1 / 74

PLATO Society

Explore the role of Shi’ism in the formation of the Islamic Republic of Iran and its transformation into a theocratic government. Understand how clerics acquired a leading role in the revolutionary movement and the institutional framework of the theocracy.

delphia
Download Presentation

PLATO Society

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. PLATO Society Shi’ism and Theocratic Governance in the Islamic Republic of Iran January 18-February 22, 2019 Peter Krug Meeting Three (Feb. 1, 2019): Shi’ism and Revolution, 1970-1982

  2. Today’s Topic: • The place of Shi’ism in the formation of the Islamic Republic of Iran (“IRI”) • The IRI is commonly described as a theocracy • Theocracy: religious figures exercising direct rule, in the name of the divine, over civil governance.

  3. Weeks One and Two • In the first two weeks, our focus was on: • The distinctive elements of Shi’ism: popular religiosity, theology, and religious scholars; and • In pre-1979 Iran, the central role of the clerical estate in Iranian society, and the challenges its members faced in the 20th century.

  4. Today’s Session: • The 1979 revolution was not solely a religious one, but it resulted in the creation of a theocracy. Questions: • How did clerics acquire a leading role in the revolutionary movement? • Why, departing from Shi’ite tradition, did clerics decide to seek direct rule? • What is the theocracy’s institutional framework?

  5. Iran Timeline, 1970-82 • 1970: Ayatollah Khomeini’s “Guardianship of the Jurist” theory • Through the 1970s: Growing opposition to the Shah’s regime, which became more remote and repressive • Through the 1970s: Khomeini increasingly the focal point of opposition to the Shah

  6. Timeline, continued • Revolutionary Period, 1977-1979: cycles of demonstrations, repression, violence, and mourning • 1/12/79: A Revolutionary Council formed in Paris under Khomeini’s direction to organize the transition • 1/16/79: Departure of the Shah and his family for Egypt

  7. Timeline, continued • 2/1/79: Return of Ayatollah Khomeini; greeted by millions in the streets of Tehran (acclaimed as “Imam”) • 2/4/79: Lay Islamic reformer Mehdi Bazargan (1907-1995) named PM of provisional government by Khomeini • 2/11/79: Collapse of the remainder of the Shah’s government

  8. Timeline, continued • 3/30-3/31/79: national referendum on “Islamic Republic”, approved by 98% in huge turnout • 5/1/79: Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps established by a Khomeini decree • Summer, 1979: First steps toward marginalization of non- clerical coalition members

  9. Timeline, continued • 10/14/79: Drafting of new constitution completed • 11/4/79: Seizure of U.S. Embassy • 11/6/79: Resignation of the provisional government, including Bazargan, leaving uncontested authority of the new state to Khomeini and the Revolutionary Council.

  10. Timeline, continued • 12/2-12/3/79: Iran’s new constitution overwhelmingly approved in a popular referendum • 1980-1982: consolidation of the IRI amid internal and external violence • Secessionist movements; Mojahedin-e Khalq; war with Iraq (began Sept., 1980)

  11. Timeline, continued • 2/4/80: Election of Abolhasan Bani- Sadr (born 1933) as President • 1/20/81: Release of all remaining U.S. hostages after conclusion of Algiers Accords between U.S. and IRI • 6/20/81: President Bani-Sadr impeached • 12/15/82: Khomeini decrees stability as IRI’s official policy

  12. Howdid Clerics Acquire a Leading Role in the Revolution? • A broad popular revolution, with a coalition of social and political groups united against the Shah’s government • Clerics; mass religious following; secular intellectuals; leftist groups; students

  13. Background: • Social changes and cultural trends in the 1960s-1970s • Social changes: • Urbanization (in-migration from countryside) • Growth of middle classes • Expansion of higher education

  14. Resurgence of Islam • Popular religion: • Cultural identification of many urban lower and lower middle classes with the clerical estate • Clerics’ growing engagement with the masses: emphasis on preaching • Specific features of Shi’ism highly suitable for mass mobilization: e.g., imagery centered on Imam Husayn

