1 / 28

Conventional Facilities Status

Conventional Facilities Status. Martin Fallier, Conventional Facilities Div. Director NSLS-II Project Advisory Committee Meeting December 10 – 11, 2009. Outline. Baseline Scope, Cost, Schedule & Staffing Progress since CD-3 Approval FY09 Goals Technical Progress

Download Presentation

Conventional Facilities Status

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Conventional Facilities Status Martin Fallier, Conventional Facilities Div. Director NSLS-II Project Advisory Committee Meeting December 10 – 11, 2009

  2. Outline Baseline Scope, Cost, Schedule & Staffing Progress since CD-3 Approval FY09 Goals Technical Progress Cost & Schedule Performance Risks & Lessons Learned Look Ahead FY10 Goals Issues Conclusions

  3. Baseline Scope

  4. NSLS-II Site Plan N NSLS-II With Full LOB Build-Out 100 0 200

  5. Ring Bldg Overall Floor Plan LOB 1 Storage Ring & Booster Tunnel Experimental Floor Access Corridor Service Buildings LOB’s 1, 2, & 3 Base Scope Future LOB’s Earth Berm Lobby RF Injection LOB 2 LOB 5 Process Cooling Water Bldg Vehicle Tunnel LOB 4 LOB 3

  6. Ring Building Section

  7. Ring Building Perspective

  8. LOB First Floor Plan • 57 One person Offices • Two people Offices • Six people Offices • Wet Laboratories • Dry Laboratories • Machine Shop • Conference Rooms • 1 Loading/Storage Area Total = 38,000 gsf Each Lab = 480 nsf

  9. LOB Exterior Perspective

  10. WBS 1.5 Cost Baseline ($K) • Major Increases or changes: • Move CM Cost from Construction to CF Management – No increase –moved $6.6M • Increase experimental floor width & misc design changes– $6.4M • Actual award of Ring Building including safety incentive - $5.7M • A/E Title II changes and T-III field representative – $1.7M • A/E LOB redesign cost – $1.9M

  11. CF Schedule

  12. CF Organization

  13. Conventional Facilities Division Staffing

  14. CF FY09 Goals • Complete Readiness of Construction Mgt Team – Done • Award Ring Building contract – Done • Complete Bid and Award of Major Contracts for: • Electrical Substation Expansion - Done • Chilled Water Plant Expansion - Done • Chilled Water Piping - Done • Owner Furnished Equipment - Done • Begin successful execution of construction contracts: • Ring Building earthwork completed and start concrete & utilities - Done • Begin Chilled Water Plant foundations - Done • Begin Electrical Substation - Done • Begin CHW Piping - Done • Confirm LOB design plan & execute detailed design- underway

  15. Progress • Started Ring Bldg Construction (1.5.3.2) – • NTP March 25th, construction start April 15th • Adopted revised phasing plan accelerating Injection and RF Bldgs – no added cost • Mobilization went smoothly & ahead of schedule • Construction progressed ahead of baseline until combination of bad weather and adopting Torcon “Early Finish” schedule as baseline was done in July 09 • Ring Bldg has since regained most of schedule and baseline has been revised to be more realistic • 19% complete by cost after 21% of scheduled time complete • 24% of concrete complete after 5 months of concrete work

  16. Progress cont’d Photo From BGRR Stack 9-21-09 Vehicle Tunnel SR Tunnel Wall Forms SR Tunnel Slab Status of construction Site at FY09 End

  17. Progress cont’d Photo From BGRR Stack 12-4-09 Column Footings SR Tunnel Slab SR Tunnel Wall Forms SR Tunnel Walls Vehicle Tunnel Ring Bldg Progress from month to month is substantial Monthly billing is ~$4M - $5M

  18. Progress cont’d • Awarded Balance of Construction Contracts – • Awarded Electrical Substation (1.5.3.3) July 17th • Awarded Chilled Water Plant Expansion (1.5.3.4) July 1st • Awarded Chilled Water Piping (1.5.3.5) August 28th • Net bid results of three contracts were within $10k of baseline • Awarded balance of pre-purchased equipment contracts • All awarded on or ahead of schedule • Delivery of equipment for each procurement running about 2-3 months ahead of schedule

