1 / 35

Michigan Association of School Administrators New Superintendent’s Conference September 23, 2008

Michigan Association of School Administrators New Superintendent’s Conference September 23, 2008. Negotiations: Practical Info Every Superintendent Needs to Know. Dr. Rodney Green Superintendent East China School District. PERA – Public Employment Relations Act. Duty to bargain

verena
Download Presentation

Michigan Association of School Administrators New Superintendent’s Conference September 23, 2008

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Michigan Association of School AdministratorsNew Superintendent’s ConferenceSeptember 23, 2008

  2. Negotiations: Practical Info Every Superintendent Needs to Know.Dr. Rodney Green SuperintendentEast China School District

  3. PERA – Public Employment Relations Act • Duty to bargain • Meet and confer in good faith with respect to wages, hours, and conditions of employment • Neither party is compelled to agree to a proposal or make concessions • Good faith bargaining is manifesting an attitude and conduct that will be conducive to reaching an agreement

  4. Bargaining is a continuous process • Preparation – review files, grievances, survey administration and board, put together facts regarding finances • Face to face negotiations • Contract administration • Then, preparation for the next round

  5. Getting Started • Decide what type of bargaining. Traditional, expedited, interest based . . . • Who is on management team? • Chief Spokesperson, other administrators • Ground Rules for negotiations • Permissive subject • Media blackout – not necessarily in district’s best interest

  6. Traditional Bargaining • More formal • One spokesperson for each side • Positional and can be adversarial • Caucus – use time wisely • Taking notes – script as much as possible • Preparation is important for any type of bargaining

  7. Expedited Bargaining • Limit the issues • Set time limits • Smaller teams • More informal

  8. Interest Based Bargaining • More collaborative than traditional or expedited bargaining • Training for both sides is available • Facilitators from management and union help facilitate the bargaining sessions • Try to walk in the other side’s shoes, see their interests and issues • Each team member is expected to contribute in some fashion in the sessions

  9. Interest Based Bargaining • Story – everyone contributes to the story • Interests • Options – brainstorming • Straw Design – combinations of options • Evaluation • Consensus – everyone has to agree • Based on the concept of building relationships – soft on people, hard on the problem

  10. Sidebar • Usually one from each side or maybe two people from each side • Talk informally about the issue • Positions can be more realistic • These conversations are considered ‘off the record’ • Sometimes used at the end of the process to get the deal done

  11. Off the Record • You can do “off the record” written proposals • Sometimes after side bar discussion • Sometimes done the whole negotiations • Helps with comfort level – realistic positions • Denote on form “off the record written proposal” • Can pull back if doesn’t help settle

  12. Subjects of Bargaining • Mandatory – wages, hours, conditions of employment • Permissive – ground rules for bargaining or curriculum • Prohibited – several subjects of bargaining are prohibited under Public Act 112

  13. Prohibited Subjects of Bargaining • Policy holder for health insurance • Decisions concerning experimental or pilot programs and/or technology • Starting day of school • Amount of student contact time • Composition of site based decision making bodies or school improvement teams

  14. Prohibited Subjects • Decision for open enrollment in or out of district • Authorization of a Public School Academy • Contracting for support services • Use of volunteers • Regional bargaining • Cannot veto local agreement

  15. Preparation • No substitute for facts – you should always be very prepared. • Credibility goes with knowing the information • Benefits – health, dental, vision, LTD, Life • Payroll for the group; retirement, FICA • Budget – cost of steps for group • How many are at the top? How many opt out?

  16. Comparison to Other Districts • Important step in the preparation for bargaining • Union will want the best of every area from surrounding contracts • Make sure you’re grounded in the facts • Know the good stuff and bad stuff in your contract compared to other districts

  17. Strategies • This is the most important concept of bargaining. • You must think through the whole process • Think big picture without missing the details • How do you decide what to put on table? • Clean up language • Talk to building level administrators about issues • Are concessions possible? • Start strong and stick to it • Be strategic

  18. Budget Issues • Dealing with the budget shows that the Board is concerned about spending • Board and administration need to be concerned about budget issues given the state-wide issues with retirement, etc. • Be cautious with buy outs. They are short term solutions and could send the wrong message to employees.

