H igh energy h igh intensity h adron beams
1 / 48

H igh Energy H igh Intensity H adron Beams - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

  • Uploaded on

Network. coordinated by W. Scandale and F. Zimmermann. H igh Energy H igh Intensity H adron Beams. http://care-hhh.web.cern.ch/care-hhh/. outline. HHH overview activities in 2008 LHC upgrade scenarios HHH workshops & results deliverables & milestones recent publications

I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about ' H igh Energy H igh Intensity H adron Beams' - ailani

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript
H igh energy h igh intensity h adron beams


coordinated by W. Scandale and F. Zimmermann

High EnergyHigh IntensityHadron Beams


HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN,17.09. 2008


HHH overview

activities in 2008

LHC upgrade scenarios

HHH workshops & results

deliverables & milestones

recent publications

HHH exchanges & results

crystal-collimation studies

two HHH highlights

Care hhh network
CARE-HHH network

Coordinate and integrate the activities of the accelerator and particle physics communities in a worldwide context, towards achieving superior High-Energy High-Intensity Hadron Beam facilities for Europe

  • road map for the upgrade of the European accelerator infrastructure (LHC and GSI accelerator complex)

  • coordinate activities and foster future collaborations

  • dissemination and outreach

WP1: Advancements in Accelerator Magnet Technologies (AMT)

WP2: Novel Methods for Accelerator Beam Instrumentation (ABI)

WP3: Accelerator Physics and synchrotron Design (APD)

Participating institutes:


Associated institutes:


Additional collaborations: Texas A&M U., U. Geneva, U. Bologna

HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

Activities in 2008
activities in 2008

  • past & planned events:

  • 3 main workshops (one per WP) [1 DONE, other 2 in November]

  • 1 joint HHH/US-LARP/BNL workshop on crab cavities

  • 4 topical HHH workshops (for APD): crab cavities, long-range beam-beam effects & beam-beam compensation, crystal collimation, electron cloud [2 DONE]

  • participation in other international workshops & events:

    • JPS meeting, Osaka, March 2008, invited presentation on LHC and the LHC upgrade [DONE]

    • ICFA Beam Dynamics Mini-Workshop on deflecting/crabbing cavity applications in accelerators, Shanghai April 2008; Yi-Peng Sun,HHH fellow at CERN, presented the LHC crab cavity effort with HHH support [DONE]

    • INFN Group-1 meeting in Pisa, September 2008

    • EPAC08, HB2008,…

    • International workshop on Multipactor, Corona and Passive Intermodulation, "Mulcopim", Valencia September 2008, organized by ESA; the workshop will address electron-cloud effects and their prevention in spacecrafts and accelerators; HHH will send 3 persons

    • Channeling 2008, Erice, November 2008. The workshop will address crystal-particle interaction phenomena

HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

Activities in 2008 cont d
activities in 2008 cont’d

  • dissemination and outreach:

  • various events/workshops organized by/with physicists from LHC experiments, e.g.

    • presentation for LHCb Upgrade working group August 2008;

    • participation in, and presentation at, “Physics at CMS” workshop, Split 25 Sept.-3 Oct. 2008;

    • involvement of experiments’ representatives in HHH workshops

  • contributions to EPAC’08, HB2008, and other events; seminars at EU universities

  • further extensions of SC & accelerator physics codes databases

  • maintenance and development of HHH web sites

    • exchanges and education:

    • visits of CERN accelerator physicists to other labs

    • support of EU or non-EU (US, J, Russia,...) scientists for visits to CERN

    • support of one PhD student and of two summer students working for the SC database

    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    LHC upgrade stages

    “phase-1” 2013:

    new triplets, D1, TAS, b*=0.25 m in IP1 & 5,

    reliable LHC operation at ~2-3x luminosity;

    beam from new Linac4

    “phase-2” 2017:

    target luminosity 10x nominal,

    possibly Nb3Sn triplet & b*~0.15 m

    complementary measures 2010-2017:

    e.g. long-range beam-beam compensation, crab cavities,

    new/upgraded injectors, advanced collimators, lower emittance,

    coherent e- cooling??, e- lenses??

