Federal policy discussion how do policy issues play out esea budget appropriations
This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
Sponsored Links
1 / 20

Federal Policy Discussion How do Policy Issues play out? ESEA–Budget-Appropriations PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 55 Views
  • Uploaded on
  • Presentation posted in: General

Federal Policy Discussion How do Policy Issues play out? ESEA–Budget-Appropriations. AASA National Conference Town Hall on Policy issues February 17, 2012 Bruce Hunter. Federal Policy Topics. Federal role in general Transformation, Reform or Improvement

Download Presentation

Federal Policy Discussion How do Policy Issues play out? ESEA–Budget-Appropriations

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript


Federal policy discussion how do policy issues play out esea budget appropriations

Federal Policy DiscussionHow do Policy Issues play out?ESEA–Budget-Appropriations

AASA National Conference

Town Hall on Policy issues

February 17, 2012

Bruce Hunter


Federal policy topics

Federal Policy Topics

  • Federal role in general

  • Transformation, Reform or Improvement

    • Can the current structure, and financing deliver the level of education desired by politicians, business leaders and policy elites?

    • Can any system deliver high achievement for 100% of students?


Federal policy topics1

Federal Policy Topics

  • Washington elites think standards based reform can deliver the desired outcomes.

  • What is standards based reform?

    • A list of what students should know and be able to do

    • A test or tests that indicate what students have achieved

    • Consequences for schools and school districts where results are deemed too low


Federal policy topics2

Federal Policy Topics

  • Growing chorus thinks the current system cannot deliver what is needed because it is:

    • Too focused on lock step student progress

    • Too focused on tests

    • Not focused enough on content

    • Isn’t individualized enough to deliver for all

    • Is very costly to individualize the current system


Federal policy topics3

Federal Policy Topics

  • So the current federal policy topics are

    • Should control over accountability, assessment and consequences be returned to states? or

    • Should NCLB carry forward but new acronyms? or

    • Should federal waivers drive state decisions regarding structure, accountability, assessment and consequences?

  • No one on the hill is questioning the current standards based format?


Title i structure

Title I Structure

  • HR 3989

  • Adds Programs to Title I

    • Title I

    • Migrant Education

    • N & D

    • Indian education

    • ELL grants

    • Rural

  • Senate Committee

  • Keeps current structure

  • Independent funding authorization

    • Title I

    • Migrant Education

    • N & D


Esea policy moves

ESEA policy moves

House Bills

Senate Committee

October 18,19 &20

Chairman Tom Harkin, IA

Ranking Member Mike Enzi, WY

Voted from committee 16-7

12 D’s & 4R’s

Floor - ? - Harkin says only when House has a bipartisan bill

  • Introduction Feb. 9

  • HR 3989 Student Success Act

  • HR 3990 Encouraging Innovation and Teachers Act

  • Hearing – Feb. 17 Jimmy Cunningham

  • Markup Week of 2/29?

  • Floor?


Title i structure1

Title I Structure

  • HR 3889

  • Permits shifting funds within Title I programs

  • Except

    • Not REAP

    • No funds out of Title I grants to LEAs, only in

    • No state approval,

    • but must be reported and included in local application

  • Senate Committee

  • No funding flexibility


Assessment and accountability improvements accountability

Assessment and AccountabilityImprovements -Accountability

HR 3899

  • States must establish an accountability system

  • Eliminates the impossible goal of 100%

  • Eliminates Adequate Yearly Progress, AYP,

  • Eliminates Annual Measurable Objectives, AMOs

Senate Committee

  • States must establish an accountability system

  • Eliminates the impossible goal of 100%

  • Eliminates Adequate Yearly Progress, AYP,

  • Eliminates Annual Measurable Objectives, AMOs,

  • Eliminates all or nothing scorekeeping


Assessment and accountability status quo accountability

Assessment and AccountabilityStatus Quo – Accountability

HR 3899

  • Disaggregation required - same sub groups

  • Reporting results by sub group required

  • School improvement grants for low performers

Senate Committee

  • Disaggregation required - same sub groups

  • Reporting results by sub group required

  • School improvement grants for low performers


Assessment and accountability improvements assessment

Assessment and AccountabilityImprovements- Assessment

HR 3899

  • Permits multiple measures

  • Requires tests that measure individual proficiency and growth

  • Provides adaptive assessment for students with the most severe cognitive disabilities

Senate Committee

  • Permits multiple measures

  • Includes computer based adaptive assessment

  • Requires adoption of new more accurate assessments


Assessment and accountability changes assessment

Assessment and AccountabilityChanges - Assessment

House Draft

  • Eliminates caps on special education testing -IEP team decision

  • Maintains current 1 year ELL testing requirement

  • Permits shifting to measuring growth, but keeps status testing too

Senate Committee

  • Eliminates the 2% testing cap

  • Changes testing requirement for ELL from one year to two years

  • Permits shifting to measuring growth, but keeps status testing too


Assessment and accountability changes graduation rate

Assessment and AccountabilityChanges – Graduation Rate

HR 3899

  • 4 year cohort graduation rate in accountability

  • State can elect to use adjusted rate for years 5 & 6

Senate Committee

  • 4 year cohort graduation rate in accountability

  • State can elect to use adjusted rate for years 5 & 6

  • Continuous improvement on track

  • Ranking schools required –identify the bottom 5%

    • Achievement

    • Achievement gap


Assessment and accountability changes teacher qualifications

Assessment and AccountabilityChanges – Teacher Qualifications

  • HR 3899

  • Section 1119 of Title I deleted –

  • Silent on teacher qualifications

  • HQT gone

  • Senate Committee

  • Maintains HQT language

  • Unchanged from current law


School improvement strategies

School Improvement Strategies

HR 3899

  • State selects school improvement strategies

Senate Committee

  • Transformation

  • Turnaround

  • Closure

  • Restart

  • Strategic Staffing Strategy

  • Whole School Reform Strategy

  • State Flexibility

  • Rural Waiver


Aasa concerns

AASA Concerns

  • HR 3899

  • Maintenance of Effort

  • Funding Cap

  • Equitable Participation

  • Senate Committee

  • Comparability

  • Foster Children


Aasa concerns other esea titles

AASA ConcernsOther ESEA Titles

  • HR 3890

  • Charter Schools

  • Vouchers

  • Senate Committee

  • Charter Schools


Fy 2013 obama budget proposal education

FY 2013 Obama Budget ProposalEducation

  • USED only non-defense funding increase -about $1.7 billion

  • $30 billion to retain, hire teachers and first responders

  • $30 billion to modernize at least 35,000 schools


Fy 2013 obama budget proposal education1

FY 2013 Obama Budget ProposalEducation

  • Level funds Title I and IDEA

  • Consolidates 38 programs down to 11

  • $850 million for RTT

  • $150 million for i3

  • $2.5 billion for teacher quality formula grants

  • $400 million for Teachers/Leaders Innovation Fund

  • NEW $5 billion grant program to reform the teaching profession


Fy 2013 obama budget proposal education2

FY 2013 Obama Budget ProposalEducation

  • Formula v Competitive grants

  • Reauthorizing ESEA through grants to states

  • Creating 50 even more federally driven SEA’s


  • Login