1 / 13

Sociological and Criminological Perspectives

Crime, Deviance, and Problem Gambling: A Look at Some of the Sociological Yesterdays, Todays, and Tomorrows Bo Jason Bernhard, Ph.D. (cand.) University of Nevada, Las Vegas March 9, 2002. Sociological and Criminological Perspectives. Who “fits”? Who doesn’t?

Download Presentation

Sociological and Criminological Perspectives

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Crime, Deviance, and Problem Gambling:A Look at Some of the Sociological Yesterdays, Todays, and TomorrowsBo Jason Bernhard, Ph.D. (cand.)University of Nevada, Las VegasMarch 9, 2002

  2. Sociological and Criminological Perspectives • Who “fits”? Who doesn’t? • Who is “normal”? Who is “deviant”? • Who is “good”? Who is “bad”? • Criminal justice systems determine this… • … so does the institution of religion • … and so does psychiatry

  3. Crime and Gambling Problems:A Sociological History • The Sociological Questions: Who defines a problem? How do we identify a problem? Which/whose criteria shall we use? • Medical Labels vs. Religious Labels • Tales from history: Crime, gambling problems, and finding the “bad guys” YESTERDAYS

  4. YESTERDAYS A History of Voices, A History of Vices • Problem gambling is a relatively young field of study • First included in the DSM in 1980 • Thanks to people like Dr. Custer, Dr. Lesieur, Dr. Rosenthal, and other experts, the diagnosis evolved. • Hence, one way to think about the “trajectory of problem gambling” is as a “history of voices” interpreting the lives of those who gamble too much. • Long before medical/psych experts provided us with the proper interpretive parameters for these lives, moral/religious “experts” were entrusted with this task.

  5. Methodology • Rachel Volberg on methods (1996) • Historic Analysis • Pre-1910 texts from the University of Nevada, Las Vegas’ Special Collections. • Almost all from USA and England • Qualitative exploration YESTERDAYS

  6. How do/did we identify them? • Virtually all of our current “identifying criteria” were alluded to in historic literature dating back hundreds of years. • Moral/religious thinkers attacked gambling in general, but in doing so, they cited specific “case studies” that described individual lives. • To identify those who gambled too much, the moral/religious thinkers of yesterday used the same “diagnostic criteria” that today’s medical/psychological thinkers use.

  7. Disrupted Family or Spouse Relationship Work Problems Lying Preoccupation Tolerance: Increasing Time, Increasing Money Chasing Loss of Control Action Gamblers and Escape Gamblers Of course, we relied on different “names” for these problems... By Any Other Names:Some Favorite DSM Identifiers

  8. Crime as an Identifying Criterion • Used as the very first criterion in the very first DSM (1980) • Still employed in the current, DSM-IV version • As it turns out, we have long used criminal behavior in order to identify those who gamble too much.

  9. Historic Examples: Crime and Criminal Behavior • Tales of criminal activity to support a gambling habit were quite common. • “It consumes time, and produces sin, immorality, and crime” -- Spriggs-Smith (1890:12) YESTERDAYS

  10. Concluding Speculations • A Sociological History: A Long and Documented Tale • A Sociology of Medicalization of Mental Illness: A Profound Parallelism Emerges • A Sociology of Religion and Morality: Institutional Contributions to Our Current Understandings and Public Discourses TODAYS

  11. The “So What?” Question TOMORROWS • This history has profound implications for research work -- and even clinical work. • A “bio-psycho-social” model extended? • Taking a “sociological step back” in order to understand the “problems” of the problem gambler • Our lives are shaped by forces far larger than us: Adding a sociological imagination to the tool chest • “If pathological gambling is a medical problem, then why is it that I am treated as a moralone?”

  12. Tomorrows: Crime and Causes • The Internet: New Gamblers, New Crimes? • Hypothesis: As Gambling Moves into the Mainstream, So Too Will Its Associated Pathology Move into the Mainstream • Fewer pre-existing pathologies? Pre-existing criminal activity? • The Las Vegasization of America? TOMORROWS

  13. Talk to me! Bo Bernhard University of Nevada, Las Vegas bobernhard@aol.com

More Related