    longer term (2020?): energy upgrade, LHeC,…

    + injector


    phase-2 might be just phase-1 plus complementary measures

    Lhc upgrade paths
    LHC upgrade paths


    early separation (ES)

    full crab crossing


    stronger triplet magnets

    stronger triplet magnets

    D0 dipole


    crab cavity


    crab cavity

    larger-aperture triplet magnets

    large Piwinski

    angle (LPA)



    reviewed by LHCC,

    1 July 2008

    HHH, CARE’07, CERN, October 29-31, 2007

    large Piwinski angle (LPA)

    full crab crossing (FCC)

    early separation (ES)

    Experimenters choice lhcc july 2008
    experimenters’ choice(LHCC July 2008)

    • no accelerator components inside detector

    • lowest possible event pile up

    • possibility of easy luminosity levelling

    • → full crab crossing upgrade


    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    Present and future lhc injectors
    present and future LHC injectors

    Proton flux / Beam power



    50 MeV

    160 MeV



    1.4 GeV

    4 GeV

    (LP)SPL: (Low Power) Superconducting Proton Linac (4-5 GeV)

    PS2: High Energy PS

    (~ 5 to 50 GeV – 0.3 Hz)

    SPS+: Superconducting SPS

    (50 to1000 GeV)

    SLHC: “Superluminosity” LHC

    (up to 1035 cm-2s-1)

    DLHC: “Double energy” LHC

    (1 to ~14 TeV)


    26 GeV


    50 GeV

    Output energy



    450 GeV

    1 TeV

    LHC /



    7 TeV

    ~ 14 TeV

    Roland Garoby, LHCC 1July ‘08

    Layout of the new injectors
    layout of the new injectors






    R. Garoby, CARE-HHH BEAM07, October’07; L. Evans, LHCC, 20 Feb ‘08

    Forecast peak integrated luminosity evolution
    forecast peak & integrated luminosity evolution

    New injectors + IR upgrade phase 2

    ATLAS will need ~18 months shutdown

    Goal for ATLAS Upgrade:

    3000 fb-1 recorded

    cope with ~400 pile-up events each BC

    Collimation phase 2

    Linac4 + IR upgrade phase 1

    M. Nessi, CARE-HHH LHC crab-cavity validation mini-workshop August 2008, R. Garoby, LHCC July 08

    lower beam emittance

    • can compensate for luminosity loss due to

    • large crossing angle [R. Garoby]

    • may be provided by new injectors

    • and/or by “coherent e- cooling” [V. Litvinenko]


    damping times in hours:

    CeC proof-of-



    at RHIC in


    promise of

    1-hr damping

    time at 7 TeV!

    strategy for “phase 2”

    • pursue vigorous R&D program for larger-aperture higher-field magnets

    • parallel crab-cavity development and testing

    • design, production & installation of wire compensator already in phase-0

    • exploration of complementary schemes, like crab waist, coherent e-cooling, e-lenses, crystal collimation; integrate them into upgrade plan when they become available

    • establish generation method long flat bunches

    • identify main limitations of the real LHC

    • LHC machine studies to explore upgrade scenarios, e.g. large Piwinski angle

    • close coordination with detector upgrades

    Workshops since care07
    workshops since CARE07

    • 19-20 November: CARE-HHH-AMT workshop onHeat Generation and Heat Transfer in Superconducting Magnets (THERMOMAG’07), Paris, 2 days (about 70 participants)

      • minimizing and evacuating heat in the next generation of superconducting magnets for high intensity particle accelerators, such as the IR magnet for the LHC luminosity upgrade and the fast cycling magnets for FAIR and for the LHC injector chain upgrade;

      • identify the state of the art on

        • (1) cooling techniques (fluids and regimes),

        • (2) heat transfer mechanisms,

        • (3) modeling of heat transfer from coils to cooling system,

        • (4) heat transfer experiments; identify a common set of thermal design criteria


    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    Workshops since care071
    workshops since CARE07

