New Zealand Dairy Board
This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
Sponsored Links
1 / 84

New Zealand Dairy Board PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 181 Views
  • Uploaded on
  • Presentation posted in: General

New Zealand Dairy Board. Presentation to Select Committee 27 July 1999. Introduction & Overview. John Storey. Overview. Process Consultation International Market Situation Strategy Co-operatives Structure Interface with Dairy Companies. Importance of Dairy to NZ.

Download Presentation

New Zealand Dairy Board

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript


New zealand dairy board

New Zealand Dairy Board

Presentation to Select Committee

27 July 1999


New zealand dairy board

Introduction & Overview

John Storey


New zealand dairy board

Overview

  • Process

  • Consultation

  • International Market Situation

  • Strategy

  • Co-operatives

  • Structure

  • Interface with Dairy Companies


New zealand dairy board

Importance of Dairy to NZ

Dairy contributes22.2% of New Zealand's export earnings


New zealand dairy board

Process

John Storey

  • Process to Date

  • Process Going Forward


New zealand dairy board

Process To Date

  • Industry Strategic Plan August 1998 - Feb 1999

    • Rigorous process

    • Top consultants employed

    • Full Industry involvement On Farm to Off Shore Marketing

  • Industry Structure Project March -May 1999

    • How best to deliver the Strategy

  • Implementation Project

    • Dealing with legislation & high level implementation issues


New zealand dairy board

Process Going Forward

  • Legislation passed

  • Commerce Commission approval

  • Merger Proposal Agreed

  • 75% Merger Vote

  • Integrate merging companies into MergeCo


New zealand dairy board

Consultation

John Storey

  • Consultation to Date

  • Future Consultation


New zealand dairy board

Consultation to Date

  • 1998 October- November 15 response

  • 1999 March- Strategy

  • 1999 May- Structure

Overwhelming support for proposals

In excess of 10,000 at meetings (70% of farmers)


New zealand dairy board

Other Communications

  • Videos (Farming with Pictures)

  • Written Material - bi-monthly

  • E Mail

  • Information via Extension Services


New zealand dairy board

Future Consultation

  • July/August- Company-Supplier Accounts Meetings

  • September- Formal merger proposal to shareholders

  • September- Shareholder vote

  • Farmer final vote on proposal


New zealand dairy board

International Market Situation

Warren Larsen

  • Milk Production

  • Market Share

  • Access,Tariffs & Subsidies

  • Market Trends

  • NZDB Performance


New zealand dairy board

Milk Production


New zealand dairy board

Milk Production

World

New Zealand

Traded Internationally 5%

Consumed

Domestically

5%

3% Freely Traded

2% Quota Business

Exported 95%

Consumed

Domestically 95%


Major dairy producers

Major Dairy Producers

Cow's milk production (million tonnes)


Who are the major exporters

WHO ARE THE MAJOR EXPORTERS?


Major dairy exporters

Major Dairy Exporters

Cow's milk equivalents (million tonnes)


New zealand dairy board

Share of International Trade

European

Community

51%

Other 14%

Australia

12%

European

Union

38%

Other 20%

Australia 6%

USA 5%

USA 4%

New Zealand

19%

New Zealand

31%

1988-90

1997


Dynamics of the world dairy market import protection

DYNAMICS OF THE WORLD DAIRY MARKETIMPORT PROTECTION


New zealand dairy board

World Dairy Access & Tariffs

Access All Products/Low Tariffs (0-30%)

Product Specific Access/Medium Tariffs (30-70%)

Product Specific Access/Medium-High Tariffs (70-220%)

Only Butter/Cheese/Protein Quota Access/High Tariffs (>220%)


