1 / 61

Lignin as a Chemical Feedstock

Lignin as a Chemical Feedstock. Ian Suckling APPI May 2012. Introduction. Chemical processing of wood mainly targets carbohydrates, e.g. pulp, bioethanol Large amounts of process lignins potentially available as “co-product” in NZ ~380,000 tpa kraft lignin

zandra
Download Presentation

Lignin as a Chemical Feedstock

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Lignin as a Chemical Feedstock Ian Suckling APPI May 2012

  2. Introduction • Chemical processing of wood mainly targets carbohydrates, e.g. pulp, bioethanol • Large amounts of process lignins potentially available as “co-product” • in NZ ~380,000 tpa kraft lignin • Lignin structure → potential sustainable source of aromatic and aliphatic chemicals • Only ~1% of lignin processed through pulp mills is currently recovered for uses other than energy • nearly all as lignosulfonates (1 – 1.2m tpa)

  3. in-situ radical polymerisation (enzyme-initiated) Softwood lignin • Potential feedstock for: • aromatic and aliphatic chemicals • biopolymers

  4. Introduction ctd • chemical feedstocks potentially a higher value use

  5. Agenda • Issues with lignin utilisation • why is lignin such a difficult feedstock? • Current technical lignins • Isolation • Structures • Current uses • Potential uses for lignin • Combustion for energy • Gasification to fuels and chemicals • As a polymeric material • Feedstock for low molecular weight chemicals

  6. Issues • Structural complexity & variability of lignin

  7. Cellulose -basis for comparison 1 chemistry >95% yield

  8. 26 C-9 units 7 different chemistries monomers Breakdown of softwood lignin

  9. Lignin heterogeneity in reality it is even worse…. • 3 lignin precursors – species dependent • process lignins heavily modified • reactive -ether interunit links cleaved • new interunit bonds formed • sulfonate or thiol groups can be introduced • lignin structure depends on process

  10. Issues • structural complexity & variability of lignin • need to isolate & purify the process lignins • degradation processes tend to require severe conditions • products often more reactive than starting lignin • generally complex mixtures of products • low yields, purification required • what happens to the rest?

  11. Issues • costs vs petrochemical alternatives • lignin often has existing value as fuel • lignin isolation • high Capex & Opex • product isolation • low saleable product yields “you can make anything you want out of lignin ………except money” • huge amounts of lignin potentially available • markets for the products?

  12. In summary Lignin as a feedstock for chemical production represents: • both a major opportunity… • large amounts available & currently poorly utilised • sustainable source of biopolymers and aromatic & phenolic feedstocks • and a major challenge… • technical • economic

  13. Isolated lignins • Kraft lignin • Lignosulfonates • Organosolv lignins • Hydrolytic lignins • “Native wood” lignins • Not possible to isolate an unmodifed wood lignin • Best lignins (research purposes only): • Milled wood lignin (MWL) • Cellulolytic enzyme lignins (CELs)

  14. Kraft lignin • Large amounts of black liquor produced worldwide • Lignin has current value as a fuel • Only small amounts currently isolated • e.g. Indulin (MeadWestvaco) • Main use after sulfonation • Benefit of lignin removal = increased pulp production in recovery-limited mill • lignin then used as fuel in lime kiln or for combustion

  15. Kraft black liquor Typical composition of the dry matter of Scots pine and silver birch Kraft black liquors % of total dry matter)

  16. Isolation of kraft lignin • By acidification of black liquor • Many variants • Issues: • Lignin purity • Obtaining an easily filterable product • H2S emitted on acidification • Foaming (CO2 release on acidification) • Restricted to CO2 or H2SO4 for acidification as residue → recovery cycle

  17. Lignoboost process

  18. Sequential Liquid-Lignin Recovery & Purification (SLRP)

  19. Kraft lignin structure Zakzeski, J. et al. Chem. Rev. 110:3552 (2010)

  20. Lignosulfonates • Major use of lignin (~1,000,000 tpa) • Wide variety of grades/purities • Derived from: • Acid sulfite pulping of hardwoods, softwoods and bagasse • NSSC pulping • Sulfonation or sulfomethylation of kraft lignin

  21. Sulfite pulping liquor Typical composition of Norway spruce and silver birch spent acid sulfite liquors (kg/ton pulp).

  22. Isolation of lignosulfonates • Depends on the cooking base and purity required • Commonly sold as powders/40-60% solutions in water • By evaporation and/or spray drying of pulping liquors • Directly → impure product • Or following purification • By precipitation as the Ca salt with Ca(OH)2 • Step 1: recovers Ca sulfite • Step 2: separate lignin as the calcium lignosulfonate • Step 3: precipitate remaining lignin & return to step 1

  23. Lignosulfonates Zakzeski, J. et al. Chem. Rev. 110:3552 (2010)

  24. Performance of lignosulfonates • Application-specific and can depend on: • Feedstock processed, e.g. hardwood or softwood • Pulping process used • Base of lignosulfonate, e.g. Ca, Na, NH4, Fe, Cr • Level of impurities – commercial products often only 60-80% pure – sugars, sugar acids, extractives, inorganics • Level of sulfonation • Molecular weight distribution • Types of functional groups present • Modifications to the lignosulfonates • Multiple grades for different applications

