1 / 16

The Wal-Mart Effect

The Wal-Mart Effect. Chapters 5 The Man Who Said NO to Wal-Mart. Chapter 5 – The Man Who Said NO to Wal-Mart. “They had the lure of Wal-Mart volume. Once you get hooked on the volume, it’s like getting hooked on cocaine. You’ve created a monster for yourself.” Jim Wier, former CEO, Snapper.

angelina
Download Presentation

The Wal-Mart Effect

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. The Wal-Mart Effect Chapters 5 The Man Who Said NO to Wal-Mart

  2. Chapter 5 – The Man WhoSaid NO to Wal-Mart “They had the lure of Wal-Mart volume. Once you get hooked on the volume, it’s like getting hooked on cocaine. You’ve created a monster for yourself.” • Jim Wier, former CEO, Snapper BUS-115 Introduction to Business

  3. Doing Business withWal-Mart • Being a supplier for Wal-Mart reorganizes the business to sustain ever-increasing need for more volume • Priorities end up skewed • Changes character of supplier company • Wal-Mart lowers value of product’s brand • At first expenses are cut • But eventually company goes into a “death-spiral” • “There’s no profit in that price, no room for reinvestment, for innovation, for rising health-care costs, or a sudden spike in … prices” BUS-115 Introduction to Business

  4. Snapper Lawnmowers • When Snapper stopped doing business with Wal-Mart, it lost 20% of its business • Short-fall made up by winning hearts of independent dealers • Well-made product • Long-life time • Service • Profit BUS-115 Introduction to Business

  5. How to Compete with Wal-Mart • Focus on things besides price • Quality • Design • Fashion • Total cost of ownership • Feel of shopping experience • Status • A higher selling price leaves more room for profit BUS-115 Introduction to Business

  6. How Snapper Competes • Focus on niche (something better) “We’re NOT obsessed with volume.We’re obsessed with having differentiated, high-end, quality products” • Emphasis on quality • Zero defects • Tireless attention to detail • Constant improvement BUS-115 Introduction to Business

  7. How Snapper Competes • Relentless focus on efficiency is as important as quality • Attention to detail and measurement • Productivity 3x what it was 10-years before • New lawn-mower every 109-seconds • Heavy use of robots • Small focus-factories w/in main factory • ½ the number of workers, job flexibility • Everybody’s performance is posted for all to see • Workers familiar with product • Paid to cut grass • “When you make a premium product, if you don’t control quality and durability, you have nothing” BUS-115 Introduction to Business

  8. How Snapper Competes • Manufacturers many of its own parts • Measures itself again rest of world but manufacturers products in U.S. • Distribution, inventory costs cut • Warehouse middleman cut out • Runs its own regional warehouses • Just-in time manufacturing made possible by predicting demand • Technology where it makes sense • Reduce labor costs to 10% • Removes China competition BUS-115 Introduction to Business

  9. The Wal-Mart Effect Chapters 6 – What Do We Actually KNOW About Wal-Mart?

  10. Chapter 6 – What Do WeActually Know About Wal-Mart? • Wal-Mart is very secretive with its data • Wal-Mart does NOT like to talk about its pricing effects • Short-run: Prices decrease by 1.5-3.0% • Long-run: Prices decrease by 7-13% BUS-115 Introduction to Business

  11. Has Wal-Mart Created More Jobs than It has Destroyed? • Wal-Mart’s success comes largely at the expense of existing retailers • Net increase of 100-new jobs in first year of Wal-Mart opening • 150 new jobs – 50 who lost other retail jobs • 4-retailers close within first 5-years • 5-years after a Wal-Mart arrives, average county has a net increase of 30 jobs • 300 Wal-Mart jobs – 250 retail jobs lost – 20 distribution jobs • 6 jobs per year BUS-115 Introduction to Business

  12. Wal-Mart’s Effect on Inflation • Grocery inflation rate in U.S. is 15% lower than actually reported by CPI • Wal-Mart has 16% of national market • Supercenter prices across 20 categories were on average 27% lower than at traditional grocery stores BUS-115 Introduction to Business

  13. Effect of Wal-Mart • Kenneth Stone, Economist, Dean of Wal-Mart scholars • In towns with Wal-Mart, sales of general merchandise leap 55% after 3-years • Small-towns within 20-miles, sales drop 13% • The losers after 5-years of Wal-Mart: • Grocery stores -5% • Specialty stores -21% • Clothing stores -18% • Winners • Restaurant sales up 3% BUS-115 Introduction to Business

  14. Effect of Wal-Mart • Kenneth Stone’s rules of thumb • Rule 1: merchants selling goods or services DIFFERENT from Wal-Mart benefit • Rule 2: merchants selling the same goods as Wal-Mart are in jeopardy BUS-115 Introduction to Business

  15. Does Being a Supplier to Wal-Mart Help or Hurt Your Business? • Reasonable profitability allows • Companies to hire talented people • Pay employees well • Do research and development • Respond to customer’s needs, Innovate • The more business you do with Wal-Mart, the less profitable each sale is • Wal-Mart either • forces you to get it together or • Pushes you to bankruptcy BUS-115 Introduction to Business

  16. Is there a Connection Between Wal-Mart and Poverty? • Stephan Goetz, economist • Should communities give tax breaks to encourage Wal-Mart to locate there? • Presence of Wal-Mart were correlated with increased family poverty rates in U.S. counties during the 1990s. • Rates of poverty fell 10% more SLOWLY in communities with Wal-Marts BUS-115 Introduction to Business

More Related