Protection from imports

Protection From Imports

  • Tariff RateAd. Val Equiv

  • $NZ/MT%

  • USA

  • SMP164459

  • WMP207574

  • Butter2927120

  • Cheese2365168


Protection from imports1

Protection From Imports

  • Tariff RateAd. Val Equiv

  • $NZ/MT%

  • European Union

  • SMP253995

  • WMP3173119

  • Butter4200175

  • Cheese3700115


Export subsidies

EXPORT SUBSIDIES


New zealand dairy board

Export Subsidies: Rates

  • Subsidy Rate%Export

  • $NZ/MTPrice

  • European Union

  • SMP129148

  • WMP194973

  • Butter3428147

  • Cheese193158


New zealand dairy board

Export Subsidies: Rates

  • Subsidy Rate%Export

  • $NZ/MTPrice

  • USA

  • SMP205087

  • WMP2760100

  • Butter212087

  • Cheese (cheddar)233967


Protectionism

Protectionism

Producer Subsidy

Equivalent

Consumer Subsidy

Equivalent

Milk

All

PSE

Milk

All

CSE

Commodities

Commodities

Australia

31

10

-31

-7

EU

61

49

-51

-38

Japan

90

74

-74

-50

New Zealand

2

3

0

-5

United States

52

20

-46

-10

Source OECD Secretariat


New zealand dairy board

EU has plenty of scope to expand


New zealand dairy board

European Butter Pricing (USD/tonne)

  • AEU guaranteed minimum priceUS$3072

    • Underpins milk price to farmers

      of NZ$9.00kg milksolids

    • Cost of butter to EU exporter

  • BExport subsidyUS$1768

    • Cash payment to export companies

      (not farmers) paid at time of export___________

  • CEuropean export price (A-B)US$1304

    • The price we confront in the market


  • New zealand dairy board

    European SMP Pricing (USD/tonne)

    • AEU guaranteed minimum priceUS$2137

      • Underpins milk price to farmers

        of NZ$9.00kg milksolids

      • Cost of SMP to EU exporter

  • BExport subsidyUS$ 936

    • Cash payment to export companies

      (not farmers) paid at time of export___________

  • CEuropean export price (A-B)US$1201

    • The price we confront in the market


  • Nz export markets

    NZ EXPORT MARKETS


    Nz s dairy export markets

    NZ's Dairy Export Markets


    New zealand dairy board

    Tariffs


    Impact of subsidies on world price

    IMPACT OF SUBSIDIES ON WORLD PRICE


    New zealand dairy board

    European Union Subsidy Change

    • The impact of EU subsidy changes between 1997 - 1999 for Cheddar, SWMP and SSMP =

    • NZ$498 million lost sales revenue to NZDB


    Nz product volumes

    NZ PRODUCT VOLUMES


    New zealand dairy board

    Share of Accessible International Market

    30%

    40%

    20%

    16%

    60%


    What does all this mean for nz dairy farmers

    WHAT DOES ALL THIS MEAN FOR NZ DAIRY FARMERS?


    New zealand dairy board

    Forecast World Production

    • USA- 2+% milk growth- low milk prices- feed to milk price ratio lowest in recent history

    • LATAM- 3-5% increase in Argentina- small increases in Brazil/Chile

    • Australia- 4-5% milk growth

    • EU- no growth

    • NZ- 4-5% forecast milk growth


    New zealand dairy board

    Global Dairy Industry Curve

    • Milk Cost

    • $NZ/kg Milk Solids

    • Austria

    • Italy

    • Germany

    • Netherlands

    • Brazil

    • Australia

    • Poland

    • Argentina

    • USA

    • France

    • NZ

    • Milk Production

    • Million Tonnes


    New zealand dairy board

    Globalisation Trends


    New zealand dairy board

    Milk shortage in EU, USSR/Afghanistan war

    EU relaxes domestic subsidies

    GATT round

    EU introduces milk production quotas

    Collapse of USSR

    Real Commodity Revenue (1997 NZD)


    New zealand dairy board

    Leading Dairy Companies

    13.5

    Company Dairy Revenues - 1996

    (US$b)

