Mary kickham samy reference renaissance conference denver co august 4 2008
Download
1 / 32

Balance of Power and Negotiation of Meaning in Virtual Reference Learning Environments - PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 82 Views
  • Uploaded on

Mary Kickham-Samy Reference Renaissance Conference Denver, CO August 4, 2008. Balance of Power and Negotiation of Meaning in Virtual Reference Learning Environments. Community of Inquiry Model: by Garrison, Anderson,& Archer. Literature Review.

loader
I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
capcha
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about ' Balance of Power and Negotiation of Meaning in Virtual Reference Learning Environments' - baina


An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript
Mary kickham samy reference renaissance conference denver co august 4 2008

Mary Kickham-Samy

Reference Renaissance Conference

Denver, CO

August 4, 2008

Balance of Power and Negotiation of Meaning in Virtual Reference Learning Environments


Community of inquiry model by garrison anderson archer
Community of Inquiry Model: by Garrison, Anderson,& Archer


Literature review
Literature Review

VR Librarian hesitating to instruct (Lee, 2004)

Students willing to be instructed (Desai and Graves, 2006)

92% - receptive

8% - “unreachable”


The theoretical framework
The Theoretical Framework

  • Critical Literacy Theory

  • Critical Information Literacy

  • Social Constructivist Theory


David ward measured session completeness by whether the librarian
David Ward measured session completeness by whether the librarian:

  • Asked student about number of sources,

  • Showed student a useful source,

  • Recommended search terms,

  • Checked that the student found the needed information


Summary of the literature
Summary of the Literature librarian:

  • Students are open to instruction.

  • Librarians want to provide instruction.

  • Students want to become independent learners.

  • VR environments are conducive to power-sharing relationships.


The main contribution of this paper is to examine
The main contribution of this paper is to examine librarian:

the activities and behaviors of the student and the librarian in the negotiation of questions and answers in a virtual reference session.


Research questions in two parts
Research Questions librarian:in Two Parts

Examination of

  • Balance in Participation and

  • Discourse Models - where they align, diverge and intersect


Questions one
Questions One librarian:

Is there parity of participation on the part of the librarian and the student?


Question two
Question Two librarian:

Does the number of questions asked during a session by the librarian, the student, or both parties combined affect the length of the transaction?


Question three
Question Three librarian:

Does the intensity of the student- librarian engagement predict the librarian’s assessment of the quality of the session?


Research design
Research Design librarian:

  • Data Source – 250 transcripts

  • Sampling – selected based on completeness of the transcripts and the demographics of the participants.


Research design variables
Research Design: Variables librarian:

  • Length of each session,

  • Librarian’s session-assessment

  • “Participation” variables, i.e. turns taken, questions asked, emoticons used.


Research design technique
Research Design: Technique librarian:

Analyses of descriptive statistics

Scatter plots, and

Tests for correlations and predictions.


Question one table 1 descriptive statistics for 7 variables
Question One librarian:Table 1.Descriptive Statistics for 7 variables


Findings question one table 2 number of instances of librarian and student activities
Findings: Question One librarian:Table 2. Number of Instances of Librarian and Student Activities.




What criteria do librarians use to evaluate a virtual reference session
What criteria do librarians use to evaluate a virtual reference session?

  • The amount of time spent?

  • The number of questions asked?

  • Emoticons used?

  • That perfect answer to a question?

  • Something else, not quantitative?


How do the librarian and the student work together to answer research questions in virtual reference environments?


Critical discourse analysis
Critical Discourse Analysis answer research questions in virtual reference environments?

An analysis of the way language confers power on some members of society and controls other members.


James paul gee critical discourse analysis
James Paul Gee: Critical Discourse Analysis answer research questions in virtual reference environments?

Two discourses:

  • our native discourse and

  • our acquired discourses


Excerpt 1
Excerpt #1 answer research questions in virtual reference environments?

Student: ty

Student: Thank you


Transcript #2 answer research questions in virtual reference environments?

Shared Discourse Model, Shared Vocabulary:

  • “user id,”

  • “password,”

  • “access.”


Transcript #3-1 answer research questions in virtual reference environments?

The librarian has an agenda. She tells the student what search terms and what databases to use. She also finds articles for the student.


Transcript 3 2
Transcript 3-2 answer research questions in virtual reference environments?

After the librarian finds the answer, a relevant article, she relinquishes power to the student.


Transcript #4-1 answer research questions in virtual reference environments?

A student asks which term is more correct?

  • Michigander?

  • or Michiganian?


Transcript 4-2 answer research questions in virtual reference environments?

Two Discourse Models:

  • The discourse model of the linguist – How do you say it?

  • The discourse model of the librarian – What do sources say that we say?


Conclusion
Conclusion: answer research questions in virtual reference environments?

Students and librarians aligning their discourse models to create a new dynamic Virtual Reference Discourse Model


Bibliography
Bibliography answer research questions in virtual reference environments?

Desai, C.M. & Graves, S.J. (2006). Instruction via instant messaging reference: What's happening? The Electronic Library, 24(2), 174-189.

Doherty, J. J. & Ketchner, K. (2005). Empowering the intentional learner: A critical theory for information literacy instruction. Library Philosophy and Practice, 8(1), n.p.

Ellis, L. A. (2004). Approaches to teaching through digital reference. Reference Services Review, 32(2), 103-119.


Bibliography cont
Bibliography (cont.) answer research questions in virtual reference environments?

Gee, J.P. (2005). An Introduction to Discourse Analysis (2nd.). New York: Routledge.

Gee, J.P. (2008). Social linguistics and literacies: Ideologies in discourses (3rd.). New York: Routledge.

Lee, I. J. (2004). Do virtual reference librarians dream of digital reference questions?: A qualitative and quantitative analysis of email and chat reference. Australian Academic and Research Libraries, 35(2), 95-110.


Bibliography continued
Bibliography (continued) answer research questions in virtual reference environments?

Ward, D. (2003). Measuring the completeness of reference transactions in online chats. Reference and User Services Quarterly, 44(1), 46-52.

Westbrook, L. Virtual reference training: The second generation. College & Research Libraries, 67(3), 249-59.

Woodward, B.S. (2005). One-on-one instruction: from the reference desk to online chat. . Reference and User Services Quarterly, 44(3), 203-209.


ad