  15. Resurgence of Islam (continuing) • Increased vitality of Islam among religious reformers and skeptics • Propagation of new perspectives on Shi’ism: • Non-clerical authors, including Ali Shariati (1933-1977) • Shariati espoused a radically populist, anti-imperialist theology of revolution

  16. Ali Shariati (continuing): • Shariati: a classless social order is a central principle of Islam. • There should not be social and economic stratification as the consequence of military, economic, and spiritual (clerical) domination. • Shariati’s ideas had great impact on students and lay intellectuals, contributing to the revolutionary movement.

  17. Cultural Trends: “Two Cultures” • Meanwhile, intensification of a “two cultures” divide, which began in the 1930’s with Reza Shah’s secularist policies (e.g., the unveiling campaign): • Traditional religious culture; and • Increasingly westernized upper and middle classes

  18. March 8, 1979

  19. How did Clerics Achieve Leadership? Summary • Nationwide network of local clergy and religious leaders • Widespread outrage over corruption, foreign influence, cultural change • Shi’ism provided cohesion and a sense of common purpose to disparate coalition elements • Khomeini’s charismatic leadership

  20. Why Did Many Clerics Seek Direct Rule? • In the 1970;s, many members of the clerical estate chose not only to participate in politics, but also to seek direct rule over civil governance. • What led to this development?

  21. Global Islamism • In the 1960’s and 1970’s, ideas of Islamism swept through the Muslim world • Islam should be the basis for civil governance • Among Sunnis, the leaders of this movement were lay intellectuals, not clerics

  22. Islamism in Iran • But in Iran: a Shi’ite variant of Islamism, emphasizing leadership of religious scholars. • Rekindled questions over the thousand-year tradition of political quietism among Shi’ite religious scholars (or, at most, leadership of popular movements (the 1890’s tobacco protests; the 1906-11 Constitutional Revolution))

  23. The “Authority Verse” • For centuries, the debate among Shi’ite scholars centered on interpretation of the “authority verse” in the Holy Qur’an. • Qur’an, 4:59: “O believers: Obey God and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you.”

  24. The “Authority Verse” • Generally, scholars determined that “those in authority” to rule in civil governance were neither temporal rulers nor religious scholars. These are not immune from error and sin. • Instead, “those in authority” refers only to the infallible Imams (Ali and his eleven descendants).

  25. In a commentary written in the 1950s and 1960s, an Iranian scholar, Muhammad Husayn Tabataba’i, stated: the Infallible Ones are those whose recognition depended on the explicit designation of God or the Prophet Muhammad, and to whom obedience was required.

  26. Ayatollah Khomeini: “Guardianship of the Jurist” • In a 1970 publication, Ruhollah Khomeini called for a departure from this interpretation. • He articulated a theory entitled “the guardianship of the jurist” (velayat-e faqih). • Note: an important source for this materials is S. Arjomand, The Turban for the Crown (1988).

  27. Guardianship, Traditionally • Previously, in Shi’ite law, this theory was limited to specific acts of guardianship (e.g., authority over child orphans and the mentally ill). • However, Khomeini asserted that guardianship of the jurist went beyond these specific types of authority: it includes a general delegation to rule directly in civil governance.

  28. Guardianship of the Jurist • Its basis was found in the role of religious scholars as deputies of the Hidden Imam. • Khomeini asserted that the scholars possess with respect to government all that the Prophet and Imams possessed. • All authority is sacred, including the political.

  29. Guardianship of the Jurist • It should be noted that this includes the Imamate’s emphasis on humankind’s need for divine guidance, and the central role of religious scholars (jurists) • Khomeini’s theory was soon adopted by many (but by no means all) Iranian clerics in the 1970s.

  30. By 1979, this basis for clerical governance was codified in the new Constitution: • Article 2: the “IRI is a system based on belief in continuous leadership (imamate) and perpetual guidance, and its fundamental role in ensuring the uninterrupted process of the revolution of Islam.”