    • 5th CARE-HHH-ABIworkshop on Schottky, Tune and Chromaticity Diagnostic (with real time feedback)(about 30 participants),  Chamonix, France, 11 - 13 December 2007, supported by HHH

    • Joint BNL/CARE-HHH/US-LARPworkshop on LHC crab cavities (LHC-CC08), BNL, 25-26 February 2008 (about 30 participants) - 3 persons attended with HHH support

    • http://adweb.desy.de/mdi/CARE/chamonix/abi_workshop_2007.htm

    • results on online tune & chromaticity measurements

    • preparation for an overall orbit, tune & chromaticity control at LHC

    • deformation of Schottky sidebands due to space charge

    • http://prst-ab.aps.org/pdf/PRSTAB/v11/i7/e074202


    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    Amt workshop
    AMT workshop

    • 19-23 May: CARE-HHH-AMT workshop onAccelerator Magnets, Superconductor, Design and Optimization (WAMSDO’08), CERN, 5 days, 107 participants

    • Main topics:

      • summary of magnet targets and specifications for future accelerators and accelerator upgrades, in particular for the LHC upgrade;

      • advances on low- and high-Tcs.c. materials and cables, with special attention to progress in Nb3Sn, low-loss Nb-Ti and coated conductors;

      • design, optimization and R&D for s.c. magnets and other devices, in particular the high field dipoles and quadrupoles for the LHC IR and fast cycled synchrotron magnets.


    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    Deflecting Cavity Workshop

    ICFA Beam Dynamics Mini-Workshop on Deflecting/Crabbing Cavity Applications in Accelerators

    April 23-25, 2008 at SINAP, Shanghai

    • Topics:

    • deflecting/crabbing cavity R&D in the applications of:

    • high energy colliders (ILC, LHC, KEK-B, CLIC, …)

    • generation of short x-ray pulse in synchrotron light sources

    • beam manipulations, emittance exchanges and diagnostics


    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    HHH workshop series summer and fall 2008

    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    crab cavity motivation

    “Piwinski angle”


    luminosity reduction factor

    without crab cavity


    effective beam

    size s→s/Rf

    “LPA” upgrade



    Care hhh lhc crab cavity validation mini workshop 21 august 2008




    CARE-HHHLHC Crab Cavity Validation Mini-Workshop, 21 August 2008

    first use in operating

    ring collider 2007

    crabbed beams in KEKB

    Bob Palmer

    • KEKB experience

    • R&D plan

    • phased approach:

    • (1) prototype

    • (2) “global” crab cavity test in IR4,

    • (3) “local” crab cavities in IR1 & 5

    • EuCARD, US-LARP & international collaboration


    global crab


    local crab

    global & local schemes considered for LHC

    crab-cavity prototype tentative schedule


    T. Linnecar, HHH Crab-Cavity Validation Workshop

    HHH, CARE’07, CERN, October 29-31, 2007

    long-range beam-beam compensation

    LR beam-beam in LHC



    in the SPS

    G. Sterbini, J.-P. Koutchouk U. Dorda, et al, SPS MD August 2008

    inverse relative loss at various tunes



    distance [mm]

    (s~1.3 mm)

    high-Tc s.c. compensator

    A.Ballarino, CARE-HHH

    mini-workshop, 28 August 2008

    MgB2 conductor


    two-stage pulse tube cryocooler

    Ex-situ, 1.1 mm 

    MgB2 wire (Columbus)

    Ic (A)

    cryostat around

    cold beam pipe

    B (T)

    electron lens

    use of e-lens as tune-spread compressor improves

    simulated LHC beam lifetime (phase to IP important)




    on beam-beam


    28 August 2008


    Mulcopim 2008

    international workshop on Multipactor,Corona,&Passive Intermodulation Valencia, 24-26 Sept.’08, organized by European Space Agency (ESA)

    • meeting place for researchers, designers, test engineers and users of any space high-power RF hardware

    • design and testing of high power RF hardware for the prevention of RF breakdown (Multipactor and Corona) and Passive Intermodulation

    • main topics:


    •  high power RF hardware design •  innovative testing techniques (facilities, detection methods, etc...) •  theoretical investigations in the multipactor physics •  surface coating & secondary emission: measurements and theory •  simulation and prediction tools •  multicarrier operation •  electron cloud effects •  multipactor in particle accelerators •  power and frequency trends •  harmonisation and standardisation

    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    e-cloud mitigation

    Evaporation of metals in relatively high pressure of a rare gas produces very rough and porous films. Already mentioned in the literature, “gold black” has been produced and characterized.