  25. Commercial lignosulfonates – an example • BorregaardLignoTech – just for agricultural chemicals

  26. Modification of lignosulfonates • Cation exchange • or from a Na base by ion exchange • Ultrafiltration to remove low MWt fractions • Sugar removal by: • fermentation, yeast production • ion exchange • oxidation in alkali • Desulfonation by treatment with NaOH or ammonia

  27. Sulfonation of kraft lignin • Treatment of kraft lignin at ~100ºC with chemicals used during sulfite pulping • Introduces sulfonate functionality into sidechain • recovery by evaporation or precipitation as Ca salt • At higher temperatures (150-200ºC) get ring sulfonation • Acid-induced hydroxymethylation of the aromatic rings • then sulfonation of hydroxymethyl groups

  28. Applications of lignosulfonates • Concrete admixtures [Large] • Reduce amount of water needed → stronger concrete • Dust control [Large] • Animal feed [Large] • Use as binder in animal feed pellets • Added to feed molasses to reduce viscosity • Vanillin manufacture [Medium] • Gypsum wallboard dispersant [Medium] • Oil well drilling mud additive [Medium to Small] • Dye dispersants [Medium] • Resins [Small to medium] • Binders [Small to medium] Ek – The status of applied lignin research Processum Report (2002).

  29. Organosolv lignins • Not currently available on commercial scale • Renewed interest in organosolv process for biofuel production with lignin as a potentially valuable co-product • Lignin easily separated from pulping solvent by: • Solvent removal and recovery • Precipitation with water + distillation to recover solvent • Organosolv lignin: • Low molecular weight • Low sulfur and ash content • Low water solubility • Readily soluble in alkali and organic solvents Attractive for low MWt phenols or aromatics

  30. Hydrolytic (dilute acid) lignins • Still produced commercially in Russia • Hydrolytic lignin ~1/3 of initial wood • Low value • Low purity (typically only 60-70% lignin) • Highly condensed lignin (condensation reactions) • Can be used as a source of process heat Ethanol + Ferment Yeast Monomeric sugars 0.4-0.7% H2SO4 120-190ºC + Wood + Furfural Hydrolytic lignin

  31. Analysis of hydrolysis lignins Composition of commercial technical hydrolytic lignins from various Russian commercial plants (% of oven-dried sample). Krutov et al. Proceedings of 16th ISWFPC, Tianjin (2011)

  32. Comparison of commercial lignins

  33. Other potential uses of lignin • Combustion for energy - current major use • Gasification to fuels and chemicals • As a polymeric material • as dispersant, emulsifier, stabiliser or sequestrant • in material systems • adhesives, thermosetresins • polymer modifier • carbon fibre • As a feedstock for low molecular weight chemicals • aromatic & aliphatic chemical feedstocks

  34. Combustion • Lignoboost kraft lignin proposed as fuel for co-firing in coal-fired power plants

  35. Gasification • Gasification to synthesis gas (CO, H2 and CO2) • Forest & other biomass residues • Lignin • Black liquor • Synthesis gas then converted to chemicals or burnt for energy

  36. Gasification - ctd

  37. Gasification - ctd • Fisher Tropsch chemistry • H2/CO ratio may need to be adjusted using water gas shift reaction

  38. CHEMREC black liquor gasification • Pilot plant uses black liquor as feedstock • Syngas then used to produce DME (H3COCH3)

  39. Dimethyl ether production

  40. Carbon fibre production • Lignin a potential low-cost source of carbon suitable for displacing polyacrylonitrile in carbon fibre production • 10% of US lignin could displace half steel in domestic passenger vehicles • reduce vehicle weight & improve fuel economy • Requires C fibre cost to be reduced

  41. Carbon fibre production from polyacrylonitrile (PAN)

  42. Carbon fibre production from lignin • Range of lignins have been melt-spun and carbonised • sometimes with added plasticising agent

  43. Carbon fibre production from lignin - issues • Requires melt-spinning of lignin at high rates • Low-cost purification of lignin • need to remove polysaccharides, salts, particulates, water and volatiles • Lignin molecular weight polydispersity • low and high MWt fractions may need to be removed • Methods to process, stabilise and derivatise lignin to optimise its thermal (Tg), melt flow and melting point • Maximise yields of carbon fibre from thermal conversion of melt-spun lignins • Application to varied lignin sources

  44. Polymer modifiers • Low-cost fillers • Focus of much research, e.g. incorporation into adhesives • High-value additives to improve polymer performance, e.g. • High-strength engineering plastics • Heat-resistant polymers • Under-the-hood uses • Antibacterial surfaces • High-strength formaldehyde-free adhesives

  45. Polymer modifiers • Area of active research, including: • Epoxies • UV stabilisers for plastics • Polyurethanes • Issues: • Economical modifications to improve solubility and compatibility with other polymers • Controllable alteration of molecular weight • Lignin colour • Control of polyelectrolyte character • Functional group enhancement

  46. Phenolic resins • Chemistry of phenol-formaldehyde (PF) resins

  47. Lignin as a phenol substitute • Lignin extensively investigated as phenol substitute in PF resins • Ready availability and low cost (vs phenol) • Issue: much lower reactivity as fewer phenolic groups • E.g. kraft lignin 0.3 reactive aromatic sites/C-9 unit vs 3 for phenol

  48. Means to enhance reactivity to formaldehyde • Demethylation • Hydroxymethylation • Phenolation • Use of novel lignins, e.g. organosolv lignins • By extensive lignin degradation (see later)

  49. Low MWt chemicals from lignin

  50. Options for low MWt chemicals

More Related