  19. Progress cont’d • 5 bay CHW Plant Expansion (1.5.3.4) jointly funded by BNL and NSLS-II • $9.2M NSLS-II cost for two bays/two chillers with total 2500 ton capacity • $8.7 M BNL cost for 3 bays for present & future load growth • Lowest cost solution for BNL & NSLS-II • Construction & ESH managed by BNL F&O • Contractor on schedule • Work quality, progress and safety performance has been excellent Chilled Water Plant basement with recently installed piping headers

  20. Progress cont’d • ARRA funds enable advance of LOB design, procurement & construction • Enables procurement during favorable market and early occupancy by beamline staff during beamline construction • Creates some potential contractor coordination issues • Have worked closely with Torcon to minimize impacts • A/E design nearly complete • Held contractor informational meeting – more scheduled • RFP to DOE for approval – expect release in mid Dec 10/11 3/10 8/13 4/12

  21. Cost & Schedule Performance • Schedule Assessment: Cumulative schedule variance $-647k on ~$52.9M or -1% - Essentially on schedule - SPI =0.99 • Cost Assessment: Cumulative cost variance $+2,355k on~$52.2M or 4.6% - Essentially on budget - CPI =1.05 • ~$2M positive cost variance due to A/E LOB design performed but not costed yet Data as of Oct 31, 09

  22. Performance Analysis • FY09 Performance • On budget and schedule most of year • Some negative schedule variance in July/Aug/Sept due to: • Use of Ring contractor early finish schedule as baseline with errors in schedule • Some weather impacts due to heavy rain in June • Combination of late award of other construction packages & errors in cost plans • Corrected Ring contractor schedule in September • Adopted contractor actual schedules as baseline for other construction packages in October • Back on schedule and on budget as of October 09 • Contractor schedule performance in the field is excellent

  23. Risk Analysis & Management

  24. Field Changes • Field change costs for construction typically range from 5 -10% of contract value • Post Bid Addendum – was issued after award to address known design coordination issues - total cost $3.1M • To issue this up front reduced risk of contractor delay and greater field change costs • Miscellaneous field changes to date are ~$970k and are due to: • Differing field conditions – undocumented utilities, legacy issues • Utility modifications for larger LOBs • Correction of design errors and omissions • Total ~$4M on $172M contract = 2.3% to date • Total without PBA ~$1M on $172M contract = 0.6% to date • Processing of field changes is slow and needs to be expedited • Working to speed up contractor proposal, price negotiation and PCR process

  25. Lessons Learned • Bid & award process for Ring Bldg was very successful • Using same methodology for LOB procurement • Use of optimistic contractor schedule in baseline is problematic • Use conservative schedule with clear critical path • Contractor safety performance must be documented and assessed regularly • Maintain clear safety performance requirements and expectations • Added early LOB work will require additional CM staff • Current workload is all that CF team can manage • Planning CM staff augmentation in Spring when LOBs awarded

  26. Conventional Facilities FY10 Goals • Maintain effective safety culture at all const. sites • Ring Building • Maintain effective working relationship with GC- pursue partnering • Construction on schedule and on budget • CF Construction Packages & Procurements • Deliver all CF electrical procurements on schedule • CHW Plant Expansion on schedule and budget • Complete CHW Piping on schedule and on budget • Electrical Substation on schedule and on budget • LOB Design & Procurement • Award LOB contract in March 2010 • Initiate LOB construction on schedule

  27. Issues • Continued focus on contractor safety performance is necessary to prevent significant injury or incident • Corrective action plan being prepared and adding Safety Eng to ESH team • Need to maintain close oversight of contractor schedule and maintain constructive relationship • Partnering meetings planned for Jan 10 • Process of resolving and implementing contract changes needs improvement • Need to reduce backlog of pending changes and improve cost certainty • Implementing changes to process to expedite resolution and issuance of C/Os • Additional CF staff needed when LOB is awarded to oversee multiple sites and multiple contractors • PCR being prepared for the added staff • Need to begin process of planning for transition to operation of buildings as they are turned over to ASD/XFD

  28. Conclusion • All goals for FY09 have been met, there has been substantial progress and LOBs are accelerated > 1year • CF is on schedule and on budget and CF Team is in place • CF risks are well understood and mitigation plan in place • 88% of CF construction costs are under fixed price contract • Plans for FY10 and beyond are well understood • CF well on track for early completion

More Related