1 / 21

ARGENTINA

ARGENTINA. The Boom and Bust of a Political Economy. Overview. Population: 41,769,726 Literacy: 97.2% GDP per capita: $14,700 GDP growth rate: 7.5% Unemployment Rate: 7.8% Pop. Under Poverty: 30% Gini index: 45.8 Inflation: 9% (official); 25% (unofficial) (221 in the world)

baird
Download Presentation

ARGENTINA

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. ARGENTINA The Boom and Bust of a Political Economy

  2. Overview • Population: 41,769,726 • Literacy: 97.2% • GDP per capita: $14,700 • GDP growth rate: 7.5% • Unemployment Rate: 7.8% • Pop. Under Poverty: 30% • Gini index: 45.8 • Inflation: 9% (official); 25% (unofficial) (221 in the world) • Exchange Rate: 4.30 pesos/$1 US • Corruption Ranking: 100

  3. Politics leading up to the Crisis Before Democracy • After Peron, there was a lot of political instability • 1955-1983 military regimes prevailed over the civil ones • Successive military interventions, and 5 military coups in 15 years • Ended after Malvinas The Return of Democracy • 1983 ->Raul Alfonsin (RCU) • $50 billion foreign debt • 1000% inflation • Plan Austral • Set-up a truth commission and went after the Generals responsible for the mysterious disappearance of 30,000 ppl.

  4. The Decade of Menem • The Peronist candidate was elected in 1989 • Foreign debt = $70 billion • Promised to restore economy • Privatization of industries • Convertibility Plan • 1 peso = 1 us$ • Middle class began to shrink • Olivos Pact -> re-election • Unemployment began to rise • Corruption & Scandals

  5. The Crisis • 1999: Fernando de la Rua, the UCR and Frepaso’s Alliance candidate, won the elections • GDP fell by 3.4 percent • Unemployment: 14% • IMF granted $40 thousand million bailout • 2001 -> Cavallo becomes Minster of Economy • Competitiveness plans • Zero deficit • Capital flight • Corralito • Carvallo & De la Rua resign

  6. The Aftermath • 2 weeks = 5 presidents • Eduardo Duhalde was appointed president • Provisional exchange rate of 1.4 pesos per dollar • “Peso-ification” • After months of no regulation, the peso devaluated by 80% • Population outraged Observations • Values of neoliberalism? • IMF’s role? • Convertibility Plan?

  7. The Reconstruction • 2003 Nestor Kirchner elected president & Roberto Lavagna, Minister of Economy • Exports boomed • Import substitution • Soybeans • Accumulation of foreign currency reserves • Maintained the peso devalued • 2006: paid debt to the IMF, $9.810 billion • GDP claimed back • 2007 & 2011: Cristina Fernandez de Kirchner

  8. Monetary Policy • Buildup of reserves • 95-98% in dollars • Hard currency shortage (coins) • Reliance on external capital to fund projects/investment • Martin Redrando affair • Key goal: return to global credit markets • Use of reserves and pension system to pay for projects

  9. Imports/Exports • One of world’s largest food producers, can feed their population 10 times over • Hasn’t developed markets for many goods • High tariffs on some and not others • Struggles because of lagging infrastructure and distribution networks • ISI approach • Restricting goods with domestic equivalent • Coordinated political campaigns against certain sectors • Energy • 100% of export revenue now required as domestic investment • Parallel quasi-governmental companies (ENARSA) • Junk ratings, political tension • Protectionist measures do more harm than good • 2008 and beef export tariffs • Massive consumer spending on food because of inflation

  10. King Soja • 3rd exporter worldwide • 55% of soy oil, 18% of beans • In 1997: $3.2 billion • In 2009: $16.3 billion • 95% exported (mostly to China and the E.U.) • Beans and final products make up 25% of total exports • Disputes with Brazil, EU, and China over tariffs • Half of farmland used for soy • No export tariffs on soy products, small tariff on beans • Low start-up cost, no capital, less labor costs • Monoculture; 98% genetically modified • No crop rotation

  11. Statistics control • Instituto National de Estadistica y Censos (INDEC) • 2007, Graciela Bevaqua forced out before 2007 elections, due to an inflation rate double of the numbers demanded by the government • Government wants to avoid shortage in liquidity related to bonds • Private inflation and other indexes banned by the government, with large fines • World Bank, IADB, others now use unofficial statistics • Poverty, food prices, investments, government funding all at different rates • Poverty is twice the reported rate

  12. Foreign exchange controls • 1/3 of economic transactions “in the black” • Half of GDP tied up in foreign bank accounts • If taxed and official, government can collect revenue • Tax collection rose 30% in 2011 • 80-90% of tested transactions not approved • 2011 controls • Instituted one week after 2011 election, days before going into effect • To buy any foreign currency: • National ID card • Tax code • Transaction must be approved by AFIP (Argentina’s IRS) based on previous tax returns • Intended to stop capital flight, control exchange market • Try to bridge gap between unofficial and official exchange rate

  13. Capital Flight • After Forex controls • Bank deposits down 13% in two weeks • $2.4-3 billion withdrawn • Currency trading • Before: $500 million/day • After: $350 million/day • 96% of flight in dollars • Return to global markets hampered • Real estate, big-ticket item sales grind to a halt • Higher domestic material costs, unclear policymaking procedures, rising inflation, byzantine labor and bureaucratic system • Estimated at $25 billion for 2011; $18 billion in first 9 months • More money withdrawn in 3rd quarter 2011 than any in the last 10 years

  14. The Future • Foreign investment will remain low • Policymaking decisions will not have a balance • Industrialization will continue, but specialization will not develop • Loss in credibility will continue to hamper the benefits of any social welfare policies • Will continue to question orthodoxy • New Peronist parties will solidify power

  15. Foreign Debt

More Related