  31. Constitution, Article 5: • “during the occultation the guidance and leadership of the Ummah devolve upon the just and pious jurist who…will assume the responsibilities [of the office of Supreme Leader]

  32. In an interview in Jan., 1980, a month after adoption of the new Constitution, Khomeini elaborated on the form that such leadership would take. • Clerics would not assume the top governmental offices; instead, it would mean installation of clerics in positions of supervision over those government officers.

  33. Khomeini’s theory led to intense debate in the 1970s among the religious scholars: e.g., Grand Ayatollah Kazem Shariatmadari (1906-1986)

  34. Shariatmadari (center)

  35. Arguments Against the Theory • 1.Authority during the occultation cannot be extended from the religious to the political sphere; and • 2. If there is such a duty mandated to the scholars, it is a collective authority of all jurists and can’t be restricted to just one individual.

  36. Khomeini won the intra-clerical debate in the 1970s, but the debate has continued ever since then. • Will be a recurring theme in weeks 4-6.

  37. Possible reasons why Khomeini’s “Guardianship of the Jurist” was successful: 1. Clerics’ distrust of liberal intelligentsia; 2. Many of the revolutionary clerics were former Khomeini students

  38. Institutional Framework of the IRI • Timeline for the IRI Constitution: • 1978-mid 1979: coalition drafting of a new constitutional text • August, 1979: election for an Assembly of Constitutional Experts • Most seats to clerics • August-October, 1979: final drafting • December, 1979: Referendum

  39. The IRI: • The only Shi’ite Twelver theocracy in the world • Pakistan (late 1940s): the world’s first (Sunni) Islamist state

  40. The IRI Constitution • Set up the system that still exists today • A complex hybrid of democratic and theocratic elements, with the latter dominant • Reflects the historical transition from coalition to exclusive clerical rule

  41. The August-October, 1979 drafting in the Assembly of Constitutional Experts: • Extensive revisions of the draft text added crucial theocratic elements. • These reflect the “guardianship of the jurist”, with emphasis on clerics’ “supervision” over actions of the democratic institutions.

  42. Democratic Elements • Presidency • Parliament • Local and regional councils

  43. Democratic Elements: • President (head of executive branch): • Responsibilities: • Implementation of the Constitution and direction of the executive branch of government, except for those matters that directly concern the Supreme Leader. • Heads the Council of Ministers, determining and implementing governmental policies

  44. Democratic Elements: The Presidency • The President is responsible for national planning and budget. • Is authorized to sign international agreements and obtain the approval of the Parliament.

  45. The President • Elected directly by the people for a four-year term of office; two-term limit. • Recent Presidents: M. Khatami (1997-2005); M. Ahmadinejad (2005-2013); H. Rouhani (2013-present)

  46. The Presidency: Qualifications • A religious or political personality; • Born in Iran and of Iranian nationality; • Administrative capacity and resourcefulness; • Good past-record; • Trustworthiness and piety: belief in the principles of the IRI and the official religion of the country (Twelver Islam)

  47. Democratic Elements • Government (Executive Branch) • Appointed by the (popularly-elected) President, approved by the Parliament • Subject to dismissal by the President • All Ministers are responsible for their duties to the President and the Parliament

  48. Democratic Elements: • Parliament (Islamic Consultative Assembly) • 290 seats, elected directly by the people and by secret ballot. • Four-year term (next election in 2020) • The qualifications of candidates will be specified in legislation. • Deliberations must be open

  49. Powers and Authority of the Parliament • Establish laws on all matters, within the limits of its competence as laid down in the Constitution. • Its ratification required for all international agreements signed by the President. .

  50. Limits on the Parliament • Prohibited from enacting laws contrary to the sacred law of the official religion of the country or to the Constitution. • It is the duty of the Council of Guardians to determine whether a violation has occurred.

More Related