    Gold black deposited by evaporation in Kr (0.5 mbar)


    P. Chiggiato

    et al


    graphite coating on

    black gold substrate

    for PS2 and

    SPS upgrade;

    effort triggered

    by HHH ECL’2 workshop

    no dependence on time of exposure to air

    Deliverables milestones
    deliverables & milestones

    • deliverables

      • 2004: HHH & HHH-APD web sites => OK

      • 2005: creation of first web-based beam dynamics code repository => OK http://oraweb.cern.ch:9000/pls/hhh/code_website.startup

      • 2007: web based database for s.c. cables and magnets concluded http://sdb.web.cern.ch/sdb => OK

      • 2008: final report – after final workshop

      • milestones:

      • web reference for IR optics => OKhttp://care-hhh.web.cern.ch/care-hhh/SuperLHC_IRoptics/IRoptics.html

      • booster synchrotron optics => in progress

      • structured list of intensity limits => OK http://care-hhh.web.cern.ch/care-hhh/Intensity%20Limits/intensity-limits.htm

      • scaling laws for magnet and cryogenic cost => 2008

    2 summer students

    + 1 doctoral student

    for further updates

    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    Recent publications presentations end of 2007
    recent publications & presentations, end of 2007

    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    Recent publications presentations 2008
    recent publications & presentations, 2008

    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    Recent publications presentations 2008 cont d
    recent publications & presentations, 2008 cont’d

    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    Recent care hhh workshop proceedings 2008
    recent CARE-HHH workshop proceedings, 2008

    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    Apd exchanges
    APD exchanges

    • 3-week visit by Mauro Pivi (SLAC) to CERN for electron-cloud studies in March 2008, mostly supported by HHH:

      • completion and benchmarking a novel simulation code "CMAD" for the detailed modeling of electron-cloud effects in LHC &SPS against simulations by the simpler code "HEADTAIL" considering a toy model

      • setting up of serial and parallel CMAD electron-cloud computations for the actual MAD optics of both LHC and SPS on the CERN linux cluster

      • discussions on possible electron-cloud countermeasures for the SPS upgrade, including the pertinent R&D program undertaken at PEP-II and CESR-TA

    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    Apd exchanges cont d
    APD exchanges cont’d

    • 4-week visit by KazuhitoOhmi (KEK) to CERN for crab-cavity & beam-beam & nonlinear optics studies in August 2008, mostly supported by HHH:

      • strong-strong and weak-strong beam-beam simulations for LHC upgrade scenarios

      • LHC crab-cavity noise tolerances from simulations

      • KEKB crab-cavity experience & simulations

      • various applications of crab-waist sextupolesto the LHC upgrade (factor 3 luminosity gain for ultra-low beta* , possible use for mitigating long-range beam-beam effects, or collimation)

    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    “crab-waist” collisions at DAFNE

    (note: no crab cavities but sextupoles!)

    C. Milardi






    can we make

    use of

    crab waists

    at the LHC?

    w/o crab waist

    current product

    C rab waist in lhc
    crab waist in LHC?

    K. Ohmi

    one example:

    f=3.5 in LPA option

    by squeezed to sx/f=2.1cm (extreme!)

    → L increases (14/2.1)1/2=2.6 times

    → xy decreases and xx is small for LPA

    → “crab waist has a chance to work!”



