130 likes | 241 Views
[DTLLS]. Advantages: . More sociable than a one-to-one interview Raises unexpected issues for exploration Low cost, can get results relatively quickly Increases the sample size by talking with several people at once. [Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Focus_group]. Disadvantages: .
E N D
Advantages: • More sociable than a one-to-one interview • Raises unexpected issues for exploration • Low cost, can get results relatively quickly • Increases the sample size by talking with several people at once [Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Focus_group]
Disadvantages: • Less control than one-on-one interview • Time can be lost on irrelevant issues • Tough to analyse – talking is in reaction to other group member comments • Groups are variable and may be difficult to assemble • May be too few members for a representative sample [Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Focus_group]
Preparation: • Ice breaker 1 question • Structure 2 • Process 2 • Outcome 3
Our Focus Group: • Sample: 2 (male) • Setting: quiet classroom • Duration: 15 mins (approx.) • Prepared questions: 8 • Recording method: notes & debrief • Notes to include: body language
Results: Structure (a): Is pace of topics ok? • Variety can help, focus is appreciated • Discussion fosters inclusivity • Different ideas from different people Structure (b): Topics build progressively? • Not taken up by group
Results: Process (a): Preferred delivery medium? • Mixture is important • Prefer Powerpoint to be limited • An interesting aside about ppt v ohp Process (b): Medium least liked? • In moderation, all ok
Results: Outcome (a): Does DTLLS inform your TP? • Affirming, boosting confidence • Professionally, vocabulary is important • Enables discussion of concepts Outcome (b): Do essays clarify & consolidate? • Yes, more conscious of lesson design
Results: Outcome (c): Is essay word limit ok? • Encourages focus on topic • Boundary/guidance appreciated • Although restrictive, does stop waffle
Results: Body Language Observation • Normally video-recorded • Analysed carefully • We used hand-written notes & debrief • Very relaxed (familiar participants) • Deferential, consultative, amiable • Consistent throughout
Micro Conclusions: • High degree of satisfaction • Varied delivery is valued • Social aspect is valued • Topic progression may be undervalued
The Overall Experience: • Even a small group was productive • Unexpected tangential results! • Real time observation of body language was difficult, even with small group • Rapid execution & analysis • Our results completely text-based • No maths!