    7.5

    6.6

    5.8

    5.7

    5.5

    5.0

    4.6

    4.0

    3.6

    3.8

    3.8

    3.7

    3.2

    1

    2

    Meiji

    Kraft

    Snow

    FCDF

    NZDB

    Nestlé

    Danone

    Sodiaal

    Besnier

    MD Foods

    Parmalat

    Morinaga

    Campina Melkunie

    D Farmers of America

    Selected dairy companies = 25%

    Top 20 dairy companies = 35%


    New zealand dairy board

    Mergers & Acquisitions

    • Global dairy market continues to consolidate

      • Nestle acquisition of Bordens Klim

      • Friesland Coberco Dairy Foods merger

      • Formation of Dairy Farmers of America

      • Suiza Foods (US) 1998 acquisitions US$1 billion

      • Dean Foods (US) 1998 US$1.1 billion in acquisitions

      • Parmalat acquisitions continue 1998 US$ 625 million


    New zealand dairy board

    Global Retailers

    • Recent global retailer activities continue to consolidate

    • buying power for example...

      • Tesco (UK) acquires Lotus Thailand and targeting

      • Korea, Taiwan

      • Carrefour (France) expanding in SEA and Latin

        • America with 150 new stores by 2002

      • Ahold (Dutch) active in 17 countries up 62% since 1994

      • Auchan (France) active in 10 countries up 19% vs 94

      • Dairy Farm (HK) focus on Asia post UK divestments


    New zealand dairy board

    Functional Foods

    Stage 2

    Stage 1

    Stage 3

    Stage 4

    30%

    Medium size

    food companies

    Global food companies

    players

    Market

    Share %

    of food

    market

    Pharmaceutical

    companies

    J &J

    Novartis

    Unilever

    Mead Johnson

    Danone

    Nestle

    MD Foods

    NZDB

    Valio

    Time

    1994

    2010

    2001

    Entry of pharmaceutical players will drive functional foods

    to 30% of total European foods market

    Source: Promar International


    New zealand dairy board

    Growth to Date


    New zealand dairy board

    Payment for Milk

    2747

    +50%

    1836

    NZ

    $M


    New zealand dairy board

    Payout

    333

    310

    250

    C/kg

    MS

    Current

    Pricing

    Current

    Under common assumptions B/E milk price around 60c higher 10 years later


    New zealand dairy board

    Estimated CMP/Payout Spread

    Note 1 CMP for 1994/1997 sourced from BCG Performance and

    Efficiency Audit

    2 CMP for 1998-2000 sourced from Boards EBIT Reporting Systems


    New zealand dairy board

    Business Unit Volume (NZ Milk only) - 1998/99

    New Zealand Milk

    NZMP


    New zealand dairy board

    Business Unit EBIT 1998/99


    New zealand dairy board

    Comparative Revenue 1998/99


    Strategic response

    STRATEGIC RESPONSE


    New zealand dairy board

    Industry Strategic Plan

    Warren Larsen

    • Key Messages

    • Key Strategies


    New zealand dairy board

    Key Messages

    • To create the world’s pre-eminent dairy business which builds and leverages truly distinctive capabilities to capture opportunities on a global stage

    • Defend and exploit our core position as the world’s lowest-cost producer and seller of basic dairy products. This is our top priority

    • Take urgent steps to earn the right to grow outside the core

    • Pursue growth options outside the core (at the right time) by leveraging our unique skills to capture attractive opportunities

