1 / 12

Are pressure groups a threat to democracy?

Are pressure groups a threat to democracy?. Read the description of the BMA How would you classify it as a pressure group? How is it successful? What are the reasons for its success?. Sectional, insider group, protective. Doctors interests. Successful lobbying of MPs.

chester-tyler
Download Presentation

Are pressure groups a threat to democracy?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Are pressure groups a threat to democracy?

  2. Read the description of the BMA How would you classify it as a pressure group? How is it successful? What are the reasons for its success? Sectional, insider group, protective. Doctors interests. Successful lobbying of MPs. Supports public health initiatives. Respected by Govt, public, international bodies. Large membership-130,000. Got a lot of money. Effective use of committees. Brief politicians-specialist teams. Expertise. Finance public information campaigns. BMA – British Medical Association

  3. Why do we need pressure groups? • Traditionally pressure groups have performed a range of functions; • Means of popular participation in politics / nationally and locally between elections • Act as source of specialist knowledge • Act as intermediaries between competing groups • Important social function

  4. Examples; mencap – was asked by government in 2004 to coordinate a study into education / intervention for disabled children. Study presented to gov. in 2005 ASH – 2/3 of funding given by Dept. of Health.

  5. Why have pressure groups increased in importance? • Membership of parties has fallen. • Parties no longer represent interests of members • Development of new social movements led to increased numbers.

  6. Are some pressure groups more equal than others? • Main argument in favour of pressure group activity is put forward by pluralists. The most notable was Robert Dahl. They argue that society consists of many groups representing different sections in society and all have equal opportunity to shape government policy. • Opponents to this argue that this is a naïve attitude and that some pressure groups distort balance of power.

  7. Are some pressure groups more equal than others? • Dahl counters this by saying that power is dispersed between pressure groups to avoid a dominant group system, by doing the following; • Liberal democracies relatively easy for individuals / groups to enter politics. • Countervailing groups balance power • Even smallest groups have power to influence voters • Individuals likely to be a member of different groups.

  8. Criticisms of pluralism Pluralism • From new right • Certain groups are able to increase their size (unions) and therefore power, by offering inducements. • These groups do not exist for the common good, merely to benefit their members. • Elitists • Pluralists fail to consider hidden forces. British Motor Federation prevented a debate on road building until explosion of anti-roads protests in the 1990s. • Inequalities of wealth ensure that there is massively unequal competition. • State run by and for capitalist ruling class. • Most vulnerable groups not organised.

  9. Elitism Pluralism PERSPECTIVES ON PRESSURE GROUPS New Right Corporatist

  10. Pluralism Believe in competition Suffragettes Key element of civil society Neopluralism? Cater for diverse society Elitism Idea of corporatism appeals to elitist. Similar backgrounds Key decisions by small no. PERSPECTIVES ON PRESSURE GROUPS New Right Thatcher – dislike of organised groups. What was the point of representation? Corporatist 1960s-70s Co-operation between unions and employers Eg.CBI and TUC Social partners – Trade unions and employers in social dialogue

  11. This concept fits with which other theory on pressure groups? Policy networks • Policy network – a description of the different kinds of relationships between groups and government and the range of players (organised groups, national and European civil servants, academics) Issue networks Large, flexible and open networks of particular individuals in any policy area. Wider than policy communities. Grown since 80s. Policy communities Small, stable and consensual groupings, government officials and group leaders.

  12. Policy made in corridors of Whitehall between representatives of NFU and Ministry of Agriculture. DEFRA will meet with; European civil servants NFU Friends of the Earth Food manufacturers Academic researchers Consumer organisations Issue networksAgricultural policy Which of these is a policy community and which is a policy network. Explain why.

More Related