1 / 28

Dr Jo Barton University of Essex

How Does Greenspace Contribute to Healthy, Thriving Communities?. Dr Jo Barton University of Essex. Outline. Theories linking nature and health Greenspaces and healthy communities – what does the evidence show? Reducing health inequalities Obesity Crime

yannis
Download Presentation

Dr Jo Barton University of Essex

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. How Does Greenspace Contribute to Healthy, Thriving Communities? Dr Jo BartonUniversity of Essex

  2. Outline • Theories linking nature and health • Greenspaces and healthy communities – what does the evidence show? • Reducing health inequalities • Obesity • Crime • Facilitates activity – ‘Green exercise’ • Green Exercise research findings • Opportunities for new public health delivery structures

  3. Our relationship with nature has changed....

  4. Wilson (1984) Theory Linking Nature and Health • “an innate sensitivity to and need for other living things – as we have co-existed for thousands of generations” • Hardwired into our genetic makeup • Evolved with affiliation for nature, urban settings not part of our genetic history

  5. Kaplan & Kaplan (1989) Attention Restoration Theory • We engage in 2 types of attention • Involuntary – requires minimal effort • Voluntary (directed)– requires focus & energy, is susceptible to mental fatigue • Nature – conducive to involuntary engagement, replenishes our mental fatigue, helps us recover from stress, restores concentration levels

  6. Health Value of Greenspaces • 80% of worlds population live in urban areas • Quality of physical environment promotes good health and wellbeing • Protect and improve natural environment = protect and enhance people’s health • Accessibility and design affects behaviour

  7. Greenspaces and Healthy Communities • Reduces property crime • violent crime • levels of aggression Provides a sense of belonging Reduces health inequalities • Improves mental health and wellbeing • Self-esteem • Mood • Reduces stress • Perceived • Cortisol • Restores mental fatigue Greenspace • Facilitates activity • Improves physical health • Lowers BP • Increases HRV • Reduces obesity • Enhances social cohesion • Reduces social isolation • Improves social networking • Encourages intergenerational links

  8. Mitchell & Popham (2008) Greenspace Reduces Health Inequalities

  9. Ellaway & Macintyre (2005) Is Greenery Associated with Obesity? (N = 6919) > x3 Odds Ratio 40% less Greenery

  10. Kuo & Sullivan (2001) Greenspaces and Crime • Highest vegetation: • 52% less total crimes • 48% less property crimes • 56% less violent crimes • Supports ART hypothesis

  11. Pretty et al., (2005) Greenspace Facilitates Activity - ‘Green Exercise’ • Good access to greenspace increases likelihood of being physically active by 24% • Green Exercise – synergistic health benefit? Laboratory studies • Analysing concept in controlled setting • Rural vs. urban views • SE, mood improve more with green views

  12. Gladwell et al., (2012) Viewing Nature Improves Recovery From Stress • Viewing nature prior to a stressor can increase HRV (indicator of better health and an adaptable CV system) • Enhances recovery from a stressor

  13. Akers et al., (2012) Underlying Cognitive Mechanisms? • Visual sensation study – to what extent does the colour green contribute to the GE effect? • Better mood & lower ratings of perceived exertion in green condition (even though exercise intensity the same) Green (unedited) Grey (achromatic) Red (filter)

  14. Barton & Pretty (2012) A ‘Dose of Nature’ • Multi-study analysis on change in SE & mood, 10 case studies, n=1252 • Aim: Assess the optimal dose(s) of GE for mental well-being • Type, duration and intensity of activity? • Type of green space? • Participant characteristics?

  15. TMD = Total Mood Disturbance (indicator of overall mood)

  16. Barton et al., (2011) Therapeutic Intervention - Longer Term Shifts in Self-Esteem

  17. Barton et al., (2012) TurnAround and Control Group Mindfulness and Self-Esteem Scores Note: A higher score=more mindful qualities, error bars represent =1SD. * indicates a significantly higher mindfulness score in the TA group (P<0.05) Note: A lower score= better self-esteem, error bars represent =1SD. * indicates a better self-esteem in the turnaround group (P<0.05)

  18. What are the Opportunities for New Public Health Delivery Structures? • Using the environment to promote WB & initiate behaviour change • Greening communities • Schools • Workplace • Retirement/care homes • New housing developments • Engaging vulnerable groups • Responsibility still with individual but we can provide them with the tools and environment to facilitate behaviour change

  19. Green Infrastructure for Children • Early encounters vital for creating meaning and establishing identity • Concerns that children today spend too little time outside • Disconnections mean • Reductions in ecological literacy • Misunderstandings about food • Reductions in cognitive capacity The virtual is replacing the real (Pyle 2002)

  20. Wood et al., (2012) Greenspaces Facilitate Physical Activity Adolescents Children * Figure 1: Mean + SD of time spent in MVPA on the school playground and field (* indicates a higher MVPA on the field (P<0.001) Figure 2: Mean + SD of time spent in MVPA during urban and rural orienteering (* indicates a higher rural MVPA (P<0.01)

  21. Wood et al., (2012) Mean + SD of time spent in MVPA during indoor and outdoor cycling (*MVPA significantly greater outdoors compared to indoors (P<0.05)).

  22. Brown and Gladwell (2012) Workplace Health – Walks4Work • Lunchtime walking interventions – nature/built • Nature walks: • ↓ heart age by 1.5 yr, built ↓ 0.15 yrs • Significantly ↓ BP & ↑ negative mood compared to built • Significantly ↓ perceived stress (i.e. people thought they were coping better with stress) • Active lunch break (walking & socialising in greenspaces) increases productivity and workplace wellness

  23. Nature Deprivation.... • If nature is important, then deprivation will create problems.... • Physical benefits of nature in urban areas (microclimate effects) • Design of built & natural environment matters for mental health • The ‘green’ element often not considered essential in urban planning & regeneration • Perception of the importance of nature?

  24. Losing Connections.... • In urban areas – nearby nature is important (e.g. Parks & open spaces, street trees, gardens, allotments, community gardens) • Source of stress • Malign influence on social networks & social mechanisms • Sense of place - Important part of personal identity created through interactions in specific places

  25. Conclusion - Research Findings to Date • Acute GE has mental health benefits: • Self-esteem & mood • Benefits for all types of: • Green spaces (imp of nearby nature) • Activities • Durations (5 mins – all day) • People (Vulnerable, ill, disaffected & disadvantaged seem to benefit more) • Green spaces facilitate activity & improve social capital: • Need accessible green spaces in towns & cities

  26. Conclusions • Need to think of Natural Health Service to complement NHS - Green places can be therapeutic, self-medicate with nature? • Green exercise & green care suggest increasing need for: • Green Design/ Infrastructure - Incorporate more green views and greenspace in urban design. Create memories (future benchmarks to behaviour) • Green Education – Ecoliteracy, creative unstructured play(free-range children), sense of place

  27. www.greenexercise.org “I can go into the hills and enjoy peace and quiet, the exercise and relax. My troubles take a back seat on a day like today” Any questions?

More Related