COGNITIVE ABNORMALITIES IN POST-TRAUMATIC STRESS DISORDER. McNally 2006. Some Basic Background. PTSD is an anxiety disorder that develops usually in response to an overwhelmingly terrifying, often life-threatening event
Related searches for cognitive abnormalities in post-traumatic stress disorder
-also found PTSD participants to exhibit heightened amygdala responses
- Findings are supported with evidence from twin studies
Distortion of Recollection of Trauma the 1980s
For example, Southwick et al. (1997) concluded that veterans with higher PTSD scores “tend to amplify their memory for traumatic events over time”
The Spectre of the the 1980s“Phony Combat Vets”
Two main problem areas in studying Vietnam
Men who claim to be suffering from combat related PTSD but who either never saw combat, never served in Vietnam, or never served in the military at all.
For example: Keane et al (1998)
Guilt, shame, & Trauma combat-related PTSD are contaminated by the inadvertent inclusion of subjects who have lied about their combat trauma
Risk factors for PTSD: combat-related PTSD are contaminated by the inadvertent inclusion of subjects who have lied about their combat trauma
Can traumatic stress damage the brain? combat-related PTSD are contaminated by the inadvertent inclusion of subjects who have lied about their combat trauma
Brown et al. (1998)
“Approximately a third of sexually abused victims report some period of their lives where they did not remember anything about the abuse and later recovered the memory of the abuse”
i.e. they have repressed the event
- DSM-III symptoms of non-specific memory impairment
- Dollinger (1985) – lightning strike study
- Wagenaar & Groeneweg (1990) – Nazi Holocaust Camp experiences
- Williams (1994) & Femina et al (1990) – Sexual Abuse example
McNally states that it is not repressed memory that is occurring in these cases but memories being recovered…
Biased – Why?
McNally performed a study on 4 participant groups and found:
“repressed and recovered memory subjects do not exhibit a superior ability to forget trauma-related words on a directed forgetting task, contrary to hypothesis that they ought to be superior at blocking out memory for material related to abuse”
Is this really proof against Brown et al’s recognition of repressed memories in sexual abuse cases?
This example highlights the balance that must be maintained between science and politics..