  19. Ideas on Containing Costs • Higher deductibles & higher co-pays on health care • Employees co-pay on premium • Self insure; HAS; caps • % first semester - % second semester • Tie total compensation to foundation increase

  20. Fund Balance • Is it important? It is very important . . . • Emergencies, cash flow, borrowing, investment income, bond rating, executive order cuts • Depending on your cash flow, 10% to 16% should be your goal for fund balance • It should be used only for one time costs. • It can help cushion budget cuts and declining enrollment, but you should be making cuts along with using fund balance

  21. What About New Language? • Every word in contract restricts management rights • Find your philosophical base regarding management versus employee rights • Superintendents come and go – not so with employee groups

  22. Tentative Agreements • Written only • Do not try to agree to things verbally • What should be retroactive? • Language is effective on date of ratification • Salary can be retroactive – it is negotiable • Ratification • Past practice – correcting a wrong practice

  23. What happens when the Contract Expires? • Terms and conditions still apply • Extension or no extension • No extension means no arbitration on grievances • Union pressure tactics • “We want a contract” really means, “We want a raise”. • Buttons, picketing, work to rule, etc. • Frame the issue -- “Benefits and salaries are important and difficult issues and we’re working to reach agreement”

  24. Patience is a Key Factor • Patience and more patience – The board must realize this. Talk to members about process and how it is important to allow the process to work. • Impatient board members and administrators make bad deals • Quick Deals – There are no good quick deals (or at least very few)

  25. Involving the Board • Keep the Board updated • Go over parameters and confidentiality early • Executive sessions • Legal issues

  26. Unfair Labor Practice Charges • Another pressure tactic • Don’t change tactics because of a threat to file • Good faith bargaining does not mean saying yes. You can listen and still say no. • Once you have a tentative agreement, make sure it includes dropping the unfair labor practice charges

  27. Impasse • The parties cannot agree and positions have become entrenched – no movement • Bargain in good faith to impasse • Once impasse is reached, the district can implement its ‘last best offer’ • Implementation will be difficult • Union will likely file ULP

  28. Mediation • State sends a mediator to the bargaining session • Each party meets in its own group and mediator goes back and forth between • Preparation still very important – Convince the mediator of the facts and you’ll have a better chance to reach an agreement with terms that you can live with

  29. Work to Rule • Union encourages members to only do what is required in contract . . . Don’t come in early, don’t stay late, don’t do extras, etc. • Union employees have a right to engage in concerted activities, but, if those concerted activities result in a refusal to perform normal services, such activity may not be protected under PERA

  30. Work to Rule • If voluntary activities have normally been done (ie chaperoning dances), not performing this duty during a contract dispute could be a violation • Concerted activity to refuse may not be protected under PERA

  31. How to Deal With Media • What to say • Could give table positions • Get the district message out; frame the issue • Don’t say • Cannot give sidebar or off the record proposals or positions • Don’t disparage union position, talk about your position

  32. Do’s and Don’ts regarding proper communications • Do, when questioned, accurately inform employee of the facts, status and table position of the employer • Do, when questioned, clarify certain contract proposals or answer employee questions regarding interpretation of proposals • Don’t inquire what went on at a union meeting

  33. Don’ts regarding proper communications • Don’t offer directly to employees something not offered at the table • Don’t call an employee into your office to discuss negotiations • Don’t state to any employee that we could reach a settlement if association representatives would get out of the way • Don’t misrepresent association bargaining position or imply association proposals were in some respect adverse to employee interests

  34. Relationship with Union • Sometimes bargaining is a power struggle • Everything becomes an issue • Don’t take it personally • Follow through, build trust • Be good with the numbers, don’t cry wolf • Make sure people can read you • Establish trust and credibility and both sides can establish power base

  35. Patience • Be patient • Help Board members be patient • Don’t make decisions (like reducing too many days) for a quick fix. The next round will be upon you soon and then what will you do? • Eventually, it will settle • Hang in there and keep hanging in there

More Related