    28 August ‘08


    Crab waist collisions
    crab-waist collisions

    K. Ohmi


    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    Crab waist to push beam halo away from opposing beam
    “crab-waist” to push beam halo away from opposing beam


    K. Ohmi

    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    Apd exchanges cont d 2
    APD exchanges cont’d - 2

    • 1-week visit by Ulrich Dorda (Vienna) to CERN for participation in long-range beam-beam compensation experiments at the SPS & and HHH topical workshop in August 2008, supported by HHH:

      • tune sensitivity of compensation

      • lifetime vs. distance power laws & WP dependence

      • “threshold” for collisions at reduced distance

      • simulations of long-range beam-beam experiments

      • “RF compensator”

    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    Apd exchanges cont d 3
    APD exchanges cont’d - 3

    • 4-week visit by Rama Calaga (BNL) to CERN for advancing crab-cavity design in October 2008, partially supported by HHH

    • 4-week visit by A. Tarantin (Dubna) to CERN for modeling the SPS crystal experiments in summer 2008, partially supported by HHH

    • short-term visits by Erik Vallazza (INFN Trieste) and MichelaPrest (U. Insubria) for participation in SPS H8RD22 crystal experiments

    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    Amt exchanges
    AMT exchanges

    APD exchanges cont’d - 4

    • planned 4-week visit by ChandraBhat (FNAL) to CERN for developing a scheme to generate long, flat, intense “LPA” bunches in the upgraded injector complex

    • 1-week visits by M. Wilson (UK) and M. Jewell (Florida) for participation in WAMSDO workshop, partially supported by HHH

    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    2007 crystal experiments

    • Seven weeks of CERN H8-SPS runs

      • goals:

        • test multi-strip crystals,

        • check the effect on electron and positrons,

        • dry-run for the equipment to be installed in the SPS

    • Participation in crystal collimation experiment at FNAL

    • Proposal of 2008 test in the CERN-SPS ring

    • Support:


      Russian Foundation for Basic Research,

      CERN AB and AT Departments, FNAL

    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    2008 crystal experiments

    crystal deflection

    of negative pions

    and muons in

    the SPS North


    W. Scandale et al


    future experiment

    in SPS ring proper

    approved by

    Research Board

    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    Channeling 2008

    international workshop on Charged and Neutral Particles Channeling Phenomena, October 25 - November 1, 2008 Erice (Trapani - Sicily), Italy , organized by INFN-LNF in cooperation with HADRON PHYSICS I3 , CARE HHH , and LPI RAS



    • coherent scattering of relativistic charged particles in matter

    • radiation of relativistic charged particles in periodic structures (coherent bremsstrahlung, channeling radiation, resonant transition radiation, diffraction radiation, parametric x-ray radiation, LPM effect)

    • crystal channeling, volume capture and crystal reflection of positive ions: theory and experiments; crystal assisted collimation in hadron colliders: proposals and experimental observations

    • channeling of radiations in capillary systems (micro- and nano-channeling, nanotubes, nanoporous)

    • novel types of sources for electromagnetic radiation (FEL, Thomson scattering, laser plasma acceleration)

    • applications of channeling phenomena (bending of the beams, positron sources, powerful radiation sources, x-ray waveguides, capillary/polycapillary optics, novel x-ray table-top instruments)

    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    2008 gantt chart - 1

    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    2008 gantt chart - 2

    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008

    2008 HHH highlights

    crystal collimation update

    (results from 2008 SPS+FNAL experiments

    + newly approved experiment in SPS proper)

    [W. Scandale or collaborator]

    LHC crab cavities

    [R. Calaga or J. Tuckmantel or Frank Z.,…]

    HHH, CARE’07, CERN, October 29-31, 2007

    Conclusions hhh2008
    Conclusions – HHH2008

    • numerous high-impact workshops concluding 5 years of HHH activity, preparation of summary report

    • in 2008 so far 12 CARE-Conf docs + 2 CARE Notes several more in the pipeline

    • maintain focused efforts in many frontier areas

    • - crystal collimation, slim magnets, e-cloud suppression, LHC crab cavities, beam-beam compensation, novel optics design schemes, fast cycling s.c. magnets, new beam diagnostics

    • results benefit global accelerator community

    • - code repository, s.c. database, intensity limits

    • sustained strong dissemination & training effort

    • - mutual visits between partner labs, publications, seminars, web pages, many summer students and graduate students

    HHH, CARE Meeting, CERN, 17.09. 2008