Aristotle International Integrity™ Age and ID Verification

1. Aristotle InternationalIntegrity™Age and ID Verification Presentation to ISTTF September 23, 2008 Aristotle’s Integrity™ ISTTF Presentation 9/23/2008

2. Overview of Integrity™ • Commercially Reasonable Age & ID Verification • Launched 2001 • 50+ million individuals verified. • 1,000+ commercial and government clients worldwide • Limits/prevents: - harmful contact between adults and minors - minors from accessing inappropriate content on the Internet - minors from accessing particular sites without parental consent - harassment, unwanted solicitation, and bullying of minors on the Internet. - adult solicitation of minors who willingly participate (solicitation not “unwanted”). • Since inception 7 years ago, no Integrity client has been fined or prosecuted for underage access after adopting the service.

3. 60 Minutes Report – November 20, 2005

4. Age Verification - Core Objectives To deter kids from acting older than they are Case 1 Child Registers with Correct Age Case 2 Child Attempts to Register with Bogus Details To deter adult predators from acting younger than they are Case 3 Predator Registers with Correct Details Case 4 Predator Impersonates a Child & Adult

5. Age Verification – How It Works Case #1: Child Attempts to Register with Correct Details • Child attempts to register. • 2. Site prompts for permission from a verifiable adult. • 3. Adult’s identity is verified for valid age and sex offender status. • 4. Access granted. • 5. Adult is sent a post card or automated phone call made to the residence.

6. Age Verification – How It Works Case #2: Child Attempts to Register with Bogus Details • Child attempts to register with fabricated or ‘borrowed’ credentials. • 2. Access denied, or, if parent’s ID is used, access is temporarily granted. • 3. Parent receives automated phone call or postcard alerting them to ‘their’ registration at the site. • 4. Parent suspends access. Child is ‘grounded’.

7. Age Verification – How It Works Case #3: Predator Tries to Register with Correct Details • Sexual predator attempts to register. • 2. Identity is scrubbed against registered sex offender database. • 3. Access denied or restricted.

8. Age Verification - How It Works Case 4: Predator Impersonates a Child & Adult • Sexual predator registers as a child, and impersonates an adult who is giving permission for that fictitious child to register. • Predator is denied access if the adult is fictitious, OR • Predator gains temporary access until the real adult gets the postcard or phone call. • Site suspends predator’s access & alerts those he contacted to the danger.

10. Age Verification • Against • Parents’ Responsibility • Added Cost • No Data on Kids • Gives False Sense of Security • Invasion of Privacy • Drives Kids Offshore • “Only 15% of our users are underage” • In Favor • Shared Responsibility • Commercially Reasonable • Not Required • Good Security Better Than None • Government-Issued ID • No Evidence • 15%? Without Age Verification, How Do You Know?

11. Contact Integrity John Aristotle Phillips john.phillips@aristotle.com (415) 440-1102