1 / 13

Information Criterion for Model Selection

Information Criterion for Model Selection. Romain Hugues. Problem description. DESCRIPTION THEORETICAL BACKGROUND IN PRACTICE. Important parameters. We have N m-vector data a sampled from a m’ -dim manifold A. We want to estimate a d -dim manifold S .

hannah-peck
Download Presentation

Information Criterion for Model Selection

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Information Criterion for Model Selection Romain Hugues

  2. Problem description DESCRIPTION THEORETICAL BACKGROUND IN PRACTICE

  3. Important parameters • We have N m-vector data a sampled from a m’-dim manifold A. • We want to estimate a d-dim manifold S. • S is parameterized by a n-vector u constrained to be in a n’-dim manifold U DESCRIPTION THEORETICAL BACKGROUND IN PRACTICE

  4. Model can be described by: • d: dimension • r (=m’-d) : codimension • n’ :degrees of freedom DESCRIPTION THEORETICAL BACKGROUND IN PRACTICE

  5. Minimization and expected residual Max. Lik. Solution of problem by minimizing J: New Notation for residual with respect to model: Residuals for future data a* : Expected residual of Model S: DESCRIPTION THEORETICAL BACKGROUND IN PRACTICE

  6. Mahalanobis projection of Data: DESCRIPTION THEORETICAL BACKGROUND IN PRACTICE

  7. Optimally fitted Manifold: DESCRIPTION THEORETICAL BACKGROUND IN PRACTICE

  8. Evaluation of expected residual: WE NEED TO ESTIMATE I(S) DESCRIPTION THEORETICAL BACKGROUND IN PRACTICE

  9. Geometric Information Criterion AIC(S) is an unbiased estimator of I(S): Extracting noise level ε from covariance: Normalized residual : Normalized AIC : DESCRIPTION THEORETICAL BACKGROUND IN PRACTICE

  10. Model Selection S1 ”better” than S2 if AIC0 (S1) <AIC0(S2) If model S1 is CORRECT DESCRIPTION THEORETICAL BACKGROUND IN PRACTICE

  11. Model Comparison S1 ”better” than S2 if AIC0 (S1) <AIC0(S2) DESCRIPTION THEORETICAL BACKGROUND IN PRACTICE

  12. What should be done in practice? • Collect Data. • Estimate Manifolds and true positions for each model. • Compute Residuals for each model. • If a model is always “correct”, estimate noise level from residuals of this model • Compare two models: DESCRIPTION THEORETICAL BACKGROUND IN PRACTICE

  13. Situations when this is useful ? • ??

More Related