External examining and comparable processes in a selection of case study countries
Download
1 / 18

Rachel Crossland - Presentation - PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 253 Views
  • Uploaded on

External examining and comparable processes in a selection of case study countries. What processes do other countries use that have similar characteristics to external examining?. Countries considered. United Kingdom Denmark Germany The Netherlands Australia New Zealand United States

loader
I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
capcha
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about 'Rachel Crossland - Presentation' - bernad


An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript

What processes do other countries use that have similar characteristics to external examining

What processes do other countries use that have similar characteristics to external examining?


Countries considered
Countries considered characteristics to external examining?

  • United Kingdom

  • Denmark

  • Germany

  • The Netherlands

  • Australia

  • New Zealand

  • United States

  • Canada


Methodology
Methodology characteristics to external examining?

  • This is a qualitative study – it is limited and not conclusive.

  • It used five characteristics as a basis for identifying comparable processes in other countries:

    • Focus on the programme as a whole at the award stage

    • Occur whenever the programme is undertaken

    • Involve external input

    • Involve people from within or close to a field of learning

    • Monitor and moderate learner assessment.


Findings
Findings characteristics to external examining?

  • External examining, in the United Kingdom sense, appears to be a relatively uncommon method of quality assurance of higher education programmes

  • Externality in some countries is more likely to be “external assessing”, rather than “external examining”

  • Each country will use a variety of measures that, in combination, are likely to meet all of the characteristics of external examining


Comparable processes
Comparable processes characteristics to external examining?

  • Processes that met some (not necessarily all) of the characteristics of external examining

    • Self monitoring and moderation (within the faculty)

    • Institutional monitoring and moderation (outside of the faculty but within the institution)

    • Professional monitoring and moderation

    • Benchmarking (comparison of programme results, standardised tests)

    • State or government monitoring and moderation (quality assurance, government examinations)

    • Public and/or media scrutiny (rankings, marking controversies)


The past
The past characteristics to external examining?

The way a country moderates or monitors

learner assessment is the product of its

historical, cultural, political and, perhaps,

geographical context.


The future
The future characteristics to external examining?

The globalisation of education and

increasing emphasis on the learner may

further enhance the importance of

processes designed to make comparisons in

relation to standards and ensure fairness in

relation to students.


Comparable processes1
Comparable processes characteristics to external examining?


External examining
External examining characteristics to external examining?

  • The use of external examining is most prevalent in the United Kingdom and Denmark.

  • Denmark

    • Mandatory

    • External examiners are appointed by the Ministry of Science Technology and Innovation Involved in appeals processes

  • Also occurs, to some extent in New Zealand and Australia

  • United Kingdom – interaction with other processes


Self or internal
Self or internal characteristics to external examining?

  • A degree of externality can exist where there is a diversity of opinions and views.

  • The Netherlands

    • Examination Boards

    • set regulations for assessment, mediate between learners and examiners, general quality assurance

    • Independent from a provider’s management

    • Better off with external examiners?


Professional
Professional characteristics to external examining?

  • Align assessment with real-world industry needs

  • Variety of forms

    • Reviews of registered institutions

    • External examiners appointed by professional bodies

    • Administration of exams

  • The United States, architecture – samples of assessment against learning outcomes


Benchmarking
Benchmarking characteristics to external examining?

  • Periodic surveys

  • Standardised discipline testing

  • Benchmarking examinations

  • United States – major field tests

  • Netherlands – benchmarking examinations

  • Australia - measuring the gains of higher education

  • OECD – international comparative assessment of learning outcomes


Government
Government characteristics to external examining?

  • Quality assurance processes used in all countries – consideration of learner assessment will vary

  • New Zealand – Institutes of Technology and Polytechnics Quality, pre and post moderation

  • Germany, state examinations –administered in areas of public interest


Public and media
Public and media characteristics to external examining?

  • Opportunistic and sporadic

  • United States, Harvard and Princeton – reducing the % of honours awards

  • Rankings that include data on learner outcomes

  • Australia, Good Universities Guide – rates and compares institutions and fields of study against twenty criteria


Further consideration
Further consideration characteristics to external examining?

  • How should these other comparable process be used to complement or even replace external examining?

  • How can external examining be developed as a competitive advantage?


Contact details
Contact details characteristics to external examining?

Rachel Crossland

Higher Education and Training Awards Council

Telephone: +353 (0)1 6314567      

Extension: 139

Email: [email protected]


ad