Environmental Issues Sandi Tabor V.P. Government Affairs Lignite Energy Council
Environmental Issues • Water quality • Waste management • Air quality • Global Climate Change
Water Water is essential for use in the process of generating electricity • Processes include • Cooling water • Steam turbines • Drinking / sanitary uses • Fire protection • Environmental impacts • Intake structure designs • Heat
Waste Management Coal Combustion Products (CCPs) • The solid residue left when combustible material is thoroughly burned includes: • Fly ash • Bottom ash • Boiler slag • Material generated through flue gascleaning • Flue gas desulfurization material - gypsum
Beneficial Uses of Coal Combustion Products
Air Quality Federal Clean Air Act regulates criteria pollutants - • National Ambient Air Quality Standards; • Carbon monoxide • Lead • Nitrogen dioxide • Particulate matter • Ozone • Sulfur dioxide
Air Quality • Clean Air Act: • Designed to protect citizens including the most sensitive (children, people with asthma & older adults) individuals from air pollution Google Earth Emission file: http://www.epa.gov/air/emissions/where.htm
Sources of Emissions Carbon Monoxide Emissions by Source Sector in North Dakota in 2005 Total Emissions 155,921 79,515 14,583 6,630 5,155 2,282 1,319 375 41 Tons Source: EPA
Sources of Emissions Lead Emissions by Source Sector in North Dakota in 2005 Total Emissions 6 2 1 0 0 0 Tons Source: EPA
Sources of Emissions Volatile Organic Compounds by Source Sector in North Dakota in 2005 Total Emissions 14,193 12,687 4,790 3,516 3,180 1,351 887 763 382 303 Tons Source: EPA
Sources of Emissions PM2.5 Emissions by Source Sector in North Dakota in 2005 Total Emissions 36,533 8,436 6,397 5,745 4,590 1,998 785 764 386 110 Source: EPA Tons
Particulate Matter
Sources of Emissions Sulfur Dioxide Emissions by Source Sector in North Dakota in 2005 Total Emissions 137,372 12,013 5,996 3,123 443 50 27 21 Source: EPA Tons
Sources of Emissions Nitrogen Oxides Emissions by Source Sector in North Dakota in 2005 Total Emissions 76,384 59,714 19,780 10,923 188 179 176 17 1 Source: EPA Tons
Air is Getting Cleaner • Industry has met greater electric demand with increasingly cleaner technologies Aggregate Emissions Decreased 54% Since 1980 U.S. Energy Consumption 29% Vehicle Miles Traveled 91% U.S. GDP Increased 126% Source: EPA data 2008
200 Tons Per Year 185K 150 138K 100 Utility Total 50 51K 0 1998 2007 2013* SO2 Emissions Trend in ND Source: ND Department of Health * Reductions estimated based on new scrubbers
Air Quality - TR National Park
ND Lignite Industry: Exceeding Environmental Expectations North Dakota is one of only 12 states to meet all the federal ambient air quality standards Source: EPA, May 1, 2010
Air Monitoring Activity • Build your own “air monitors” • Materials: • Container (milk carton or coffee can) • String (for hanging) or pole • Black permanent marker • Vaseline • Hole punch • Magnifying lens
Mercury EPA’s concern about mercury • Bioaccumulates in food chain • Human exposure through fish consumption • Mercury is a neurotoxin • Selenium protects against mercury toxicity – ND soils are high in selenium
Selenium in Soils
Mercury is a Global Issue Background: Mercury is a global issue • Estimated 4400-7500 tons emitted worldwide from all sources – natural & man-made • Estimated 1/3 from natural sources; 2/3 from human activities • U.S. contribution is about 3% • Nationwide coal-fired utilities account for about 48 tons - about 1% of worldwide total mercury release • North Dakota utilities account for 1 ton, about 0.02% of worldwide total mercury release
Mercury is a Global Issue
Mercury Deposition % contribution by non-U.S. sources, 2004
Regional Haze • Goal - return all national parks and wilderness areas (Class 1) to natural conditions by the year 2064 • States - establish goals and emission reduction using best available retrofit technology (BART)
Regional Haze Regional Haze Sources • Fossil fuels combustion • Open burning • Agriculture • Unpaved roads • Oil and gas extraction • Motor vehicles
Regional Haze 30 dV visibility vs 10 dV Courtesy of ENSR
Regional Haze 1.4 dVChange
Regional Haze Challenge for ND • Already clean air upon which to improve • Significant distances to Class I areas • Small industry base • Crop burning • Prairie fires • Unpaved roads
Global Climate Change
Controversy Abounds
Web Sites of Interest • Environmental Protection Agency:http://www.epa.gov/climatechange/ • Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change:http://www.ipcc.ch/ • Junk Science: All the Junk that’s Fit to Debunk http://junkscience.com/Features.html • Space and Science Research Center:http://www.spaceandscience.net/id16.html • The Skeptical Environmentalist – Bjorn Lomborg http://www.lomborg.com
Issue in Perspective Man-made 2.9% • Man-made carbon dioxide emissions are less than 3% of total annual CO2 emissions Natural 97.1% • United States makes up 23% of the 2.9 percent
Sources of U.S. Man-made CO2 Commercial – 3% Residential – 6% Electricity – 40% Industrial – 17% Transportation – 34% Source: EIA 2007
Sources of ND Man-made CO2 Residential – 2% Commercial – 2% Industrial – 24% Electricity – 59% Transportation – 13% Source: EIA 2007
Sources of MN Man-made CO2 Commercial – 6% Residential – 9% Electricity – 34% Industrial – 15% Transportation – 36% Source: EIA 2007
CO2 Emissions: US vs. China & India – (1990-2025) 2009 Source: Energy Information Administration (EIA), International Energy Annual 2002 & International Energy Outlook 2005
Projected Global Energy Demand Projected 10-Year Growth in Per Capita Energy Use 33% 12% 4% 7% 5% 88% 13% 17% 36% 37% 20% 27% EIA: 3.5 Billion People to Increase Energy Use by 60% in 10 Years
What is the Problem? • No commercially available technology to capture CO2 from pulverized coal power plants • Risks associated with sequestering the CO2 in geologic formations • Global issue requires global solution • Current solutions being considered by Congress not addressing economic impact
CO2 Storage Activity • Goal: Students learn about geologic sequestration as a technique used to reduce carbon dioxide in the atmosphere • Objectives: Students will … • Understand geologic sequestration as an idea being considered to reduce carbon dioxide in the atmosphere • Use chemistry to simulate enhanced oil recovery
Solutions - Actions • What can industry do? • What can government do? • What can consumers do?
What can industry do? • Develop cost-effective technology to capture CO2 • Diversify energy resource mix • Work with Congress to ensure the passage of legislation that protects the environment and the economy • Encourage the transfer of technologies to third-world countries
CO2 Emission Reductions • Electric companies are world leaders in taking voluntary actions to address GHG emissions • Electric industry leads all other U.S. industrial sectors in reducing CO2
What can government do? • Develop regulations that are synchronized with technology development • Partner with industry to develop • CO2 capture technology for existing plants • Clean coal technology for new plants
What can consumers do? • Change our energy appetites: • Energy efficiency (doing things smarter) • Energy conservation (doing with less)
Summary A. North Dakota lignite industry exceeds environmental expectations B. Important to maintain affordable and reliable electricity • The timing of federal legislation to solve global warming must be in sync with the development of technology to capture CO2