130 likes | 214 Views
This study delves into the impact of cochlear implants (CI) on unilateral deafness, highlighting the underestimated disruptions and educational challenges faced. It explores the potential benefits, such as reduced social isolation and improved quality of life, while addressing key factors like tinnitus perception and speech perception in noise. The analysis covers adult and pediatric data, highlighting the efficacy of CI in improving speech perception and localization, even in cases of unilateral sensorineural hearing loss. Patient recruitment criteria and consideration of bimodal users are discussed, emphasizing the importance of careful assessment and vigilant reporting in CI for single-sided deafness cases.
E N D
Introduction • disruption in unilateral deafness is underestimated (Laryngoscope. 2012 Sep;122(9):2088-95) • educational • 12-41% additional needs (Bess 1988) • 22-35% grade failures (Cho Lieg 2004) • social isolation • vocational • quality of life • tinnitus • perception in noise
CI for Single Sided Deafness • “absurd concept historically” • long period of deprivation • limited benefit for hearing • possible uses for tinnitus • short period of deprivation? X X X X X
Adult Data • unilateral tinnitus (n=26) (PunteAK, et. al. Cochlear Implants Int. 2011 May;12 Suppl1:S26-9) • unilateral SNHL • all post-lingually deaf • better with short periods of deprivation
Pediatric (and Adult) Data • CI for SSD (n=40) vs. • CROS aid • BAHA • untreated patients • decreased hearing handicap • improved localization • improved speech in noise (Arndt S, Laszig R, Aschendorff A, et. al., HNO. 2011 May;59(5):437-46) .
CI for SSD – Speech perception 100 From Arndt, Laszig, Aschendorff performance 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >7 duration of deprivation
CI for SSD – Speech perception 100 From Arndt, Laszig, Aschendorff performance 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >7 duration of deprivation
Patient Recruitment • inclusion strict • minimal deprivation • normal anatomy • exclusion • anomalous cochlea (narrow nerve!) • developmental delay
Bimodal users in the CI program at SickKids Unaided Aided
Binaural Fusion Electric Electric Cochlear Implant (CI) Cochlear Implant (CI) Acoustic Electric Cochlear Implant (CI) Hearing Aid (HA)
(M. Deighton) R L HA CI
Current Opinion • not expanded criteria • experimental protocols • short deprivation • careful assessment of bilateral function • vigilant reporting