    • Consider options to tailor the structure of the NZDI to deliver the strategy


    New zealand dairy board

    10 Year Financial Aspiration

    • ROTGA 15% pa

    • Global revenues NZ$30 billion

    • Revenue growth 15% pa


    New zealand dairy board

    Growth Horizons

    Horizon 3

    Create viable options

    Profit

    • Industry biotechnology agenda

    • Risk management services

    Horizon 2

    Build emerging businesses

    Horizon 1

    Extend and defend core businesses

    • Industry Milks strategy

    • ‘Global slivers’ in specialised ingredients

    • Leverage our ingredients network beyond NZ Dairy

    • Defend and exploit core low cost position

    • Earn the right to grow

    Time


    New zealand dairy board

    Industry Strategic Plan Revenue Growth 1998 - 2008

    $ Billions

    30.0

    • $19 billion Horizon 2 & 3 ‘Non-core’ growth

    25.0

    20.0

    15.0

    10.0

    • $11 billion Horizon 1 ‘core’ business

    5.0

    0.0

    1998

    1999

    2000

    2001

    2002

    2003

    2004

    2005

    2006

    2007

    2008


    New zealand dairy board

    Industry Structure

    Tim Gibson

    • Current Structure Issues

    • Co-operatives

    • Options Considered

    • Recommended Option


    New zealand dairy board

    The Problem With the Current Design

    Industry configuration complex and politicised

    The success of the strategy demands fast, consistent, commercial decision making

    • The current industry organisation design will not realise full value from the strategy

    Traditional emphasis is on placement of NZ milk

    Many of the growth opportunities require sourcing of non-NZ milk

    Dramatic reduction in interactions cost driven by IT/communications revolution

    Current organisation design does not leverage dramatic reductions in interaction costs


    New zealand dairy board

    Why Co-operatives in Dairy

    Farmer

    Processing Company

    Milk

    - Un-pasteurised

    - Perishable

    - Worthless after 48 hours

    Factory

    - $100-150m

    - Worth scrap without milk

    Milk Vat

    • Farmers

    • Require a secure outlet for milk

    • Require a fair price

    • Have little choice today

    • Have highly seasonal supply

    • Processor

    • Requires milk to recover capital

    • Want to receive it on a fair price

    • Highly seasonal supply


    New zealand dairy board

    International Co-operatives

    • Co-operative Structures are used around the world to overcome bargaining problems in Dairying

    Co-operativeUS$ Bn (Revenue, 1996)

    Dairy Farmers of America7.5

    Friesland Dairy Foods5.5

    Campina Melkunie3.8

    MD Foods3.6

    Land O’ Lakes3.49

    MergeCo4.8*

    *Estimate


    New zealand dairy board

    Current situation

    Organisational trends

    Capital/Ownership

    Design Choices

    • External equity

    • Internal equity

    • Corporate gover-nance structure

    • Co-operative governance structure

    Ownership linked to supply

    Ownership delinked from supply

    Differentiated farmer payouts across NZ

    Uniform farmer payouts across NZ

    Four Capital/ Ownership Design Choices


    New zealand dairy board

    Current situation

    Organisational trends

    Four Organisation Design Choices

    Organisation

    Design

    Choices

    Multiple marketers

    Single Marketer

    • Multiple manufacturers

    • Single manufacturer

    • Vertically aligned

    • Horizontally aligned

    • Atomised organisation

    • Centralised organisation


    New zealand dairy board

    Thirty-Two Options

    Single

    Marketer

    Specialised

    Marketers

    Consumer with

    Merchant

    Ingredients with

    Merchant

    Commodity

    Competitors

    Merchant with

    Processor

    Fully Competing

    Marketers

    Single

    Manufacturer

    No integration

    Multiple

    Manufacturers


    New zealand dairy board

    C

    I

    M

    P

    Preferred Option

    Single company for processing, merchanting and ingredients. Consumer separate subsidiary


    New zealand dairy board

    Key Issues for the Commerce Commission

    • Fair Value

    • Governance

    • Local Market Competition


    New zealand dairy board

    Fair Value

    A Shares

    Q Shares

    MergeCo

    Tradability

    ShareSupply LinkEligibility

    A80-120% Amongst Farmers

    Qno linkageAmongst Farmers


    New zealand dairy board

    Governance

    • Elected using ward system

    Shareholders’ Council (30-100)

