeks for One-day and Three-day Fraser Island Tour Respondents

More Related