    • Farmer Directors nominated by Shareholders and/or Shareholders’ Council

    • Independent Directors nominated by Board

    Board of Directors (9-11)

    2-3 Independents

    7-8 Farmer Directors


    New zealand dairy board

    DivestCo

    Issue: Dominance of Domestic Dairy Market

    • Solution: Establish Independent Company by Divestment

      • 40% Market share in all key segments

      • Arms length, non-exclusive milk supply contract and established brands

      • Full manufacturing & marketing facilities


    New zealand dairy board

    Interface with dairy companies

    David Pilkington

    • NZDI

    • Milk Supply

    • Payment Process

    • Product Mix

    • Interface Inefficiencies

    • Governance


    New zealand dairy board

    14,700 Farmers

    800 Specifications

    NZ Dairy

    Research Institute

    More than 11 billion

    1700 Products

    litres of milk

    Sole

    Exporter

    8 Co-op Manufacturing

    More than 80

    NZDB

    Dairy Companies

    Offshore Companies

    Livestock

    More than 1.3 million

    Trading to over 115

    Improvement

    tonnes of product

    Countries Worldwide

    New Zealand Dairy Industry


    New zealand dairy board

    NZ Seasonal Milksolids Supply


    New zealand dairy board

    Product Acquisition Process

    • NZDB purchases all export product from dairy companies on the 20th of month following manufacture

    • NZDB manages inland transport, storage, ocean freight and export documentation

    • Basis for payment to dairy companies has just been reviewed (BDP - Business Development Project)


    New zealand dairy board

    Payment Process

    • Prior to BDP companies were paid:

      • a single pooled milk price (NZDB Base Price)

      • Modelled standard manufacturing costs

      • Capital cost or return on capital payment

      • Grade penalties or premiums

      • Differential payments to influence preferred product


    New zealand dairy board

    Payment Process

    • Dairy Companies paid to farmers:

      • NZDB base price, plus

      • Dairy company margin

    • Farmers judged NZDB performance through the NZDB base and dairy companies the margin

    • Dairy company executives focused on maximising their margin versus others


    New zealand dairy board

    Payment Process

    • BDP introduced Commercial Pricing Model. As a result dairy companies will be paid:

      • Commodity product price

      • Additional incremental manufacturing costs for non standard products

      • For speciality products a share of the NVA (Profit)

      • A distribution of NZDB margin over commodity


    New zealand dairy board

    Payment Process

    • Changes were introduced to:

      • more closely reflect commercial reality into the payment system, and;

      • to allow farmers to more transparently judge the performance of the NZDB


    New zealand dairy board

    Product Mix Process

    • NZDB collates market demand information and advises commodity price data to dairy companies

    • Dairy Companies decide their preferred mix of products to NZDB

    • Iterative process required to fine tune mix to match market demand


    New zealand dairy board

    Interface Inefficiencies

    • Individual dairy companies make their own product mix decisions based on their analysis

    • Several iterative steps needed to match combined result to market demand

    • Allocation of new products to plants debated widely

    • Dairy companies are drawn into non productive equity debates


    New zealand dairy board

    Current Ownership

    14,700 Farmers

    NZCDC

    Kiwi

    Northland

    Westland

    Tatua

    Tasman

    Kaikoura

    Marlborough

    58.2%

    27.3%

    8.7%

    2.7%

    0.8%

    1.5%

    0.3%

    0.5%

    New Zealand Dairy Board


    New zealand dairy board

    Current NZDB Governance

    Northland

    Electing Group*

    Govt Appointed

    NZCDC

    Kiwi

    NZDB

    * NZ Electing Group comprises Kaikoura, Marlborough, Tasman, Westland, Tatua


    New zealand dairy board

    Wrap Up

    John Storey


    New zealand dairy board

    Summary

    • Complex Industry

    • Huge benefit

    • Industry committed to make it happen

    • Co-operation assured


  • Login